News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:53PM (#35161399)
But you need 5x as much wind and solar because you will have to store it in the form of hydrogen for 50-80% loss in round-trip back to electricity

There will never be enough batteries and hydro storage in the world.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by sunshinesnacks on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:43PM (#35162575)
> There will never be enough batteries and hydro storage in the world.

Do you have a source to back that up? An amount of storage that would be needed and what it isn't reachable?

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by pfdietz on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:02PM (#35162747)
The levelized cost of wind/solar/storage will likely still end up cheaper, even for the use case of providing synthesized baseload power.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by ianburrell on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:25PM (#35162935)
For 5x wind and solar, you don’t need long term storage. Just short term storage for time shifting. It is fine to use gas leaker plants in emergencies and use the extra capacity to pump the carbon out of the air. Hydrogen would also work welll for few times it is needed.

Also, nuclear is so slow to build that we don’t know what storage will look like in the future. Nuclear is impeding against the unknown storage tech in 15 years.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by pasttense01 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:35AM (#35163922)
In Minnesota solar produces three times as much electricity in the longest days of summer than in the shortest days of winter. So either you need massive overcapacity or lots of long term storage or a massive expansive expansion of the electric grid [which Nimbys will oppose]--and probably all three.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by pfdietz on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @08:27AM (#35167205)
Or wind, which is somewhat anticorrelated with solar.

Also, the PV can be arranged at an angle that maximizes production in winter rather than total annual production. This has the added benefit of allowing some sun to hit the ground in summer, so something can be grown there.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by ianburrell on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:30AM (#35169845)
The point is that renewables are cheap enough that can build overcapacity for same price as nuclear capacity. Overcapacity is an advantage since there can be dispatchable users of the free power. We will need to pull carbon from air, make hydrogen, and make carbon fuel. Those could turn out to be long term storage.

Also, we shouldn’t think of power regionally. Minnesota is good at wind, Arizona is good at solar, California and Texas are good at solar and wind. This will require more transmission lines but those are affordable compared to alternatives. We would need more transmission lines in all nuclear world.