Re:Show HN: Whatdoesthiscodedo.com – AI explanations for oth...
by siva7 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:40AM
(#35164346)
I don't understand how people often assume you need to struggle in order to acquire knowledge. Maybe you don't?
Re:Show HN: Whatdoesthiscodedo.com – AI explanations for oth...
by throwaway675309 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:50AM
(#35164401)
There's a difference between acquiring knowledge and acquiring understanding.
And there's lots of research to support the idea that working through concepts on your own helps aid in long-term retention.
Re:Show HN: Whatdoesthiscodedo.com – AI explanations for oth...
by colmvp on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:48AM
(#35164759)
Yeah I'm not sure why that's controversial.
I have a plethora of books on programming languages. Know what helped me learn it the most? Solving small bugs on open source projects.
If I told an AI to code the solution in the language of choice, I would solve the problem but not truly comprehend the subtleties of why the decision was made. Even when it tells me why it did something, I guarantee you I'd forget about it in a few hours if not by the following day.
An AI doing a code review is one thing I could say would've helped me, but an AI solving the problem I think would've stunted my growth.
Re:Show HN: Whatdoesthiscodedo.com – AI explanations for oth...
by justusw on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:19AM
(#35165329)
That is the better half of a comp-sci or mathematics degree.
Re:Show HN: Whatdoesthiscodedo.com – AI explanations for oth...
by logarhythmic on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:31AM
(#35169856)
If you mean acquiring facts, maybe not. If you mean getting better at a skill such as programming or playing the piano, how could you possibly get better without challenging yourself?
Developers should review and learn from each others’ code, that’s how you progress. Even as a senior, I’m still happy when I read code written by juniors because everyone learns.
I’m also confused by this hype. I tried a 2-lines sample of very basic C++ code, and the tool gave me: 1/3 obvious explanation, 1/3 wrong, and 1/3 right. So, it’s at most 66% right but not useful to me.
I guess it’s meant for non-developers, or for a quick summary if you’re stuck in your tasks. But overall it’s way too basic to be useful at the moment.
I’ll sound like a Luddite but you don’t learn anything from those tools: no struggling (which is IMHO essential to acquire knowledge), no searching, nothing that you’ll remember. I’m confused on who the target audience really is.