I mean working as a consultant I've worked in industries like public transit, finance, energy, postal etc, but nowhere did I think I understood enough to fix the whole thing. Actually working in those industries makes you appreciate the scale and scope of them, and that unless you end up at C-level, anything you do will probably only affect a small aspect of the whole construction.
And that's just fine, do what you can and you'll make it to retirement, take on more than you can chew and you'll end up overworked, disillusioned, or fired.
If an amateur was interested enough in music to make a music notation program I'd say they're a serious amateur who has every right to try it.
I'm fairly certain that it's quite different, when compared to decades if not centuries of past methods, all thanks to someone with a particular set of software development skills taking a new look at the already existing approaches and deciding to do something different.
Yes, sometimes, but if that’s what you’re going for it’s still important that you’re solving a problem that you understand well. So maybe I would be okay with someone with limited photoshop experience making an image editor, but I hope they still have a designer/artist/etc. background.
I disagree. Writing a program can be a fantastic way to learn more about the problem. Of course, if you want the program to be good, you’ll probably end up needing to do some serious iteration/rewriting as you learn more.
Wouldn't a fresh look at things, essentially a "clean room" implementation offer the possibility of a novel approach to a thing or two, as opposed to making the same tool, just different?
But overall the idea of matching one's ambitions (project scope) to one's abilities (including domain knowledge) is a good one.
Not doing that is why we get things like Kickstarter campaigns for MMO games by novice developers, which never go anywhere as projects. Of course, it's also useful to fail and be humbled with learning projects, especially when someone's money is NOT on the line. Maybe more people should explore developing something like microservices in non-prod projects to better learn their advantages and disadvantages and so on.