Several said that if SVB didn't get 100% depositor coverage that they would assume any regional bank could fail, and thus everyone should move to something safe like JP Morgan. By the time they started to say this publicly they already instructed portfolio companies move out of regional banks. Many were in the process of doing so.
The Fed / FDIC can see this happening and now are over a barrel. So the VCs managed to start one run, then jump up and down yelling to be saved OR ELSE we are going to actively start a series of runs by undermining trust. It's super cynical, and basically allowed the banking system to be held hostage.
Now I am not someone who thinks there shouldn't be some kind of action to help out depositors. For me the biggest issue is cash flow, and if uninsured depositors can be helped very quickly to make sure their businesses don't fail (because they can, SVB has the assets) then the government should make that happen. But somehow that wasn't good enough for the VCs. They yelled that its 100% secured deposits or nothing. And it's really uncomfortable that we allow them to have that kind of leverage.
You have to wonder if any financial authority will step in order to investigate this. After all screaming "fire!" in a crowded theatre should be punishable, especially if you end up financially profiting from said action of screaming.
That's the risk you run investing in a bank. Better this than the 2008 bailouts when the banks ran themselves into the ground for profit and were still made whole. And, better this than spooking the entire financial system by not protecting deposits.
If everyone was talking to each other, and they’re so smart and rational, why didn’t they decide to have everyone take out a small amount to cover essentials like payroll? Was it maybe… greed? Lack of ingenuity? To be fair, bank runs do happen, but everyone who caused this one was in a big old group chat and they could have prevented it, and nobody had the idea.
If it was so rational, why did they continue to demand a bailout even after it became clear the FDIC would get them nearly 100% back? Was it maybe… greed? God forbid that anyone lose even a few cents of uninsured deposits. What happened to paying for extra insurance? Now they complain about contagion to get a bailout, contagion which they began and continued.
I am talking about the period just prior to when the bank ceases normal operation, when everyone is panicking and deciding whether to withdraw everything. People in bank runs are judging the behaviour of other participants. If you think everyone else is going to do that, then yes, it’s rational to do that ASAP. If you have all day to talk about it, and everyone relevant is in the room, then if possible you don’t do that. Because bank runs are bad! You might try to soften the blow, even out the damage, ensure nobody’s left behind, and then get the bank to go down gracefully. The people here acted as if they thought the bank run would go on until all the money was drained, or worse, as if bankruptcy meant getting pennies on the dollar. Of course that wasn’t going to happen. Maybe 20% got out, which amplified losses slightly by the slower reactors. Was a few percent worth causing a panic and threatening a larger one? No!
But no, it had to be run run run, full speed, and then threaten the government with more panic if they didn’t bail it out. This path is greedy and needy, and it will not make big tech any less of a pariah in the American psyche.
People hate this when I say it but ideology makes you a dummy. And that's what they were being because of their paranoid libertarian ideology.
Have you considered that rational decision may actually be a rational decision?
As in, something is actually wrong there, with the way banking is done?
It seems your thinking stops at "Rational actors would expose a problem with the current style of banking. Therefore, stop rational actors from acting, in order to PROP UP that same style of banking."
The moral hazard is real. People who point to it are simply one step ahead of you in how such actions necessarily pan out over time, not "missing the point by a mile".
Are they talking about short sellers talking up the bank run, or just companies that withdrew funds so they could pay their employees?
> These billionaire VC's started a bank run on their own bank and then immediately pivoted to screaming for a government backstop. Incredible stuff.
> It's really not even clear SVB was in such terrible shape on the merits. Was def squeezed, for sure, but really looks like their little group chat knocked it over!
https://twitter.com/chrislhayes/status/1635136751516938240