News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silicon Valley Bank Depositor Bailout Makes Mockery of ‘T... by makomk on Monday March 13, 2023 @06:18AM (#35133624)
You're right that without the bank run SVB probably wouldn't have collapsed on Friday and might well have held on for a few more weeks or months. That's not really enough though; in order for pulling your money early and parking it safer not to be the sensible choice everyone would need to know that it wouldn't collapse at all, and the best anyone's been able to offer is that it might have survived. There's this weird sentiment that it's all the fault of stupid Silicon Valley startup bros for not keeping their money in a bank that was flashing warning signs, and also that keeping large amount of money in a bank that's showing signs of failure is such a bad decision that making people and companies who do it whole causes moral hazard. You really cannot have both those things at once.
Re:Silicon Valley Bank Depositor Bailout Makes Mockery of ‘T... by cormacrelf on Monday March 13, 2023 @06:37AM (#35133781)
If the bank is being mismanaged, it should still collapse. The FDIC steps in, bankruptcy courts are really good at distributing funds, the bank dies and it’s operators suffer reputational damage, and everyone learns a bit about banks, insurance premiums get adjusted and life goes on. If the bank was so bad at its job, then this should happen. It could even have happened on Friday, if people came to an agreement and got enough money to survive out before accelerating withdrawals.

I am talking about the period just prior to when the bank ceases normal operation, when everyone is panicking and deciding whether to withdraw everything. People in bank runs are judging the behaviour of other participants. If you think everyone else is going to do that, then yes, it’s rational to do that ASAP. If you have all day to talk about it, and everyone relevant is in the room, then if possible you don’t do that. Because bank runs are bad! You might try to soften the blow, even out the damage, ensure nobody’s left behind, and then get the bank to go down gracefully. The people here acted as if they thought the bank run would go on until all the money was drained, or worse, as if bankruptcy meant getting pennies on the dollar. Of course that wasn’t going to happen. Maybe 20% got out, which amplified losses slightly by the slower reactors. Was a few percent worth causing a panic and threatening a larger one? No!

But no, it had to be run run run, full speed, and then threaten the government with more panic if they didn’t bail it out. This path is greedy and needy, and it will not make big tech any less of a pariah in the American psyche.