People in the Bay Area seem to live in buzzword land.
> Ruined housing market & transit systems, wagged war on labor law, accelerated the militarization of public space & the border, and intensified gambling.
https://twitter.com/bigblackjacobin/status/16353042104211496...
But sure, corporate social responsibility is a concept that has long predated the current ESG trend. We once had a society that at least paid lip service to noblesse oblige.
It's important to understand that noblesse oblige was transactional: it staved off the masses from revolting and even generated some good. When charity puts a target on your back, folks won't engage in charity.
They don't fear scolds; they fear pitchforks and, more realistically, _taxes_. You can call it cowardice but it's entirely rational.