News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by scrlk on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:57PM (#35160449)
Is it still a 1/5th of the cost if you have to factor in storage?
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by ianburrell on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:24PM (#35160941)
We are approaching the prices where storage is almost as cheap as nuclear power.

More importantly, we don't need to worry about storage now. Gas peaker plants will work until we get rid of all the other fossil fuel power plants. Then, storage should be cheaper since will know how to scale it. There is difference between short-term and long-term storage.

Finally, one solution to storage problem is build more supply. Three times will cover nearly every situation, and we will need extra power for doing hydrogen, carbon removal, and fuel generation. It is possible we won't need long-term storage and can use hydrogen or fuel.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by rayiner on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:31PM (#35161062)
Okay but what’s the amortized cost of building triple the supply? The chart you linked to only talks about marginal cost.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by ianburrell on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:51PM (#35161370)
I don’t think amortized cost matters. The research and development has been done or is included in the unit cost.

Renewables have better unit economics than nuclear since fixed costs are spread over many, many more units. It sounds like better reactors need lots of research. More important is time, it takes ten years to build reactor while can order solar panels now. Probably can build a new solar panel plant and multiple solar installations in decade.

There does need to be economic incentive to over build. Someone, probably the government, will need to pay for carbon capture. May need to encourage hard-to-electrify industries to switch. But we have a while until that happens.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:14PM (#35160786)
Yes. Battery backed solar and wind is still cheaper than nuclear, and mostly cheaper than coal and natural gas in many markets. For seasonality, you can use buried HVDC transmission (which is fairly efficient at moving large amounts of energy vast distances). China moves more power further with HVDC than the US would have to. Burying it gets around NIMBYs and other land issues that slow this infra down.

Commercial nuclear is just ridiculously expensive for the capacity factor and energy produced. It’s not entirely without use, but best suited for where there are no other options (the Arctic, Antarctica, etc). It’s likely cheaper to burn natural gas for the last ~5% of generation needed when the grid is mostly zero carbon in a decade (based on renewables and battery storage ramp rates) and then suck that CO2 into the ground with excess renewables (that otherwise would’ve been curtailed) versus continuing to try to build nuclear (although I haven’t done the math).

https://reneweconomy.com.au/nuclear-inquiry-told-firmed-rene...

https://www.lazard.com/media/451881/lazards-levelized-cost-o...

https://spectrum.ieee.org/chinas-state-grid-corp-crushes-pow...

https://www.power-technology.com/features/chinas-mega-transm...

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by Gwypaas on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:02PM (#35160522)
No need to factor in storage when creating synthetic fuels like the GP suggests.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by loeg on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:24PM (#35160944)
You would instead need to factor in the inefficiencies of creating and burning those fuels.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by pydry on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:04PM (#35160558)
If you synthesize windgas and burn that for electricity (which is probably the most expensive, inefficient way to store and use that energy) it's still about 4/5ths the cost of nuclear power.

If you combined pumped storage and batteries with solar and wind it's roughly between 2/5ths and 3/5ths.

This ignores taxpayer shouldered insurance for nuclear power. If you price that accurately the cost of nuclear power balloons still further.

It's never been particularly cost effective but compared to dirt cheap renewables it's a veritable financial black hole. This is why EDF is currently imploding. It's why only countries that have nukes or really want the option to have nukes build civilian nuclear power plants.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by akvadrako on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:38PM (#35161161)
windgas? That's not a word I've ever heard or sound like a well established source of energy.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by pydry on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:42PM (#35161214)
coz it doesnt make economic sense to do it until A) wind and solar energy is routinely producing a lot more energy than can be currently used and stored cheaply B) pumping natural gas becomes prohibited or prohibitively expensive.