News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by powertower on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:05PM (#3502376)
I still don't get what this fuss is about?

Do you really think that MegaUpload generated 175MM from a few users signing up to a paid account, and from ads and scams that were displayed on URLs with legit content.

If 95% of their revenue came from copyrighted material being shared (without permission), then I'd say MU was a criminal enterprise and what happened was completely okay.

If 5%, than not okay.

The supporting evidence so far points to the former figure.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by lawnchair_larry on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:34PM (#3502492)
> Do you really think that MegaUpload generated 175MM from a few users signing up to a paid account, and from ads and scams that were displayed on URLs with legit content.

When did we end up in a society where "Do you really think..." is sufficient for judge, jury, and execution?

The fuss is not about megaupload. The fuss is about the MPAA and the RIAA teaming up with law enforcement to make sites and businesses that they don't like disappear from the internet, without due process.

It's been said before, but your whole post describes pre-google youtube. The only difference is they didn't use ads. It's worth noting, the charges against megaupload have nothing to do with any dirty business using ads.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by awj on Monday January 23, 2012 @07:57PM (#3502927)
> The fuss is about the MPAA and the RIAA teaming up with law enforcement to make sites and businesses that they don't like disappear from the internet, without due process.

Since when is "equipment subpoenaed via grand jury indictment" not due process? I'm all for arguing if what's happening should/should not be allowed, but let's at least get the facts straight on "what's happening" first.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by talmand on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:24PM (#3502448)
Sure, let the government have its day in court to prove its case. But some would say these people are being punished without due process right now before they appear in court. Plus the fact this has international implications makes it seem the US government has overstepped just a bit.

I always love the logic of forcing someone to pay to defend themselves in court but the government takes away your assets so that you are unable to pay for your defense.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by OpieCunningham on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:30PM (#3502473)
I still don't get what this fuss is about?

Your company looks very suspicious, just look at all these words I wrote down that show you just how suspicious it is.

The words I wrote down are so suspicious, I'm going to take your house and all your money. You can start issuing your own words to get it all back in a few months while I get paperwork ready to keep it from you permanently. Trust me, I'm going to win, I promise. If I didn't think so, would I have taken your house and all your money?

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by res0nat0r on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:31PM (#3502480)
PayPal does this all the time.
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by firefoxman1 on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:27PM (#3502458)
We all know MegaUpload is the go-to place for pirated content. That's not really in question. The question here is: Is our government following the rules our founding fathers laid out, or do they believe they can cut straight to taking down a company 90% out of their jurisdiction without even following due process.

The whole reason it's a debate is because if we, as citizens, don't watch our government closely when they make controversial moves like this, it easily becomes a very slippery slope. If we let our government get away with something like this, where will it end? Soon, will unwarranted search and seizure will be OK for the FBI, so long as they're after "pirates?" Will we end up like Iran who can execute a programmer 'cause they said so?

Yeah, those are extreme examples, but the reason it is such a slippery slope is because our court's decisions are largely ruled by precedence. If the courts declare the actions taken against MegaUpload legal, it's pretty much "anything goes" for the FBI and DoJ to attack future, perhaps less piracy-oriented or even completely legitimate companies. All the DoJ or FBI has to say is "see, you let us do it last time with MegaUpload."

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by jrockway on Monday January 23, 2012 @07:45PM (#3502892)
We all know MegaUpload is the go-to place for pirated content.

We all know that the west side of the Chicago is the place to go to buy drugs. That must mean that everyone living west of Halsted Street is a drug dealer and should be put in jail without a trial.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by res0nat0r on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:30PM (#3502477)
The arrests overseas we executed in full cooperation with those local countries governments. Not via some rogue operation.
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by firefoxman1 on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:43PM (#3502530)
Yeah I did read that. The police in the respective countries carried out the actual arrests. But since when did the U.S. see themselves the official justice department for the entire world? (I guess the answer is "since WWII") But how many people in the U.S. were being so irreversibly harmed by MegaUpload that our government felt such a need to command this world-wide operation.
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by Seth_Kriticos on Monday January 23, 2012 @06:25PM (#3502689)
Probably a few dozen. All very well packed and with excellent tie-ins to officials.

Welcome to the new democracy.

Not to defend MU here. Just don't think all that many people felt the harm for what they were doing. And if you ask artists, they will probably point you in different direction.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by powertower on Monday January 23, 2012 @06:22PM (#3502674)
> But since when did the U.S. see themselves the official justice department for the entire world?

I'm still confused on why you're confused. MU was distributing copyrighted material around the globe.

The US gathered evidence, presented that evidence to its partners, partners made the arrest.

It's a global network, there are various treaties, and there is cooperation.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by firefoxman1 on Monday January 23, 2012 @07:20PM (#3502837)
Well that's what's in question. Nobody is sure yet, but the question is: did the U.S. overstep their boundaries on this one? That's really all it is on the surface.
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by victork2 on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:56PM (#3502581)
Hi,

Indeed your quick analysis is true: MegaUpload was a platform to download copyrighted things over the internet.

But there is a greater principle at play: when should action be taken? The way it is done in democracy and countries where liberty is valued is that the action taken is done after due process. Also and I think this is pretty damn important there are international rules in terms of law and what can be done. Citizens of other countries should have the right to benefit from the law in vigor in their country without the US interfering with them. The US is not all saint and sometimes take poor decisions that cost the business, health or life of some people, especially when the problem comes from private interests.

Anyway if you allow authorities to take action without due process you end up in dark dark world where arrests become arbitrary. There were plenty of evidence that MegaUpload business was not legit actions could have been taken legally, but probably bribes came into play and short-circuited the whole thing. This becomes rampant in the US (Bradley Manning anyone ?) and it has to stop before it's too late.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by scott_s on Monday January 23, 2012 @06:41PM (#3502743)
I have only been skimming the MegaUpload discussion and articles, so please understand that I am asking an honest question: in what was was due process not followed?
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by dsthysd on Monday January 23, 2012 @07:02PM (#3502796)
-Megaupload never got to state their case

-There was no trial (and probably will not matter because their site has already lost all its traffic and revenue)

-It is not a US based site

-The majority of its traffic did not come from the US

-There is not much evidence that that they were doing anything illegal by US law. They had a system in place (such as youtube) to remove copyright infringing content if found.

The fact that the majority of their traffic came from pirated content (I am just assuming, no facts) is irrelevant. I am pretty sure that if the media companies put as much effort into reporting copyright violating content on Megaupload as they do on youtube, it would have none.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by pyre on Monday January 23, 2012 @08:04PM (#3502944)

  > -Megaupload never got to state their case
That usually happens at the trial. This is like saying that my life was disrupted when the police arrested me, because I should have had a chance to state my case before being arrested and indicted.

  > -There was no trial (and probably will not matter
  > because their site has already lost all its traffic
  > and revenue)
The site was taken down because the servers were confiscated as part of a pending trial. I don't understand the 'no trial' business.

  > -It is not a US based site
They had servers in the US, which established a US presence, and they are accused of massive copyright infringements against US companies who have all/most of their copyrights based in the US.

  > -The majority of its traffic did not come from the US
Do you have numbers to back this up?

  > -There is not much evidence that that they were doing
  > anything illegal by US law. They had a system in place
  > (such as youtube) to remove copyright infringing
  > content if found.
The government plans to prosecute the employees and send them to jail. I'm pretty sure that they wouldn't be attempting this if they had little to no evidence. Not that I believe that the US government are saints, but they usually don't bring cases that have little chance of winning. The evidence will out itself at trial. Have you read any of the requisite legal documentation on this?

  > I am pretty sure that if the media companies put as
  > much effort into reporting copyright violating content
  > on Megaupload as they do on youtube, it would have none.
If you read the court filings, you would have realized that MegaUpload limited the number of filings allow per day. The content companies were hitting that limit and requesting that it be increased/removed. If there are a million infringing files and you only get to take down 2500/day, it's going to take awhile, no? Especially considering that the number of infringing files/links would not be static.

The government is claiming that MegaUpload purposefully restricted the number of takedowns because they knew that they needed the infringing material to bolster their growth (and allowing all infringing files to be taken down would hurt them).

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by victork2 on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @10:04AM (#3505008)
Hi Pyre,

I agree with your comment. However I would understand due process as process that seems to be fair and just, not something legal. Because if tomorrow the government says by law that part of the trial is to kill the culprit before the trial that would be legal in regards to the law but not in regards to the basic human principles. I know the example is extreme but I hope you see my point on the matter. In that case even before the trial the parties are punished and destroyed: no presence anymore on internet, no servers, no domain names. It certainly feels like somebody is punished even before the trial, no?

Also the fact that the FBI (FEDERAL) has power to seize or take things oversea is seriously worrying. I believe there are more urgent matters that needs to be taken care in the united States by the FBI before investigating that. This is a result of the PATRIOT Act. Great!

To sum up I believe that MegaUpload profit came massively from copyright infringement but even the worst killer should have his rights guaranteed.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by scott_s on Monday January 23, 2012 @10:19PM (#3503298)
As pyre explains, it sounds like the federal government followed due process as it is laid out in federal law. Perhaps they didn't follow what you think is fair "due process," but that's a different matter.
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by cynicalkane on Monday January 23, 2012 @06:41PM (#3502742)
I think the point of this post is that we don't have any reason to believe that the Megaupload takedown is sinister. I happen to agree and don't think it should be downvoted.

The Internet's reaction to these events seems really knee-jerk. Okay, the Megaupload case might have been a horrible abuse of government power. But right now it seems like a routine takedown of a business that supported itself mostly through illegal activity. This is standard operating practice from long before Internet piracy was a thing.

So let's not make a big deal about something which might have been bad, but we have no reason to believe it actually was. If Megaupload turns out to be completely innocent, I'll join the bandwagon. But the grand jury indictment is so damning, it would really have to turn out to be mostly lies.

Meanwhile there are real government abuses, such as the indefinite detention of terror suspects. Can we talk about those instead?

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by droithomme on Monday January 23, 2012 @10:30PM (#3503328)
> Do you really think that MegaUpload generated 175MM from a few users signing up to a paid account

No, I think they made money from a LOT of users signing up for paid accounts. I know lots of people that did so, Megaupload is widely used by professionals in the video, music, graphics and games industries for transferring and distributing large files at low cost legally.

I find it highly unlikely that those engaging in illegal activity went in and gave their traceable credit card information to get accounts for illegal activity. That may have happened, but it seems obvious that users doing illegal stuff, particularly those involving stealing things because you don't want to pay, are not highly likely to be creating easily traceable financial connections between their illegal activity and their real identities.

File sizes are large nowadays and millions of people and teams work remotely. There is a tremendous need for locker sites with large file capabilities, reasonable usability, and low cost. Megaupload provided a good technical solution and price to a strong need in modern business and this is why they were successful. People paid them because people have large files they need to work with and distribute. Completely separately from illegal use.

Any company that allows uploading of material is going to have this problem. Legislation such as DMCA was supposed to protect business from copyright violation liability when the infringement was committed by third parties as long as they followed the takedown process. Now we find that DMCA does no such thing, and businesses are beginning to shut down or drastically limit file hosting services. This is creating serious problems for tens of thousands or more of legitimate users and is harming legal businesses that benefit from locker file hosting services.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by powertower on Monday January 23, 2012 @11:39PM (#3503491)
> No, I think they made money from a LOT of users signing up for paid accounts.

Except that the indictment states that MU had only a few paid users and was largely ad supported... And I could have sworn that before all this happened, MU said the same thing.

> Legislation such as DMCA was supposed to protect business from copyright violation liability when the infringement was committed by third parties as long as they followed the takedown process.

DMCA didn't protect MU because they refused to delete the actual files (they only deleted some of the links pointing to that same file), and actively ignored DMCA takedown notices that did not come from major US parties.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by droithomme on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @01:26AM (#3503724)
I did not remember reading in the indictment that it was largely ad supported and not subscriptions as you indicate, but you do cite the indictment itself so I assumed you noticed something I did not and went and reread it. It documents $8,840,000 in ad revenue in items 42 through 44, $110 million in subscription revenue from PayPal in item 41, and then in item 67 says "Between September 2005 and the date of this Indictment, the defendants collectively have received more than $175 million from advertising and subscriptions."

It would be nice if there was a more detailed break down but the breakdown given does not support claims that subscription income was inconsequential. I wonder, had you actually read the complete indictment, or were you just relying on summaries from other web sites. Sometimes summaries are not accurate or don't give the whole picture. Then again, perhaps I missed a more detailed breakdown elsewhere, if you have it please reference it by specific item number within the indictment. Thanks.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by powertower on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @09:09AM (#3504754)
I've looked it over again and you're right. The majority of that came from premium accounts.

This still does not help MU if the signup originally came after a user visited a page with illegal content, and signed up to be able to get that content or to partake in sharing illegal content and get bounties on it....

Which would all be easy to check by taking a small sample of the logs and seeing what's what.

Though it does help MU if it can be shown those were all legitimate users.

Aside from that, the indictment is still very damning on other points. Even if the revenue was mostly legit, the primary driver to that revenue and the way MU conducted itself looks to be questionable at best.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by learc83 on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:28PM (#3502469)
What's the cutoff? Is it a 50/50 thing? If my site makes 10% of it's revenue from pirates, should I go to jail? Google makes plenty of money from sites that host counterfeit goods and copyrighted material, should Larry Page go to jail?
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by powertower on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:33PM (#3502487)
Does your business completely revolve around profiting from the illegal distribution of copyrighted works?
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by yassim on Monday January 23, 2012 @06:16PM (#3502651)
Did theirs? Can real numbers be shown of the money that was generated by piracy with this service vs money that was not?

My guess is from this point we will never know the real unbiased numbers, not matter who wins.

Edit: to clarify tone.

Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by Steko on Monday January 23, 2012 @10:01PM (#3503255)
My guess is that we'll be shown fairly conclusive internal communication that makes it clear the MU knew exactly that they were profiting illegally and continued to do it and enable it. At that point it doesn't matter exactly how much they made legally or illegally. Does it matter that a pawn shop makes some money legitimately if it's basically a front for selling stolen property?
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by pavel_lishin on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:23PM (#3502444)
At what percentage do you draw the line?
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by powertower on Monday January 23, 2012 @05:35PM (#3502498)
When that percentage is the primary driver of your business.
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by pavel_lishin on Monday January 23, 2012 @09:06PM (#3503147)
So, 51%?
Re:Megaupload Takedown Questioned By Users, Lawyers by lwat on Monday January 23, 2012 @07:49PM (#3502899)
Yes and how much is that exactly