News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by jjcon on Sunday March 05, 2023 @05:12PM (#35034648)
I mean it 100% is ultimately discussion no matter how much one wants to shroud it in academic ivory tower BS.
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by SketchySeaBeast on Sunday March 05, 2023 @05:19PM (#35034728)
If we reduce it to an incredibly basic form, sure, in the same way that surgery is just ultimately stabbing with medical ivory tower BS.
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by jjcon on Sunday March 05, 2023 @06:31PM (#35035399)
If my surgeon had as much education as the average therapist does and surgery science had the replication crisis that therapy does I would call it exactly that: stabbing with medical ivory tower bs… thankfully that isn’t quite the case
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by comfypotato on Sunday March 05, 2023 @06:51PM (#35035581)
You’ve both labeled therapy as an ivory tower and implied therapists don’t have much education; that’s somewhat of a contradiction. What’s your purpose here?

I think a much better analogy than surgery would be a software bootcamp. In the same sense that a classroom-oriented bootcamp is just discussion, therapy is just discussion.

There’s no replication crisis for the greater umbrella question of whether or not therapy is effective. Therapy in combination with medication is provably more effective than either alone (or nothing).

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by jjcon on Sunday March 05, 2023 @10:46PM (#35037313)
> You’ve both labeled therapy as an ivory tower and implied therapists don’t have much education; that’s somewhat of a contradiction.

No contradiction - The problem isn't education obviously - its that some professions and disciplines are far more likely to produce pretentious ivory towers than others, that I have a problem with. Typically and ironically imo it is stronger in the soft sciences than the hard.

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by austinjp on Monday March 06, 2023 @03:31AM (#35038760)
Since you mention surgery as some sort of high-value comparator, surgical training favours people with some unpleasant personality traits [0] (apparently due to the stressful nature of the work), while surgery itself is a very powerful placebo [1].

This isn't to say that surgery or surgeons are evil and to be avoided. Not at all. It just adds nuance to the picture: the degree of training your healthcare professional receives is only one aspect of their job, albeit an important one.

[0] https://doi.org/10.1308/rcsbull.2015.331

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6693073/

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by baremetal on Monday March 06, 2023 @08:18AM (#35040589)
> surgical training favours people with some unpleasant personality traits

Do I care what kind of personality my surgeon has? No. I care about his aptitude at his job.

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by johnchristopher on Monday March 06, 2023 @10:35AM (#35042245)
Let's hope your surgeon personality doesn't help them too much with hiding their drug abuse problem if they have one then and that you are not the one going under the scalpel when they first start to lose it.

> Alcohol and drug abuse are a significant issue among physicians in general and surgeons in particular. A recent 7000-member survey of the American College of Surgeons demonstrated a prevalence for alcohol abuse among male surgeons at 13.8% and for female surgeons at 25.4%. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamasurgery/article-abstrac...

This dictionary and factoid HN comment war thread makes me want to waste karma.

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by comfypotato on Monday March 06, 2023 @11:27AM (#35042932)
This is relatable. If you feel like diving, I literally got a response from dang a few days ago after absolutely losing my shit in another thread. In that case, the results for myself were not positive, and I regret my actions. At least it was a first offense and I didn’t get banned.

Personally I feel HN is a good place to cathartically vent some heat. The limits/guidelines are set such that you can be aggressive without breaking them. You can add value in an aggressive tone. It’s like a city where the drivers are aggressive. Being kind, the first comment guideline, requires respect as opposed to syrupy fake facades. MMA fighters often respect each other, for example. This attitude is acknowledging the toxicity of anonymous internet culture and making the best of it. It’s generally an unhealthy place, but there’s value to be made/found.

Ironically stated on a thread about mental health. That being said, the comments surrounding this particular chain warrant aggressive discussion imo.

This is admittedly being posted somewhat in the spirit of Cunningham’s law.

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by johnchristopher on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @05:04AM (#35053595)
> Generally, though, I feel HN is a good place to cathartically vent some heat. The limits/guidelines are set such that you can be aggressive without breaking them. You can add value in an aggressive tone.

Venting is okay, but weak rhetoric devices like one-sentence x doesn't work because vast blanket uninformed or intentionally reductionist statement should not get a free pass in the name of conversation. All it does is derail threads and put people who knows better in the position of managing egos while explaining what's wrong and doing it in a way that doesn't accuse the other party of just trolling or something. Or more likely they move on when they've had enough and the cycle repeats with other players.

> Are there any anonymous internet forums good for your mental health? I think not.

Yeah, agreed. But it's so addictive :D !

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by baremetal on Monday March 06, 2023 @11:35AM (#35043021)
>A recent 7000-member survey of the American College of Surgeons demonstrated a prevalence for alcohol abuse among male surgeons at 13.8% and for female surgeons at 25.4%

"Avoid female surgeons" seems to be the thrust of your point here.

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by johnchristopher on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:57AM (#35053537)
You missed the point and managed to illustrate it.
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by austinjp on Friday March 10, 2023 @01:23PM (#35098657)
Why do you think they're separable? Personality informs decisions and care.

You're not a machine in need of a mechanic. You're a person, and people respond better when they're involved in shared decision-making regarding their healthcare.

Besides, "aptitude" is necessary but not sufficient for a surgeon. For a particularly creepy example of abuse, see https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7424662/

Further reading: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7424662/

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by johnchristopher on Monday March 06, 2023 @10:31AM (#35042175)
> [..] some professions and disciplines are far more likely to produce pretentious ivory towers than others, that I have a problem with. Typically and ironically imo it is stronger in the soft sciences than the hard.

Plenty of pretentiousness among the software crowd as well apparently.

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by Lalabadie on Sunday March 05, 2023 @05:32PM (#35034868)
This is similar to saying a hiring interview is only discussion, and any acknowledgment of employee skills or hiring techniques is just bs managerial posturing.
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by welshwelsh on Sunday March 05, 2023 @06:17PM (#35035287)
Which it is. The idea that you can accurately gauge a person's skills during an interview is complete bullshit. And at the end of the day an interview is just a discussion, people are hired based on how they make the interviewer feel and it will be months before they discover if they are qualified or not.
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by jodrellblank on Sunday March 05, 2023 @06:42PM (#35035509)
You can’t gauge them accurately in an interview, that doesn’t mean the skills themselves don’t exist.

Storytelling is just discussion but that doesn’t mean stories don’t exist, or that all stories are the same, that everyone is an equally good story teller, etc.

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by johndunne on Sunday March 05, 2023 @05:30PM (#35034859)
What makes you want to apply reductionism at level 100%. A discussion might help.
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by jjcon on Sunday March 05, 2023 @06:47PM (#35035555)
Because I think it is absurd and frankly ascientific how hard people cling to the idea that depression and anxiety are some biological or chemical body problem that is entirely outside their control. That it requires drugs or “special therapy techniques” to improve (Quite a useful narrative if your trying to sell those though)

If that were the case population level rates would be relatively stable over time and not vary dramatically by country but that is wildly not the case. Clearly lifestyle choices are a primary factor here but that is so taboo these days to even mention.

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by comfypotato on Sunday March 05, 2023 @07:06PM (#35035708)
> If that we’re the case

This isn’t necessarily true. There’s a wide variety of reasons for which diagnoses of mental illnesses would vary greatly. Equating Psychology to hard sciences is naive. It is the softest of sciences, but labeling it as non-science would be ridiculous.

I personally think Psychiatrists in particular have one of the most difficult jobs as physicians. It’s made worse for patients by the fact that a poorly performing Psychiatrist has many scapegoats behind which to hide.

Unfortunately I spend a lot of time around mentally ill folk, myself included. A good dose/choice of medication and a good therapist-client-match work modern miracles on people, and it’s very easy to see when you’re around it. It’s very similar to a surgery with a low success rate.

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by jjcon on Sunday March 05, 2023 @11:47PM (#35037607)
> softest of sciences, but labeling it as non-science would be ridiculous

It is about as scientific as chiropractics and acupuncture, full of anecdote and very little substance, you even provided some yourself. How can you possibly trust much of anything coming out of those disciplines when the majority of papers can't even be replicated?

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by tsimionescu on Monday March 06, 2023 @03:10AM (#35038609)
Simple:because, unlike chiropractic and acupuncture, some papers can be replicated.
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by comfypotato on Monday March 06, 2023 @09:04AM (#35041105)
As myself and others have pointed out, there is plenty of hard evidence that therapy is effective. Unfortunately it isn’t as optimistic as, say, cataracts surgery. Suggesting that the recent decades of funding and research in the general psychology domain haven’t yielded good results is humorously ignorant.

The purpose of my anecdote was to encourage you to see that you have no personal understanding of the subject. This is reasonable, yes? You appear to have no vested interest in someone who claims to have benefitted from therapy, and it’s very apparent you don’t see a therapist yourself.

There’s no better alternative, in terms of evidence-based approaches, for confronting mental illness. It’s irrelevant here just how good the approach is. It’s simply sick people doing the best they can to get well. From this perspective, you “having a problem” with it makes you look like a sociopath (I tend to think you aren’t).

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by jjcon on Monday March 06, 2023 @03:03PM (#35046809)
> You appear to have no vested interest in someone who claims to have benefitted from therapy, and it’s very apparent you don’t see a therapist yourself.

I could replace therapy in that sentence with chiropractics or acupuncture and it would express an equally meaningless platitude.

> Suggesting that the recent decades of funding and research in the general psychology domain haven’t yielded good results is humorously ignorant.

And yet if we look at populations (as we do to benchmark real medicine) in much of the western world deaths from despair are up, depression and anxiety are up, population happiness is trending down. What a testament to those decades of research.

> From this perspective, you “having a problem” with it makes you look like a sociopath

This is a clear violation of HN rules, I suggest you take a look at them. What I have a problem with is people being duped into spending tons of money by charlatans. People in need spend money on tons of things they are convinced help them (supplements, psychics, acupuncture etc), that isn't evidence of their utility.

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by comfypotato on Monday March 06, 2023 @04:29PM (#35047883)
> clear violation of HN rules

Sorry

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by johnchristopher on Monday March 06, 2023 @10:39AM (#35042294)
You really should take that chip on your shoulder to a therapist or a surgeon rather than on HN though. Acid comments won't help people consider your point of view if exposed with such aggression.
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by Groxx on Sunday March 05, 2023 @06:56PM (#35035631)
While explicitly not trying to take a side:

>If that were the case population level rates would be relatively stable over time and not vary dramatically by country but that is wildly not the case.

That would be true if and only if the measurements were accurate and did not change by time or location.

The measurement strategies have been changing dramatically in the past decades, and countries are almost universally in disagreement over the (significant) details. Wide variance in time and location are definitely expected, drawing a conclusion based on that is very much standing on shaky ground.

Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by jamilton on Monday March 06, 2023 @01:47AM (#35038179)
What do you mean? Talk therapy makes the assumption that depression/anxiety is not solely biological/chemical, and that the therapy will in some way alter the patient's mindset, lifestyle choices, environment, etc.
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by squeaky-clean on Sunday March 05, 2023 @05:21PM (#35034761)
No, therapy usually involves lots of homework as well. The talking part of it is essential to get there, but if you just go to therapy to talk it won't help much.
Re:Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee M... by johnchristopher on Monday March 06, 2023 @10:27AM (#35042110)
Pretty sure the vast majority of therapists have left the academic ivory tower and build their practice on years of secular experience but okay.