It would be nice if there was a more detailed break down but the breakdown given does not support claims that subscription income was inconsequential. I wonder, had you actually read the complete indictment, or were you just relying on summaries from other web sites. Sometimes summaries are not accurate or don't give the whole picture. Then again, perhaps I missed a more detailed breakdown elsewhere, if you have it please reference it by specific item number within the indictment. Thanks.
This still does not help MU if the signup originally came after a user visited a page with illegal content, and signed up to be able to get that content or to partake in sharing illegal content and get bounties on it....
Which would all be easy to check by taking a small sample of the logs and seeing what's what.
Though it does help MU if it can be shown those were all legitimate users.
Aside from that, the indictment is still very damning on other points. Even if the revenue was mostly legit, the primary driver to that revenue and the way MU conducted itself looks to be questionable at best.
Except that the indictment states that MU had only a few paid users and was largely ad supported... And I could have sworn that before all this happened, MU said the same thing.
> Legislation such as DMCA was supposed to protect business from copyright violation liability when the infringement was committed by third parties as long as they followed the takedown process.
DMCA didn't protect MU because they refused to delete the actual files (they only deleted some of the links pointing to that same file), and actively ignored DMCA takedown notices that did not come from major US parties.