Re:Joint Statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federa...
by loeg on Sunday March 12, 2023 @06:50PM
(#35127492)
Banks use deposits to extend loans to other customers. A narrow bank wouldn't do that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Joint Statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federa...
by selimnairb on Sunday March 12, 2023 @06:53PM
(#35127556)
Couldn’t the Fed just offer retail loans at the Federal Reserver rate, with maybe some kind of premium if inflation is high, or discount if inflation is low? What am I missing? Why do we need all these banks, some of which catastrophically explode every decade or so?
Re:Joint Statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federa...
by loeg on Sunday March 12, 2023 @07:01PM
(#35127677)
I mean, you would be substantially increasing the size of government. The federal government currently employs about 3 million workers. The banking sector employs 1.4 million. To perform similar functions, the US government would need (at least) a similar number of employees. That is probably politically disagreeable.
Re:Joint Statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federa...
by selimnairb on Sunday March 12, 2023 @07:48PM
(#35128352)
They would be employees of the Fed, not the Federal Government, no? Also, I am not afraid of a big government so there’s that. Also, they would be paid well, but not get insane bonuses, etc. so that’s a distributive plus in my book (i.e., less wealth concentrated in a tumescent financial sector).
Re:Joint Statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federa...
by scrlk on Sunday March 12, 2023 @07:01PM
(#35127670)
> Banks use deposits to extend loans to other customers
"Money creation in the modern economy" from the Bank of England is worth a read - it explains why this isn't the case.
https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/quarterly-bulletin/2014/q1/m...
Re:Joint Statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federa...
by pgwhalen on Sunday March 12, 2023 @07:14PM
(#35127895)
This is nitpicking. While that paper is a good read and important to understand how banking works, the parent commenter's point about how money creation works, and how a narrow bank would not participate in it, is valid. Deposits _are_ a source of funding that a bank considers when making loans, even if a bank does not "turn deposits into loans."
Re:Joint Statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federa...
by lbsnake7 on Sunday March 12, 2023 @08:50PM
(#35129006)
I have been reading about this topic recently and still don't really understand how 'new money' is being created. In a loan, the bank creates an IOU that didn't exist before and doesn't point to a stack of $$ on the shelf. But it does point to the bank, and the bank itself has tons of customer deposits. And if I take that IOU and give it to a car dealership who puts it in their bank, for the transfer my bank will take actual money from the general pool of customer deposits. AND I have to pay back the loan which goes into the general pool. So while specific money isn't earmarked, the IOU represents money that the bank has right?
I guess a way to ask the question would be: if i were to liquidate all assets of a bank and call in every loan, would that be >= all customer deposits?
Re:Joint Statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federa...
by rashkov on Sunday March 12, 2023 @11:12PM
(#35130510)
Also been thinking about this. If you look at this article, read section titled “money creation process” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking
If I deposit $5 in my bank account, and then the bank keeps $1 in reserve and lends out $4, then they just added $4 to the money supply. I can withdraw my $5, and the loan-taker can withdraw their $4. This is possible because there’s a reserve pool of money which is not loaned out, and because people tend to just leave the money in their account.
At least that’s my understanding. Happy to be corrected