News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by nknight on Saturday January 21, 2012 @05:02PM (#3494784)
The response to these incidents is depressingly predictable. "Yes he has the right to shut it down, but..." -- no, there is no "but".

Consider this: An employee quits his job. Do you say "Yes, he has the right to quit, but..."? No. There is no "but". He has the right to quit, period.

Involuntary servitude isn't allowed even when someone is getting paid for it, what the hell makes you think it's acceptable when they aren't, and are even investing their own resources?

He's not being a jerk, he's not being harsh. His right in this matter is absolute, and he's already given the community more of an opportunity than was necessary -- legally, ethically, or socially -- to step up. He has no obligation of any kind to keep putting his time and money into it. If you want slavery, build yourself a time machine, don't demand that he do it for you.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by soc88 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @06:42PM (#3495052)
This comparison is just deeply flawed.

Point is, he can do whatever he wants, but his actions are solely designed to make the live of everyone else a bit harder, just for the sake of it.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by ww520 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @06:59PM (#3495092)
I didn't see he forgot to return the keys (owned by the company). He asked for help to transition it off. No one came, so he just shut it down.

Yes. I can see how everyone's life is a bit harder since he has stopped providing free product and service for them. Well, they had a free ride to begin with.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by soc88 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @07:06PM (#3495110)
You are still missing it completely.
Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by bmelton on Saturday January 21, 2012 @07:30PM (#3495169)
I believe it is you missing the point. They're his keys. If I quit the company I'm working for, they can't just take all all my keys because at some point they gave me some.

This is no different than my old neighbor, Mr. Taylor. He used to let us use the pool in his backyard until one of the kids pooped in it. He stopped letting those kids come to the pool.

It's his pool, and it's his choice who can and can't use it. In this case, David Pollack has just decided nobody can use the pool, and he's put a fence around it.

You're just pissed you can't use the pool for free anymore.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by soc88 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @07:42PM (#3495194)
I never used his pool.

I just think that his behavior is intended to maximize the potential damage to everyone, he is well aware of that and does it on purpose, because someone hurt his feelings.

In my opinion there are other, more constructive options available.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by ww520 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @10:27PM (#3495509)
Can you prove that? I'm not familiar with the Scala drama.

Even if that innuendo is true, why don't you blame the one who hurts his feeling? Instead of blaming him. Open source developers are human, too. They have taken on far too much abuses from ungrateful users.

I don't see the need for David to be a doormat to every abusive user out there. I would snap too and say fuck it, you guys are on your own.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by soc88 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @11:09PM (#3495597)
After people finally figured out that he was leaving (almost no one knew of that) they offered to take over the complete responsibility, what happens? Suddenly he wants to keep the domain, forcing everyone to pull and update their documentation, packages, artifact IDs, Maven POMs out there, because they can't use it anymore. And the promised transition of accounts to another provider just won't work for all people who entered an id of "org.scala-tools", because most other providers require that the person publishing an artifact also controls the domain name.

The whole thing is basically maximized for pain and wasted hours of transitioning, migrating and repacking.

Have a look at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3495303 for the circumstances how he "told" everyone he was leaving. I visited the Lift IRC channel an hour ago and asked what their stance was on Pollak leaving Lift/Scala. They had no idea and asked for a link. So much for "nobody stepped up for maintenance". Of course nobody can step up if nobody knows.

It is not acceptable that someone who expected that he would transfer the domain to the people maintaining it insulted him, but how can this be communicated to that individual if no body knows who it was. "Somebody insulted me" doesn't help to resolve that matter.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by zak_mc_kracken on Sunday January 22, 2012 @12:51AM (#3495791)
> After people finally figured out that he was leaving (almost no one knew of that) they offered to take over the complete responsibility, what happens? Suddenly he wants to keep the domain

This is in complete contradiction with what dpp said (he asked for help a few months ago and nobody answered). So either you or dpp is lying.

Considering that his call for help is well documented, I think you are the one spreading false information.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by soc88 on Sunday January 22, 2012 @02:11AM (#3495923)
Oh c'mon. I know and read that message too. How many people else did? Not many.

It is not like someone like dpp doesn't know how to get the right audience for his issues.

Additionally this wouldn't have been a solution as the domain still remained in his possession.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by tbsdy on Sunday January 22, 2012 @04:49AM (#3496162)
Please, tell us the point then.
Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by zak_mc_kracken on Sunday January 22, 2012 @12:48AM (#3495785)
You are over-dramatizing, and you are doing the exact same thing that the OP said: thinking you can add a "but" to what is a 100% personal decision.

Reread the comment above and take the time to understand it.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by nknight on Saturday January 21, 2012 @06:54PM (#3495078)
The "keys" in this case are his own property, and any banners he might want to put up are being put up on his own property, so your supposed point makes no sense.
Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by soc88 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @07:18PM (#3495144)
So you would expect to be totally within your rights if you would register windows-tools.com/net, ipod-library.com/net and use these sites to damage the reputation of the mentioned product?
Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by nknight on Saturday January 21, 2012 @07:26PM (#3495157)
You seem to be stuck on the idea that there's some sort of legally-enforceable trademark at issue, but you've provided no evidence of it. To even begin to claim a trademark, you must assert it, and I see no evidence of anyone asserting such a trademark. To actually enforce it in court, registration is required in the US and I'm sure at least some other countries.

You also have interpreted his statements as saying he will seek to harm the reputation of Scala, but his statements only imply that if you assume the worst about people. In other words, you're projecting.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by soc88 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @07:32PM (#3495177)
Then maybe you should actually read the text.

Apart from that, registering multiple common scala-* domains and then making them point to his blog instead of something actually related to the topic is pretty much the definition of domain grabbing.

Sure, he can do it and figure out if he gets away with it. But in my opinion it is just ethically and morally wrong to register domains which with popular names which are expected to be used by Scala-related projects and keep them to punish the whole community for something a single person did.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by bigiain on Saturday January 21, 2012 @08:40PM (#3495309)
You realise you're sounding a lot like you've never had to deal with the problems of the effectively single dns namespace before?

Trademarks don't automatically apply to domain names - since ordinary trademarks apply to a narrow protection of people offering "that same type of goods or services". ("Generic" trademarks exists, but need t meet much wider standards of public recognition than Scala-as-a-programming-language has.)

Apart from trademark disputes, which "The Scala Community" have no chance of winning here, domain names have _always_ been first come first served. If _you_ thought scala-tools.org was a worthwhile asset, you should have registered it before he did. Same with any scala-* domain.

Feel free to get huffy about whether or not you think he should have done things differently, but trying to frame this as some sort of abuse of domain name ownership is, frankly, naive...

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by soc88 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @10:00PM (#3495460)
I have no idea what your problem is, but feel free to completely ignore what I have written and write down your ramblings instead. The net is big enough for everybody, right?
Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by lmm on Saturday January 21, 2012 @05:52PM (#3494929)
He has the right to quit, but the domain is a .org, and its name is not his but that of the language; it should belong to the community. If he wants to stop running it that's fine, but he should let it lapse or sell it to someone who will maintain it for the community, not turn it into something else.
Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by nknight on Saturday January 21, 2012 @06:03PM (#3494959)
> the domain is a .org

That has no particular significance. The Big Three TLDs haven't had any special requirements or policies in many years.

> its name is not his but that of the language

The language's name is "Scala", not "scala-tools.org", but let's assume you just think any domain with "scala" in its name is effectively the name "Scala". I have some news for you:

"Scala" is also the name of a typeface, the student chapter of the American Library Association, part of human anatomy, a unit of area, a couple of music albums, a software company with no connection to the programming language, a couple of entertainment venues, two locations, a surname for I-don't-know how many people, and a snail.

> it should belong to the community

A "community" cannot actually own a thing. Who exactly do you think should have the domain? Who represents "the community"? And why exactly does this amorphous "community" have some special claim to one of an infinite number of domains that might be used for similar or entirely different purposes?

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by lmm on Saturday January 21, 2012 @08:59PM (#3495357)
>"Scala" is also the name of a typeface, the student chapter of the American Library Association, part of human anatomy, a unit of area, a couple of music albums, a software company with no connection to the programming language, a couple of entertainment venues, two locations, a surname for I-don't-know how many people, and a snail.

disingenous. He's not talking about repurposing the domain for any of those things.

>A "community" cannot actually own a thing. Who exactly do you think should have the domain? Who represents "the community"?

Once the community gets sufficiently large, a formal foundation like apache or the python software foundation. (Obviously for practicality it's fine for the domains of a smaller community to be owned by individuals, but they should act as custodians)

>And why exactly does this amorphous "community" have some special claim to one of an infinite number of domains that might be used for similar or entirely different purposes?

If you call your domain scala-tools and your site becomes known as a place to get scala tools you have a moral obligation to keep it about scala tools, or give it up and let someone else use the name. Doing otherwise would be cybersquatting - scala-lang may not be a single person's name, but it still means something.

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by soc88 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @06:42PM (#3495053)
Maybe someone should try to explain to you the concept of a "trademark".
Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by tankenmate on Saturday January 21, 2012 @07:00PM (#3495093)
I think that is one variant of his point and you have completely missed it. Who in the "community" should own the "trademark"? Did someone register it? Do "they" represent the community?
Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by soc88 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @07:11PM (#3495122)
The EPFL owns it, especially the logo he is also using. And no, registering is not always a requirement.
Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by nknight on Saturday January 21, 2012 @06:53PM (#3495076)
I can find no evidence of anyone registering "Scala" as a trademark for a programming language. www.scala-lang.org never indicates there is a trademark or uses any usual trademark symbol.

I expect I'll be receiving an apology for your condescending assault on my intelligence?

Re:I don't owe you scala-tools.org by soc88 on Saturday January 21, 2012 @07:14PM (#3495129)
Sorry. I think we should try having a constructive debate again, that was lost a bit it seems.