Re:The Smallest Hash Table
by whatever1 on Monday March 06, 2023 @09:30AM
(#35041419)
Even for journal publications, the reviewers are anonymous. So really there is no reason to not just express your true opinion on a submission (as a reviewer). I have literally approved for publication dozens of submissions from unknown universities and non-affiliated contributors.
It is extremely hard to believe that the submission was not accepted BECAUSE of the lack of university affiliation.
But what is indeed true is that different conferences/journals have different expectations from a submission. Some prefer more theoretical analysis, others more computational work and benchmarking. And this is where a seasoned Professor offers value. They can judge where to submit a paper and have a high probability of success.
It is extremely hard to believe that the submission was not accepted BECAUSE of the lack of university affiliation.
But what is indeed true is that different conferences/journals have different expectations from a submission. Some prefer more theoretical analysis, others more computational work and benchmarking. And this is where a seasoned Professor offers value. They can judge where to submit a paper and have a high probability of success.