News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The moral case against equity language by nine_k on Friday March 03, 2023 @01:01AM (#35006330)
But interpreting someone's words in the most uncharitable way possible is an ancient sport, intended to slight and annoy the opponent, when finding reasonable, material objections fails. It's just an ancient hold of wresting in the (verbal) mud. It sort of gives the party who successfully pulled it an upper hand.

Now that these wrestlers found out that they can persuade the public that the most uncharitable interpretation is actually harmful to some third party (nobody from the audience usually says that they personally are offended), this approach became immensely popular.

Since simple reason would usually dispel much of the effect, leaving only the small and easily correctable issue, it is common to excite a large amount of reason-eclipsing emotions over such issues, preferably the righteous rage.

But it may feel fun to express a strong and righteous emotion, especially in a crowd of other people doing the same. It does not take thinking, it does not take making a difficult decision (because everybody around can't be wrong), so it feels good. A big echo chamber like a popular Twitter thread make it feel epic in scale.

This makes that kind of righteous rage a very convenient tool of manipulation, for fun, profit, and any other purposes.

Re:The moral case against equity language by kenjackson on Friday March 03, 2023 @08:21AM (#35009211)
And to be clear, these uncharitable interpretations go far beyond word policing.

The one that actually annoys me the most is “analogy policing”. If I say “would you be ok if i stole your bike”. And then your response is “now you’re equating me to a bike thief!” Or “ you’re trivializing This to bike theft?!”

We can’t have discussions because every phrase is taken as a way to win an argument. IMO this is far worse than language policing as there is not even the intention of trying to protect a disadvantaged group.

Re:The moral case against equity language by nine_k on Friday March 03, 2023 @09:30AM (#35010052)
It's almost as if the goal of winning an argument might contradict the goal of coming closer to truth, or to an agreement.

Much like bringing a knife to a gunfight, attempting to seek truth during a status-assertion contest is not very efficient.