News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Generative AI could be an authoritarian breakthrough in b... by kelseyfrog on Sunday February 26, 2023 @09:21PM (#34952194)
The only problem with this is that it ends up giving people the ability to think critically about information which contradicts their beliefs. It's the same problem smart people have - they're more capable at rationalizing their beliefs than they are at deciding what to believe.
Re:Generative AI could be an authoritarian breakthrough in b... by macawfish on Monday February 27, 2023 @03:04AM (#34954142)
That's not critical thinking then, it's reactionary thinking. Critical thinking is a tool for challenging our own beliefs and assumptions.
Re:Generative AI could be an authoritarian breakthrough in b... by kelseyfrog on Monday February 27, 2023 @01:01PM (#34959727)
I agree. Critical thinking is often paired with developing the methods or tools of critique. Instead of applying the tools of critique to one's own thoughts, these tools get applied selectively to ideas, especially ideas one doesn't agree with already.

For example, recognizing bias is a component of critical thinking. Rather than recognizing one's own biases, the reactionary thinker will instead tend to recognize bias in other's assumptions and arguments. They apply different standards to their own thoughts than they do to others'. You're absolutely right that this isn't critical thinking, but it is definitely a result of half-teaching or half-learning the tools of critique, or an inability to be intellectually honest or emotionally available to being wrong.