News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by jschveibinz on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:03AM (#34970032)
Entomologist: “ah, a rare insect! I will kill it and mount it in my insect collection! And then, I will write about how I discovered it. Brilliant!”
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by reborned on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:29AM (#34970368)
The insect was on the exterior wall of a Walmart - it was likely not long for this world. That's the nature of science though. The story does remind me of a documentary I saw on a researcher of rare lizards in the Australian outback. Over 30 years he collected thousands of specimens. The interviewer asked if he might be harming the population of the various lizard species he was studying. The researcher thought about it for a second and said he used to believe the populations were large enough that it did not matter, but then admitted he isn't so sure now.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by ceejayoz on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:05AM (#34970062)
To be fair...

> Skvarla found the specimen in 2012, but misidentified it and only discovered its true identity after teaching an online course based on his personal insect collection in 2020.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by galleywest200 on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:20AM (#34970257)
Still odd one's reaction to seeing a neat living creature is to immediately kill it and mount it.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by toss1 on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:26AM (#34970335)
Yes, especially these days when we are driving the 6th mass extinction event, and we have all kinds of other options for documentation.

It was one thing a century and a half ago when wildlife was still close to plentiful. Now, take some photos and videos, log the location & conditions, and let it live...

Killing & mounting isn't science anymore, it's a snuff fetish.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by ceejayoz on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:34AM (#34970416)
> Now, take some photos and videos, log the location & conditions, and let it live...

From the article, a microscope and DNA testing were required to confirm:

> "We were watching what Dr. Skvarla saw under his microscope and he's talking about the features and then just kinda stops," said Codey Mathis, a doctoral candidate in entomology at Penn State. "We all realized together that the insect was not what it was labeled and was in fact a super-rare giant lacewing. I still remember the feeling. It was so gratifying to know that the excitement doesn't dim, the wonder isn't lost. Here we were making a true discovery in the middle of an online lab course."

> For additional confirmation, Skvarla and his colleagues performed molecular DNA analyses on the specimen. Since confirming its true identity, Skvarla has deposited the insect safely in the collections of the Frost Entomological Museum at Penn State, where scientists and students will have access to it for further research.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by AlexandrB on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:40AM (#34970486)
When it comes to insects, I think your anger is misplaced. Capturing and mounting a specimen hardly makes a dent compared to how many die on car windshields, due to pesticide use, or from loss of habitat. Adult insects also tend to have a short life - for many species only one season.

And in this case the collection was done for a valid scientific purpose, not just for funsies.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by reaperducer on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:57AM (#34970699)
Capturing and mounting a specimen hardly makes a dent compared to how many die on car windshields

Well, the point here is that this was a "rare" insect. Comparing the number of a particular rare insect to the number of common mosquitoes doesn't make sense.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by blendergeek on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:20AM (#34971022)
And when he captured and mounted it, he thought it was a common insect.

He only realized it was a rare insect 8 years later.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by sokoloff on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:24AM (#34971120)
The predation load on the insect population from all entomologists worldwide is infinitesimal. Capturing and mounting an insect will almost surely not change the course of that species' survival.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by positr0n on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:22AM (#34971076)
Plus, most insects lay thousands and thousands of eggs. Whatever the carrying capacity of the local environment is, insects will fill it quickly.

Pesticide use and loss of habitat make that carrying capacity smaller. Smashing bugs on your car windshield and collecting specimens just makes room for more juvenile bugs to survive to adulthood in a few hours/days.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by adrianN on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:35AM (#34970423)
I bet there are a lot of sciency things you can do to a specimen that you can't do to a photograph of a specimen. And it's not like a few thousand specimens in museums are driving mass extinction. It's habitat destruction and climate change.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by sliken on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:16AM (#34970973)
Heh, well driving a car at 60 mph during on the wrong day on the wrong road would kill 100x more bugs than a entomologist does in their entire career.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by stevenwoo on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:22AM (#34971068)
Reminds me of the guy killing the oldest extant tree specimen to get their core sampler out. https://www.radiolab.org/episodes/91722-be-careful-what-you-...
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by subsubzero on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @12:27PM (#34972085)
As an aspiring entomologist (when I was younger) its very common. I would have put it in a jar when I got home and observed it but you have to know that insects have very short lives and one in a polluted urban setting would not live long anyways. I think people conflate insects lifespans with mammals(which can be as long or longer than humans).
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by Cpoll on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:19AM (#34970241)
Well, what else do you do with it? Insects aren't pandas, there's no world where killing one will have an ecological effect.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by he_is_legend on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:36AM (#34970445)
You could say the same for humans, yet for some reason its a crime.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by unixgoddess on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:29AM (#34970355)
it's the opposite actually. Insects are incomparably more important than highly complex highly specialized animals when it comes to biodiversity.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by ceejayoz on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:35AM (#34970432)
Insects as a whole, yes. A single insect, generally not.

If an endangered insect species is down to a population where single individuals matter, it's already a goner.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by anonymouskimmer on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @06:21PM (#34976381)
The Lord Howe Island Stick Insect bounced back from a remnant population of 24 individuals once rediscovered and taken to a larger habitat free from the predation that extirpated them from their original island.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by ceejayoz on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @07:32AM (#34981636)
Maybe. https://lhimuseum.com/learn/phasmids/

> In 2014, an unauthorised climbing team sighted live stick insects near the summit of Ball’s Pyramid, in a thicket of sedge plants rooted in very thin soils at an altitude of 500 metres, suggesting that the insect’s range on the island is more widespread than previously thought, and that its food preferences are not limited to Melaleuca howeana.

That species likely was a goner, barring the human breeding program. Successful reintroduction is going to require humans to finish wiping out the rat population on Lord Howe Island (which wiped the insects out there in just two years after their 1918 introduction).

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by anonymouskimmer on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @12:27PM (#34985228)
Yep.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by unixgoddess on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @03:39AM (#34980110)
it was a "rare insect", so killing it is potentially catastrophic as insects are highly likely to play an important role in any ecosystem.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by myself248 on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:29AM (#34970366)
"Embedded in the mud, glistening green and gold and black, was a butterfly, very beautiful and very dead."
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by toss1 on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:30AM (#34970376)
Photograph & video it, log the location data, and let it live.

When it is "a rare, surviving eastern population of giant lacewings that evaded detection and extinction. ", it is very much like a panda, and a single premature death can make a difference in the survival of a population.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by water-your-self on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:50AM (#34970617)
It helps to read the article
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by toss1 on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @11:58AM (#34984703)
It helps to not make incorrect assumption about who has read what.

You add nothing with such a vague comment, only distraction. If you have a problem with what I wrote, state the problem or don't bother subtracting value.

(Hint: I did, and yes I understand that he didn't even realize what it was until years later. I also recall being taught in middle school to capture and mount insects, so it isn't just the handful of PhDs doing it who will actually do DNA analysis on it...)

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by reaperducer on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:03AM (#34970784)
Insects aren't pandas, there's no world where killing one will have an ecological effect.

Ten years ago, people thought the same thing about bees.

Today, we're starting to worry about the food supply.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by blendergeek on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:21AM (#34971054)
And still, killing one bee will likely not have an ecological effect.

It is mass deaths of bees that are causing the problems, not entomologists taking for collections.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by anonymouskimmer on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @06:19PM (#34976356)
The Lord Howe Island Stick Insect was once reduced to a population of 24 living off the understory of one bush.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by bell-cot on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:59AM (#34970742)
Is there any indication that the insect was alive and reproductively relevant when he plucked it off the side of the building? I've lived in areas where swarms of dead & dying mayflies (aka fish flies) appear on the sides of buildings every year.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by korroziya on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:42AM (#34971405)
I assure you, entomologists have done more to help insect welfare than you ever will.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by jschveibinz on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @03:24PM (#34974333)
That could be true, if you knew anything about me. But the fact is that like all science, there are ethical considerations to be considered. Here is an article that attempts to address this issue:

https://faunalytics.org/entomology-and-the-ethical-treatment...

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by korroziya on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @04:09PM (#34974880)
You made a cheap glib remark about an entire scientific group and now you want to try and backtrack with a link as though you weren't acting like a pretentious teenager. Just take the loss and move on.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by jschveibinz on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @08:22PM (#34977523)
Fair enough. Your comment made me giggle a bit, but I will take your wisdom and move on.
Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by pvaldes on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @04:56PM (#34975471)
Yup, professional entomologists study insects all the time. Is what they do.

And to identify it they need to look at things that aren't visible in a photo. Moreover, photos are not a valid proof of anything currently because they are easily falsifiable.

Individuals are not important, we protect populations. And to detect valuable populations we need to take samples.

Re:Rare insect found at AR Walmart sets historic record, poi... by Natsu on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @06:40PM (#34976539)
* * *