News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letter to Pixar President Ed Catmull [pdf] by bhouston on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:03AM (#35081240)
A similar thing happened to me on a smaller scale in the VFX industry. At my first job out of university, I had the idea of creating a render farm manager, pushed for it internally, wrote most of it and launched it as a product and did the first sales of it. I then left the company to start my own company. CEO then proceeded to completely erase me from history. The product became widely successful and was eventually purchased by Amazon.

Early Deadline PR features me prominently everywhere: https://web.archive.org/web/20050518071754/http://software.f...

Recent article on the "history" of Deadline where I do not exist, which is par for the course: https://www.fxguide.com/quicktakes/aws-thinkbox-deadline-a-b...

The lesson I took from this is that you can not expect other people to tell your story. They will tell their story, because telling your story is not in their interests, especially if you left their company. You yourself are responsible for telling your own story and getting it out into the world.

Re:Letter to Pixar President Ed Catmull [pdf] by steve1977 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:38AM (#35081606)
You have been Musk‘ed. Or Edison‘ed.
Re:Letter to Pixar President Ed Catmull [pdf] by antegamisou on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:21AM (#35081415)
This comment and the rest of the thread is hopefully a short wake-up call to all those entrepreneurs’ cock-suckers who think they’re the ones behind every innovation they’re falsely claiming credit for. (Although what happened between Ed and ARS is a bit different story.)
Re:Letter to Pixar President Ed Catmull [pdf] by rsgalloway on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:50PM (#35084218)
wow, sorry this happened to you Ben. sounds like you took away a good lesson from it though, if nothing else. and I had no idea you created Deadline, that's awesome!
Re:Letter to Pixar President Ed Catmull [pdf] by bhouston on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:11PM (#35086774)
Long time no chat! I remember you from the Alembic project (I was selling Exocortex Crate, which was based on Alembic) and also you were a supporter of Clara.io (which has become https://threekit.com) back in the day.
Re:Letter to Pixar President Ed Catmull [pdf] by buffington on Thursday March 09, 2023 @03:30PM (#35086252)
I've been a co-founder of 2 startups, and have been the first employee of several others. In every single case, after moving on to the next one, I had to take steps to remind people at those companies that I had a role in their founding and that erasing my name from their history wasn't acceptable.

When a co-founder leaves, I think there's a tendency to believe that an origin story where a co-founder leaves somehow reflects poorly on the company. A clean story broadcasts "stability" or "competence" or whatever. Origin stories where someone leaves bring up questions. Or at least I assume that's the thinking.

Whatever the motivation, it's insulting, and can actually be damaging to the person being erased from the story.

On one occasion a company I'd co-founded found ourselves in the awkward position of having a major partner of ours pull out of a deal we were putting together. During their due diligence they found no evidence of my involvement in a previous company, despite our claims of my involvement. It took a lawyer to compel the owners of the company I'd co-founded (and which had been sold by then), that I indeed co-founded it and still owned 10% of (though not really - those shares were converted to the equivalent value of shares in acquiring company, but you get the idea). The deal was saved, but only after a lot of tedious back and forth between legal teams of all those involved.

Part of the problem is that it's not just the company changing its origin story, but it's all the Crunchbase's reflecting that incorrect story. People use these resources as "truth," and that can be difficult or impossible to set straight.

Every startup has an origin story, and very few are "clean." I think the better origin stories are the ones that demonstrate that despite the friction all startups face, the friction wasn't enough to stop a company from becoming what it becomes.

If you're in a startup: own your truth. Show your flaws. Be authentic. When I see a "perfect" origin story, I know it's bullshit, and I won't trust you, let alone be an angel investor or advisor. I know I'm not alone in thinking that.

Re:Letter to Pixar President Ed Catmull [pdf] by Keyframe on Friday March 10, 2023 @12:05PM (#35097290)
Have you reached out to fxguide guys? They do not seem as someone to perpetuate bullshit, but maybe I'm wrong.