However, what would realistically happen in a hypothetical world without copyright, is that commercial organizations will stop most OSS development and revert to distributing obfuscated binaries.
That same copyright law protects my photographs. I am generally in favor of strong copyright laws.
There are also philosophies of software licensing that want to ensure that the user can have access to the code that uses my code. Under those philosophies, it is the protections granted by the limited right to prepare derivative works that allow that licensing to have teeth and enforce a copy left.
Without copyright, the GPL and corresponding licensing that is written with the desire to be able to guarantee the 2nd and 4th freedoms (access to the source for some product and ability to modify the code for that product) have no teeth and those cannot be guaranteed.
With no copyright law I could take any GPL software, modify it, sell it as my own and nobody could force me to give up the code.
If copyleft means permissive (MIT) - then it's not a hostile environment. You are free to create and share permissive works with no hostility from anyone else.
Clout, reputation, group identity, coolness factor. It's similar to how demoscene operates.
Considering that the demoscene spun off the cracking scene...
It's a ridiculous position. Especially given the hypocrisy in supporting copyleft, which lets people distribute works gratis with heavy restrictions, and ripping off other peoples work who didn't want any part of that, while getting mad that people aren't following the copyleft restrictions.
But sometimes I still try to do things I can't - I currently have a broken wrist.
>The bottom line, what I did violated the laws governing copyrights. I don't agree with those laws 100%, but they were designed by people with lots of money in their pockets to keep lots of money in their pockets, so I doubt they're going to change for the better any time soon. This is why I'm a huge advocate for the open source community.
I understood that to mean "the open source community specifically addresses the flaws in a system that it cannot itself abolish, so I support them".
Copyright law protects the smallest against the biggest. If some company comes and steals my product and outspends me on marketing, how do I fight back without copyright law?
Say someone stole the book I wrote and passed it off as their own - how does open sourcing it help me?
The chief purpose of the DMCA was to clarify legal liability and penalties for digital copyright infringement brought on by the disruption of the internet. How does that keep anyone rich? Who is that taking money from? Who is made poorer because people are able to create and sell their own works in the manner of their choosing?
Because they have more nuanced thoughts that you think ?
"A copyright law" is not a one thing.
DMCA doesn't touch OSS software for example. It could entirely go away.
Length of copyright protection could be 5 years from creation instead of 70y from authors death and it would do near jack squat to OSS software. Ye you could use 5y worth of unfixed bugs and ignore OSS license but that wouldn't exactly hurt most projects.
As for the "people that actually write software", I couldn't care less. It's been shown over and over that piracy never made the effect on thier bottom line that large software companies led many to believe. Simply put, people didn't buy these things because they considered them overpriced luxuries for simple hobbyists. The only choice was to pirate the software, or to never get to use it. As someone who writes software myself, I have no sympathy for people who want harsh punishments for someone who steals their stupid little program. Sure you put hard work into it, but so did a lot of people who offer their software for free. Generally, my thought is that these people are more upset that their software failed to make the impact that they thought it would or failed to generate the profit that they had dreamed of. Piracy was never at fault for either of those. They need to cope
I don't care how much work I put into it, I don't care how much money its worth. I don't care about its impact.
I create because it's mine and I control it. The hands that built it decide what happens to it.
I could paint the prettiest picture and then burn it forever and nobody has any right to stop me, no matter how many poor hobbiest art admirers wanted to see it.
Copyleft is a hack that turns monopoly inside-out. All for one, and one for all.
Without copyright, copyleft would be fundamentally broken. But that isn't the whole picture: anything under a permissive license like MIT or Apache2 would see the same result they implement today. Those are part of "open source", too.
And we could certainly come up with a different system to maintain copyleft: we could make regulation that preserves a user's right to edit their software, and bans practices like DRM and intentional incompatibility. That's what I imagine the "open source movement" would look like if it were brought to an extreme logical conclusion.
more restrictions on the road to copyright freedom
if restricting what people are allowed to do with software is bad, why does that make it acceptable to create more restirctions on what people can do with software.
once we have 1,000 pages of restrictions closing all the interop and drm loopholes - our software will truely be free
There are quite very different open-source licenses. Copyleft licenses do depends on copyright, that is true. On the other hand, typical non-copyleft licenses are in my opinion much less dependent on copyright.
A world without copyright does in my opinion not correspond to any open-source license that I am aware of: you are allowed to reverse-engineer and distribute any software that you want and you must not forbid this to any person using your software or any work derived from it, but nobody is obliged to provide any source code.
In my personal opinion such a license is a gap in the "market of open source licenses", so if some reader feels inspired to create such an open-source license, I utterly encourage the respective reader to do so.
If hes an anarchist then fine, but it looks like he wants laws that benefit him and not people that actually write software.
I read the whole thing and I still don't know why he did it. He says there was no money incentive and his work had no impact on piracy. What was its purpose then?