News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by buildbot on Friday March 10, 2023 @02:40PM (#35099739)
This was an interesting article until it started praising musk for slashing half of twitter - I don’t think the HR and legal departments were doing fake work, and the current lack of stability seems to indicate that a good portion of those people layed off where actually important.
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by GVIrish on Friday March 10, 2023 @02:43PM (#35099804)
The fact that Twitter had to ask some of the people it laid off to come back shortly after having fired them says it all about how incompetent and self-defeating those layoffs were.
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by Jensson on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:12PM (#35100225)
If they asked most of the fired people to come back you would have a point, but they just asked a small fraction of the fired people to come back. That doesn't seem unreasonable, you will make errors and it is good to admit when you made an error.

Would you think the whole ordeal was done better if they just refused to admit that any of the firings were in error? Nobody makes no mistakes when firing. There are many issues with the Twitter firings, but asking some of them to come back isn't a negative sign at all.

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by buildbot on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:41PM (#35100685)
No that is in my opinion, still insane. Laying someone off and then being like, "oops, you were actually important", is indicative they have no clue. Maybe they could have waited a bit to figure shit out instead of scorch-earthing everything.
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by jrootabega on Friday March 10, 2023 @04:01PM (#35100986)
Maybe. Maybe once those plans were noticed, they would have been resisted and thwarted by people who wanted to retain their power within the organization. Political struggles happen even in "healthy" companies.
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by simplotek on Friday March 10, 2023 @06:14PM (#35102625)
> Maybe once those plans were noticed, they would have been resisted and thwarted by people who wanted to retain their power within the organization.

I'm perplexed by the mental gymnastics you had to resort to to try to deflect any responsibility from Musk, let alone the despair to omit any reference to the extremely poor judgement and outright incompetence it takes to pull this sort of stunt, and instead fabricate this theory where this impulsive shot in the foot was actually a brilliant plan to thwart entrenched interests.

Occam's razor and Musk's track record reject this hypothesis. Musk f-ed up, just like he keeps on f-ing up, like the recent shit fest of Musk posting a stream of brain dead and profoundly I'll advised tweets trying to publicly smear a employee with disabilities.

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by jrootabega on Friday March 10, 2023 @07:05PM (#35103203)
You're really worked up about the simply proposed possibility of how someone might (MIGHT) go about firing a lot of people, especially in an organization already hostile to new ownership. It seems like you need a devil figure to channel anger against, rather than someone who does some stupid stuff and maybe some not so stupid stuff.
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by 908B64B197 on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:50PM (#35100824)
> but they just asked a small fraction of the fired people to come back.

That we know of (meaning they posted publicly about it). The real number could be way higher.

> but asking some of them to come back isn't a negative sign at all.

It's a very negative sign, especially at the scale it happened (as I said, we know about the cases where the person accepted to go back or publicly stated they were offered to come back).

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by GVIrish on Friday March 10, 2023 @05:08PM (#35101879)
If you fire people hastily but then are forced to ask them to come back because you discovered they were actually key personnel, that speaks to incompetence. The speed of Twitter's layoffs were completely under the control of Musk. There was no crisis or external factor that made them cut people so quickly.

Mistakes certainly can happen, but they're much more likely to happy when things are done chaotically without proper planning.

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by beebmam on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:01PM (#35100081)
The truth about the Twitter layoffs is that the company is not even remotely profitable and likely never will be, so it doesn't really matter that much as long as the company barely continues to operate. You can certainly barely operate a web services company with a barebones crew: we all do it every year during the holidays! But long term growth? Yeah, good luck with that.

Twitter is now just nice yacht for a billionaire. The acquisition was no different than Ron Watkins buying 8chan.

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by sidfthec on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:06PM (#35100142)
Twitter lost 200mil on 5b in revenue in 2021 and has had a handful of profitable quarters in recent history. Not sure why you think it's "not even remotely profitable and likely never will be".

Of course, that's a pre-Elon analysis. Elon's loans alone add 1 bil/year in interest costs, and reports say there's been a large drop in revenue since his purchase.

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by spicybright on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:10PM (#35100203)
That's actually a good point. I bet it helps as a marking tool for his future investments too.

"He owns twitter, of course he knows what he's doing!"

"He owns a Lambo, of course he knows what he's doing!"

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by 908B64B197 on Friday March 10, 2023 @04:15PM (#35101178)
> The truth about the Twitter layoffs is that the company is not even remotely profitable and likely never will be, so it doesn't really matter that much as long as the company barely continues to operate.

But it was profitable at certain times. Despite all the reported "bloat". Ironically now, it has little hopes of being profitable thanks to advertisers pulling out due to lax moderation (some of the automated stuff no longer working because the maintainers are gone!). So even if they managed to run the site with a skeleton crew, assuming they keep breaking non-essential features, it's unclear they could ever become profitable again.

There seems to be this echo chamber around the Twitter acquisition that thinks most software companies are bloated and that software engineers basically do nothing. They seem to believe Twitter will make that demonstration. It's particularly pervasive in semi or non-technical circles. I guess it's the same crowd that bought into no-code and low-code tools to "get rid of expensive developers" for the last decade.

While Twitter hasn't suffered any complete outage as of yet, several products and features seem to be broken, as well as a good chunk of their API (I don't buy the claim it's intentional because the latencies and error rates have been jumping up). To be completely honest, this level of service degradation would have killed more serious products. It's fine for Twitter because there's no SLA, no enterprise customers and no critical infra running on it.

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by GVIrish on Friday March 10, 2023 @05:11PM (#35101913)
Twitter actually had some profitable years lately and in the last 5 years before Musk bought it they recorded a net profit. Revenue had been grown 60% over that time.

But now with Twitter reportedly losing 40% of its advertisers and taking on $1 billion of annual debt servicing costs, it seems unlikely they'll be able to get back to profitable if things keep going this way.

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by TurkishPoptart on Friday March 10, 2023 @02:49PM (#35099897)
IMO Twitter has been 100% better since Musk took over.
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by csb6 on Friday March 10, 2023 @02:54PM (#35099970)
Really? Since the sale I’ve seen lots more bugs (e.g. replies failing to load, like button not working, images not loading, menus not working, Tweets not loading, etc.)
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by ericmay on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:00PM (#35100065)
What differences have you noticed? The main one I see is that there are more blue check marks but now I have kind of trained myself to ignore those more and just pay attention if it’s gray/gold or an official org page.
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by throw_pm23 on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:07PM (#35100158)
As someone without an account, I am finally able to browse and read it.

In the last months before he took over it had become literally unusable. After some seconds of scrolling a sign-up window would show up which was impossible to dismiss and neither ublock nor umatrix helped.

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by illiarian on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:20PM (#35100361)
That's the only good thing that happened.

Meanwhile:

- failures are happening more often. Just in the past week they broke "following" page for half a day, and then image uploads for a few hours (with hilarious "your account has hit the API limit for their own site)

- they just randomly killed third-party apps that made Twitter what it was with zero warning or explanation

- destroyed all possible credibility of blue checkmarks. Which are not just celebrities, but also government agencies

- people report an increase in harassment and trolls

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by ackfoobar on Friday March 10, 2023 @06:46PM (#35102993)
Some outages for increased velocity can be a good trade off for twitter.

I think the acquisition is partly idelogically motivated. So destroying the blue checkmark credibility is probably "mischief managed".

For government accounts, they now have gray checkmarks.

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by illiarian on Friday March 10, 2023 @10:28PM (#35104914)
> Some outages for increased velocity can be a good trade off for twitter.

What increased velocity?

> So destroying the blue checkmark credibility is probably "mischief managed".

This statement makes no sense

> For government accounts, they now have gray checkmarks.

Wat?

Is this the velocity you're talking about? When they introduced paid blue checkmarks, then realized it's a bad idea, and introduced "official" label to only backpedal less than a day later, only to introduce gray checkmarks? First time I hear of gray checkmarks btw.

Just checked: of course there are now gray checkmarks. And of course they are randomly assigned. And of course there are also golden checkmarks because reasons. Also randomly assigned.

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by CatWChainsaw on Saturday March 11, 2023 @06:12PM (#35113768)
I used uMatrix to read Twitter without difficulty. Did you have most of the scripts blocked?
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by smrtinsert on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:00PM (#35100050)
Please qualify that. The public has observed failures in infrastructure and content safety/moderation.
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by OnlineGladiator on Friday March 10, 2023 @02:53PM (#35099957)
Why?
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by hstan4 on Friday March 10, 2023 @06:16PM (#35102648)
I love how this comment is flagged solely for having an unfavorable opinion to most here. Good job HN
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by Someone1234 on Friday March 10, 2023 @02:53PM (#35099963)
Stuff reductions for changes in priorities/direction is normally fine, I think the problem Musk's Twitter had is they cut far too fast, far too quick, with seemingly a balance sheet at the forefront.

It is the whole "Learn WHY things are how they are, before you suggest changing them" which all new engineers need to learn, also seemingly applies to restructuring. If they had waited a couple of months, they could have made strategically smart changes, and over the long term it likely won't cost them more.

Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by zamnos on Friday March 10, 2023 @02:58PM (#35100022)
The term for that is Chesterton's Fence: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton%27s_fence
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by flappyeagle on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:17PM (#35100318)
Musk stressed the hell out of twitter. His technique and demeanor were total trash. They probably fired the wrong people in many situations. But he did prove that they were overhired by 50% or more.
Re:Google, Meta hired talent to do 'fake work' by cathdrlbizzare on Friday March 10, 2023 @08:50PM (#35104238)
Departments aren’t a hive mind. Individuals do work.