https://libcom.org/article/phenomenon-bullshit-jobs-david-gr...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs
> Who's going to take care of sick people? Who's going to maintain our infrastructure? Who's going to police people? Who's going to defend our country from war? Who's going to make sure your cellphone still works? Who's going to make sure your house still has electricity? Who's going to make sure the laws are being followed? Who's going to make new entertainment for you?
You simply seem uninformed. My english is not so good to be persuasive enough, somebody please help me.
Basic income doesn't mean all people will stop working. Jobs would still exist, and people would still choose to work, but for different reasons that they do now. They could do what they want, and stop anytime for any period of time, and start whenever they would feel like it.
We have voluntary firefighters now, don't we?
People just wouldn't have to choose job based on its capacity to provide sustenance for their family, but do what they love no matter the financials.
Many teachers now are leaving the profession (in the US), because they're unable to earn enough to sustain their living expenses.
> Who's going to take care of sick people?
Do you think that doctors and nurses are in it for the money, and nothing else than money? No, they do it because they want to help people. I don't fully understand it, but it is so. And they would still be awarded for doing so.
> Who's going to police people?
Don't keep people in poverty, and you wouldn't need so many policemen and prisons. Do you know you're 1st in the world in this area too? And do you think there would not be anyone who would want to be police, without the necessity to earn a living?
> Who's going to defend our country from war?
You're an american, are you not? Are you people really that scared? With all the money and with bases in 3/4 of all countries of the world?
> Who's going to make new entertainment for you?
All those youtube attention seekers are not going anywhere.
With UBI, you will have to drive your trash to the nearest landfill yourself. And the car will barely work for lack of mechanics. And the road will barely function for lack of construction workers. And the landfill will just be a disordered rubbish tip, and not a proper facility. Because no one--and I mean no one--is working in garbage, grease, or tar when they can sit at home instead.
It's the purest idiocy anyone ever thought of.
And yeah, doctors and nurses are in it for the money. No one works in shit and puke for fun either.
It's a complicated topic, with many unknowns and many things that would have to change, but insisting that status quo is the best way to handle things ... that seems like blindness to me.
Not everyone is a cynical monster who would only ever do anything that benefitted themselves personally.
That's not the point. The point is what they are producing isn't contributing value to our lives, or actually creating negative value. Building highways looked very productive on paper in the 50's, but now we live in car dependent sprawl, and we continue to pay people to maintain that sprawl when we could have walkable cities that are human friendly.
I love it in the city, can't imagine living where you literally cannot walk anywhere - but most of those people out there like it or they wouldn't be out there.
So, no, the people maintaining those highways aren't doing nothing. Maybe they're doing nothing for you. Maybe you can argue you're subsidizing other people's lives. But you can't say that people maintaining highways are doing nothing or are net negative.
Our preferences, choices and decisions have ripple effects.
Maybe if we'd intentionally designed our society/environment differently, we wouldn't need so many highways, and so many people managing them.
Source?
I love that so many people are convinced everyone but them is doing nothing and somehow getting paid for it.
> Only 2% of population working in agriculture already produces food for 10+ billion people.
What's your point?
Who's going to take care of sick people? Who's going to educate our next generation? Who's going to maintain our infrastructure? Who's going to police people? Who's going to defend our country from war? Who's going to make sure your cellphone still works? Who's going to make sure your house still has electricity? Who's going to make sure the laws are being followed? Who's going to make new entertainment for you?
We need to do more than just have beans to eat.