Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by atlasunshrugged on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:28AM
(#34997866)
I think this part is the most interesting to me, "Redwood says that the main cost driver in the whole process comes down to logistics, particularly now while there are so few end-of-life EVs waiting to have their battery packs recycled. Redwood says that "in time, as end-of-life pack volumes increase, the logistics cost will decrease so that batteries will become assets that will help make EVs more sustainable and affordable in the long run"
I wonder if we'll see a push for smaller recycling facilities (and the tech that enables them) that are pretty localized to try to minimize transportation costs in the future rather than these massive recycling plants.
Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by secabeen on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:49AM
(#34998185)
If we can get the facilities small enough, they can be co-located with the static storage Grid battery facilities that are hopefully the first re-use of these EV batteries.
Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by ramesh31 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:57PM
(#34999243)
>If we can get the facilities small enough, they can be co-located with the static storage Grid battery facilities that are hopefully the first re-use of these EV batteries.
End of life cells will never be directly reused in any form of safety critical application like that. It's simply too dangerous to deal with the voltage and discharge irregularities that come after so many cycles. They will have to be remanufactured from raw materials.
Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by ramesh31 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:08PM
(#34999398)
>Isn't there a large gap between "no longer cost-effective for mobile applications" and "end of life"?
Not for lithium batteries. They have a significant change in voltage (internal resistance) and charge/discharge curve that is unique to each individual cell, based on the specifics of it's lifetime usage. That makes any form of safety critical application impossible. You cannot build a pack around cells with unknown or variable properties. Sure they could be used for hobby projects or DIY stuff, but that's about it.
Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by recycledmatt on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:33PM
(#34998883)
The trick will be doing the front end of the process more local to material (size reduction and separation) and then doing refining at larger plants. They will shred the batteries, pull out plastics and metals, and concentrate the black mass. This is the good stuff, and you will reduce the mass and dimensions considerably.
Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by sliken on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:41PM
(#34999893)
Sure if you have $50k for a car, can charge at home, and want to drive 300 miles without charging then you need 1 ton (or so) of batteries.
But as electrification improves, more charging stations, better autonomous driving, car sharing services that don't require drivers, etc. The size of batteries can shrink and the number of people that need dedicated cars will decrease.
A self driving EV could be significantly cheaper than human driven Uber/Lyft, allowing more people to opt in only as needed, which makes public transit more feasible.
Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by tumetab1 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:52AM
(#34998216)
What I would like know, and the article does not mention, is how environment friendly is the process. Can they have a profit without generating a lot of pollution?
From the little I known about computer hardware recycling some process generated a lot of hazardous chemicals so I'm concerned if the same happens with EV battery recycling.
Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by recycledmatt on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:36PM
(#34998929)
Mining virgin materials uses much more resources than recycling. The material is already concentrated in the to be recycled items. Strong environmental controls must be in place with the recycling companies, but the impacts are less.
Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by recycledmatt on Thursday March 02, 2023 @08:32PM
(#35004673)
The value here isn’t decided by the plastics. We are talking lithium, cobalt, copper as primary recovery.
There are tons of interesting angles in plastic recycling. Engineered plastics do have value, other polymers not as much
Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by cptcobalt on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:08PM
(#34998467)
The question should focus on: is it cleaner to re-refine during recycling than to do new mining of new materials? (And if it isn't yet—like due to economies of scale—is there a clear road with the concept.)
Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by recycledmatt on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:52PM
(#34999160)
Redwood has been getting a lot of press lately over their potential $2 billion dollar loan (https://www.forbes.com/sites/alanohnsman/2023/02/09/redwood-...), but what shocks me with this is how low volume their process is now. I talk a lot about scale and volume in recycling - but 250NT of material is nothing. Some large car shredders generate that much in fluff/ADC in a day, and there are dozens of them operating around the country.
Re:What Redwood learned in its first year of EV battery recy...
by toomuchtodo on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:40PM
(#35000794)
Nissan’s CEO said the batteries are outliving the cars. Old battery packs are usually repurposed as stationary storage versus being shredded and recycled.
I wonder if we'll see a push for smaller recycling facilities (and the tech that enables them) that are pretty localized to try to minimize transportation costs in the future rather than these massive recycling plants.
End of life cells will never be directly reused in any form of safety critical application like that. It's simply too dangerous to deal with the voltage and discharge irregularities that come after so many cycles. They will have to be remanufactured from raw materials.
Not for lithium batteries. They have a significant change in voltage (internal resistance) and charge/discharge curve that is unique to each individual cell, based on the specifics of it's lifetime usage. That makes any form of safety critical application impossible. You cannot build a pack around cells with unknown or variable properties. Sure they could be used for hobby projects or DIY stuff, but that's about it.
25MWh is pilot-project size, but they are working through the difficulties and building the tooling to enable re-use.
My guess is we’ll have 10 or so around the country each dealing with 100x as many batteries.
It's hard to believe we could provide 1 ton batteries to 5B+ people long-term without efficient recycling. The mineral reserves are just not enough.
I'm not saying everyone on the planet should own a car, but I certainly wouldn't bet on this market shrinking any time soon.
But as electrification improves, more charging stations, better autonomous driving, car sharing services that don't require drivers, etc. The size of batteries can shrink and the number of people that need dedicated cars will decrease.
A self driving EV could be significantly cheaper than human driven Uber/Lyft, allowing more people to opt in only as needed, which makes public transit more feasible.
From the little I known about computer hardware recycling some process generated a lot of hazardous chemicals so I'm concerned if the same happens with EV battery recycling.
That depends heavily on the material in question. Aluminum, yes. Plastic, no.
We recycle about 12 million cars a year in the US - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_recycling - this is 1,268 cars worth of batteries. We have a long way to go!
Older Nissan Leafs are still on the road: https://cleantechnica.com/2022/09/21/surprise-nissan-leaf-ba...
The state of the lithium-ion battery recycling market - A conversation with battery analyst Yayoi Sekine of BNEF. [DEC 9, 2022]
https://www.volts.wtf/p/the-state-of-the-lithium-ion-battery