Re:Blindly submitting content to HN, good or bad?
by veyron on Sunday January 22, 2012 @06:15PM
(#3498173)
In your perspective, what are valid reasons for downvoting?
Re:Blindly submitting content to HN, good or bad?
by chc on Sunday January 22, 2012 @06:56PM
(#3498327)
In the perspective of many people here, downvotes are to indicate that you don't think the comment contributes to the conversation in a positive way. For example, I upvote comments I disagree with as long as they make the point well and give me something to think about. Similarly, I downvote comments I agree with if they're snide or poorly constructed.
Re:Blindly submitting content to HN, good or bad?
by vannevar on Wednesday January 25, 2012 @05:53PM
(#3512112)
Yes, I think many people are under the mistaken impression that the upvote/downvote buttons are functionally symmetrical, which is understandable given that they are presented as visually symmetrical. But upvoting serves to avoid redundant 'I agree.' posts, while if users downvote to disagree, it robs the discussion of valuable content (i.e., why they disagree). It would help if the UI were modified to signal this asymmetry.
Disagreeing with something is not a reason to downvote either.