News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Saving 4M Books from Landfill – Internet Archive Blogs by pengaru on Saturday March 11, 2023 @12:03AM (#35105551)
Kudos for your efforts to preserve and upload your picks to archive.org.

It's such a bummer that public libraries won't have these physical objects on shelves in a discoverable form and place, where people can just stumble upon and page through them.

I've picked through a couple public library "removed from circulation sales" and always find at least one gem there's no obvious good cause for removal. It's hard to not become a hoarder in such situations.

Already brought two such finds home: Bombs Over Bikini [0] and Alaska Crude [1]. They're tiny, and dense with historically relevant photographs. It seems strange to remove them, I suspect it's partly because their contents are dark/depressing/embarrassing to the nation in hindsight. But that's arguably their value IMHO.

[0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/18354016-bombs-over-biki...

[1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25135337-alaska-crude

Re:Saving 4M Books from Landfill – Internet Archive Blogs by fock on Saturday March 11, 2023 @02:55AM (#35106388)
the public library around my childhood town just put them on a shelf. They had fun 1950s radio equipment manuals (and a Landau-Lifshitz iirc!) but those were gone when I last stopped by.
Re:Saving 4M Books from Landfill – Internet Archive Blogs by pbronez on Saturday March 11, 2023 @07:32AM (#35107767)
Librarians are very thoughtful about what gets shelf space. They curate their collections with many different factors in mind. They refer to this process as “collection development”.

https://www.librarieslearn.org/self-paced-courses/collection...

Re:Saving 4M Books from Landfill – Internet Archive Blogs by Amezarak on Sunday March 12, 2023 @07:22AM (#35118835)
Whatever the ideal is, the reality is that everything old is pulped to make room for the latest political fare and romance novels, especially if it’s not been checked out lately. An ideological criterion is applied on top of this.

God only knows how many works have been consigned to permanent oblivion because they were only of local or niche interest, when even notorious classical works that were read for a thousand years are no longer available in many library systems without ILL. (And sometimes not even then.)

Modern libraries are for entertainment, not education, with few exceptions.

Aside: do not donate books to the library unless you do not care what happens to them. If the library cannot sell them they will be pulped. They are almost never added to collections.

Aside2: for some reason rescuing library books from dumpsters is considered theft by some librarians, so be careful.

Re:Saving 4M Books from Landfill – Internet Archive Blogs by pengaru on Sunday March 12, 2023 @06:15PM (#35127001)
Librarians are biased like everyone else, it's reflected in the books retained.

It's quite apparent when I've explored libraries in small towns on cross-country road-trips. Ideological influence for sure.