News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by iskander on Monday March 06, 2023 @02:40PM (#35046518)
>This is fun to read and think about, but it's also important to keep in mind that this is very light on evidence and is basically fanfic.

Applicable to much of the rationalist AI risk discourse.

Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by GauntletWizard on Monday March 06, 2023 @02:42PM (#35046555)
LessWrong as a whole is basically Asimov's Robot's ERP.
Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by 93po on Monday March 06, 2023 @04:30PM (#35047899)
I hesitate to defend AI safety discourse, but I will say that philosophy in general is sort of fanficy, and AI safety is something I'd loosely associate with philosophy.
Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by dragonwriter on Monday March 06, 2023 @04:40PM (#35048042)
> > Applicable to much of the rationalist AI risk discourse

> I hesitate to defend AI safety discourse

The rationalist AI risk discourse is not the same thing as AI safety discourse, in any case; it’s a small corner of the larger whole.

Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by 93po on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @02:21AM (#35052545)
Interesting distinction I haven't heard before but it makes sense
Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by coldtea on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @11:52AM (#35057595)
Yeah, think for example of leftist (or libertarian for that matter) critique of risks from AI application.

Not "Roko Basilisk"-style crap, but things like encoding bias into systems then used for automated law enforcing, employee screening, etc.

Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by astrange on Monday March 06, 2023 @06:42PM (#35049509)
It's sort of philosophy reinvented by people who haven't read any, which is eg how they got the internet to say "steelmanning" and so not notice philosophy already had "reconstructing arguments" which is the same thing.
Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by PaulHoule on Monday March 06, 2023 @08:38PM (#35050395)
The thing you have to realize is this is a cult. Like Scientology they are always inventing new language that's designed to make insiders become incapable of communicating with outsiders.

Sequences is like Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health, something that ensures real critical thinkers don't feel welcome.

This article contains numerous features that conform to the style guide for lesswrong including: (1) spammy crossposting for SEO (even good sites like arstechnica and phys.org do this today), (2) trigger warnings ("more technical than usual"), (3) random bits of praise for the cult leader (now EY is a "literary critic" but he's going to be a war hero like L. Ron Hubbard one of these days.)

Apocalyptic talk like theirs is dangerous: it's the road to

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heaven%27s_Gate_(religious_gro...

I do appreciate the shout out to structuralism, maybe they have been reading what I've written. Structuralism was a fad that dated to when linguistics was pre-paradigmatic and people thought language was a model for everything else. After Chomsky developed a paradigm for linguistics that turned out to be a disappointment (could be applied to make languages like FORTRAN but couldn't be used to make computers understand language, privileged syntax at the expense of semantics, etc.) the remnants moved on to post-structuralism.

The spectacular success of ChatGPT and transformers in general (e.g. they work for vision too!) has made "language is all you need" seem a much more appealing viewpoint, certainly it is a paradigm which people can use to write a number of papers as well as hot takes, fanfics and other subacademic communications.

Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by ChadNauseam on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @07:10PM (#35063331)
Nice, but don’t you realize that HN is a cult too?

1) Paul Graham, the revered founder whose corpus of essays is widely read (and will surely make “real critical thinkers” feel unwelcome)

2) Dang, an enforcer who invisibly hides comments and chastising people for speaking in a way he dislikes

3) Trigger warnings (“this article has a paywall”)

VC talk like HN’s is dangerous: it’s the road to a system that has seen more human rights abuses than almost any other

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_capitalism

More seriously, LessWrong is not a cult by pretty much any measure and your comment doesn’t really provide any evidence to say otherwise

Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by hipmanbro on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:55PM (#35058597)
It's not the same in that you can steelman a position and come up with brand new arguments that are better than what the other side is saying. "Reconstructing" doesn't necessitate the strongest form of the other argument.
Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by astrange on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @05:20PM (#35062082)
I mean, that is what it's for. It's about making someone else's argument fit into your own system without misrepresenting it or making it unclear.

I suppose having "steelman" lets you relate it to "strawman" and "weakman" which can be an advantage, but knowing the existing term lets you read the existing literature.

Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by hipmanbro on Thursday March 16, 2023 @01:09PM (#35184910)
> making someone else's argument fit into your own system without misrepresenting it or making it unclear

I think this is where steelman is a superset of this, in that it includes the reconstruction definition but also includes making a whole new set of arguments that are entirely unrelated to your own argument or the other person's argument. i.e. Steelmanning can involve coming up with novel arguments for the other side.

Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by phillipcarter on Monday March 06, 2023 @07:26PM (#35049887)
Yep, by my estimation it's a bunch of people who don't actually study AI or have practical experience with it pontificating on black boxes they sometimes interact with. Sounds like they have a lot of free time.
Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by coldtea on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @12:16PM (#35058017)
Re:The Waluigi Effect: an explanation of bizarre semiotic ef... by coldtea on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @11:49AM (#35057544)
"rationalist"