Do you still think it's a negligible cost? These costs are also going up: in January 2023 Ireland issued two more fines for $0.4 billion.
[1]: You can check at https://www.enforcementtracker.com/
[2]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/745351/facebooks-quarter...
Ireland's data privacy serves as Meta's main regulator in the European Union because the company's European headquarters are in Dublin. Making it out as if Ireland's GDPR fines are "just one country" is disingenuous.
I'm old enough to have seen the internet evolve in the UK, and as usual the US dominates it and screws it up for the whole planet.
I'm surrounded by USAF, and pro American brits because they get employed by the US Mil, and their extremist mentality grinds you down.
So I really do hope the EU starts putting the US and UK in its place, and failing that Russia or even China because there are some very toxic people running these countries, getting away with murder.
Unless the same rules get enforced on the big players, it's just a moat around the status quo. In Europe's defense, they have been fining the big players, but on the other hand at this rate the fines are starting to feel more like a kickback than actual punitive measures intended to change behavior.
It's now the game over state for personal and family privacy. All the sites and apps and even casio watches has telemetry always-enabled (via mobile apps). Even cars. No one in governments or agencies cares about privacy anymore. Call it whatever one wants: corruption or lobbying, the name does not matter.
The possible solutions are impossible for the non-software engineers (pihole and dns set in the home wifi, personal openvpn gateway set on all 4/5G connected devices). Younger generations don't care. Older ones just don't understand.
It's the dark age of privacy. Literally no hope.
I wonder what the consequences would be in the next 5-10 years when the collected data would be analyzed by AI and sold to anyone for a more and more cheaper price. What should happen for the people to push the unprivacy back hard enough to stop or revert?
There are many engineers (I'm one myself) who wouldn't even consider working for Google. It very definitely is not the case that all other options are second-bests chosen by someone who failed to get into Google.
It’s beyond that. It’s micromanaging. Regulation cannot and should not be able to keep up.
Politicians might not, but the government apparatus does. There's a reason 3GPP/ITU for years have built backdoors in telecommunication networks. It is simply that the IETF folks building atop Packet Switched Networks are putting up brave resistance: https://archive.is/iawrM
In the USA, doesn't know? Or doesn't want to know? Things like The Patriot Act are more effective (?) when there's an endless buffet of personal data available without the need for a wire tape, court order, etc. Probable cause? Much easier with phone meta data and CCT footage. Etc.
There's too little incentive for the gov to get it right. The current situation is no accident.
Elizabeth Holmes was indicted 5 years ago. She was sentenced last year. She’s still walking around freely.
A normal person would’ve spent at least 4 of those years locked up, if not all of them. They most certainly wouldn’t be out and about after being convicted. These people simply have different rules applied to them.
Wow, I didn't know this, but you're right:
https://www.womenshealthmag.com/life/a39299534/elizabeth-hol...
She received an 11-year sentence last November but she's apparently a free woman until April 27th of this year.
Can someone who knows more about the American legal system explain this to me? Why is this possible? I assumed that when you're sentenced you get taken to jail pretty much immediately.
(Yes, I'm sure the short answer is just "because she has lots of money", but what are the details? What exactly did she spend it on to buy an extra 5 months of freedom?)
So you'd get a revolving door between Google and this supposed agency regulating Google where engineers and policy makers would work at the agency, be friendly to Google and then switch jobs into a cushy job at Google with a nice pay bump as a thank you for years served and services rendered.
The broader problem is that the government, courts, police and everyone else who is otherwise in charge of enforcing rights in this country does not know the first thing about technology.
We have dealt with this problem plenty of times in the past by setting up specialized bureaus and giving them broad authority to regulate players in the space and deal with infractions (the SEC is a great example of this), but there is no such tech authority. Imagine a world where the smartest programming minds aren't just joining Google but also the agency set up to regulate Google. Imagine if in a post-scandal hearing you don't have politicians who can't figure out an iPhone ask the questions but someone who knows how to set up a network firewall and what 2FA means. Until that happens, just passing more and more laws is going to be meaningless.