News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by roflyear on Saturday February 25, 2023 @09:57PM (#34942608)
Classic. What's the context for the poll? You're giving one party the benefit of the doubt but not the other.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by viraptor on Saturday February 25, 2023 @10:03PM (#34942643)
There is no context to that poll. That's the whole question. I was hoping there's more, but it looks like it was just done to create controversy and attention. It's a meaningless (yet loaded with subtext) question that the author had to realise will do what it did. And people like Scott can grab onto that and cause more havoc on top with a side of some ignorant spicy takes.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by mightyham on Saturday February 25, 2023 @10:49PM (#34942867)
I'm not making any claims about the accuracy of the poll results because I have no idea how it was conducted, but the question "Do you agree or disagree with this statement: 'It’s OK to be white.'?" is certainly not meaningless even if it's loaded. There is a very unambiguously correct answer to that statement and if there is a population with a significant amount of people answering "no" that clearly demonstrates something problematic about current public attitudes and race relations.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by paulryanrogers on Saturday February 25, 2023 @11:39PM (#34943077)
The question is a racist dog whistle. Knowing that I'd hesitate to answer in the affirmative even as a Caucasian. I'd probably decline to continue with the poll.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by autoexec on Sunday February 26, 2023 @07:21AM (#34944978)
Yeah, if all they had to choose from was a simple yes or no refusing to answer is the right move. Some answers need further explanation or else a lot of people will misunderstand you.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by roflyear on Sunday February 26, 2023 @11:47AM (#34946952)
Yes, but you have to realize that is you and other people will react or think differently - and you're starting to get at why this compromises the poll entirely.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by mightyham on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @08:10AM (#34968850)
I think you need to get off the internet for a little while. The world does not revolve around 4chan memes, and the phrase "it's okay to be white" does not signal that someone is secretly a racial supremacist.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by viraptor on Saturday February 25, 2023 @11:15PM (#34942978)
I agree, it's only unambiguously correct in vacuum with no social context. Unless you control for what possible extra meaning can be assigned or implied here, it's a terrible poll - that's why I called it meaningless (as a poll question). If that one doesn't resonate for some people, let's try some other examples that should have unambiguously correct answers: "Is it ok to say gay?", "Is it ok to be a proud boy?", "Is it ok to support uniformed workers?", "Is it ok to love children?", etc. Now add the actual social context you're thinking of... Are they still unambiguous?

A more meaningful one would be "do we still have issues with racism?" without a gotcha approach. (That the poll creator did not acknowledge)

Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by mightyham on Sunday February 26, 2023 @05:44AM (#34944567)
>it's only unambiguously correct in vacuum with no social context No it's not, lol. There is quite literally no social context where objecting to someone's given race is the correct moral choice.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by roflyear on Sunday February 26, 2023 @11:52AM (#34946990)
"it's okay to be white" is a troll that originated on 4chan. In that context yeah you can disagree with the phrase.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by mightyham on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:23AM (#34971091)
That actually doesn't at all justify disagreeing with the phrase. Having a problem with a 4chan troll campaign is a different issue (and one I suspect most people have little to no knowledge of). This can very easily be likened to BLM. It's ok to not fully agree with the organization/movement but to disagree with the phrase "black lives matter" is simply wrong.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by ipaddr on Saturday February 25, 2023 @11:00PM (#34942908)
Are we cancelling the people who made the poll? Are we cancelling and calling those who said yes racist? No. We're cancelling the person who said stay away from people who said that because it might offend those people?

Seems to make 2023 sense. The era of ignorance and racism.

Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by hackerlight on Saturday February 25, 2023 @11:08PM (#34942939)
> We're cancelling the person who said stay away from people who said that.

Factually wrong. He is saying to stay away from "Black people" in the abstract. It is plainly racist and there is no redeeming context in the video.

Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by ipaddr on Sunday February 26, 2023 @12:59AM (#34943463)
Redeeming? I thought that was a weird choice of words bar to set. So this person's video wasn't able to save you or people from sin.

"able to save people from sin, error, or evil" (oxford dictionary)

Calling his reaction plainly racist when the entire thing is highly racist is being dishonest with yourself and this conversation. The redeeming part of this video is calling out people who ignore racism when it suits them and point fingers when it doesn't. Racist publisher creates survey you ignore. Survey shows about 1/2 black population is racist. You ignore. Crazy guy says stay away from black people.. you call him racist. Same story but half of whites surveyed are racist against black. Would you have ignored it? Are you part of the problem or solution?

Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by hackerlight on Sunday February 26, 2023 @04:24AM (#34944214)
This is a lot of mental gymnastics over a simple point I was making. The post I was responding to falsely claimed that Adams was suggesting people stay away from only those Black people that allegedly held racist beliefs. I was merely pointing out that this was factually incorrect by highlighting that Adams was clearly talking about Black people in the abstract rather than only singling out Black racists.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by ipaddr on Sunday February 26, 2023 @09:28AM (#34945786)
Widen your len. They literally have produced the most racist survey that showed half the people responded in a racist way and you want to call out the person reacting to it? You want to call me out? Because he didn't qualify it by saying only the black people who responded when he prefixes the entire thing by telling you about the survey so you know who he referring to.

What is the point you are trying to make? That you are defending racist people by calling others racist for them.. and you are an ally to racism?

Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by mindslight on Sunday February 26, 2023 @10:29AM (#34946258)
Criticizing racism isn't automatically anti-racist. You seem to be assuming that it is, such that pinning the racism tag on the poll absolves Adams. This is fallacious.

It's unfortunate that the academic zeitgeist can be racist without suffering many repercussions, but the just answer is to hold the line of anti-racism rather than giving in and engaging in one's own racist rants.

Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by ipaddr on Sunday February 26, 2023 @05:57PM (#34950587)
You can't selectively hold the line. By letting some through you negate your neutrality. Your outrage needs to be broader or it becomes hollow.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by mindslight on Sunday February 26, 2023 @06:43PM (#34951015)
I can't figure out how you're getting "let some through" from what I said. In fact that seems to be exactly what you are doing by defending Adams's racist rant because it happened to be calling out other racism. It's possible to call out the original racism without going on a racist rant yourself, and if you want to be anti-racist that is what you need to do - otherwise one is just being a different flavor of racist.
Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by hackerlight on Sunday February 26, 2023 @07:37PM (#34951508)
> What is the point you are trying to make?

I have made the point twice already. You said something factually incorrect. I explained why it was factually incorrect. That's all.

Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by autoexec on Sunday February 26, 2023 @07:16AM (#34944944)
> There is no context to that poll. That's the whole question. I was hoping there's more

There is some context for the poll, or at least for that one question, and I think it's safe to assume that at least some of the people answering would be aware of it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/It's_okay_to_be_white

Re:‘Dilbert’ dropped by The Post, other papers, after cartoo... by viraptor on Sunday February 26, 2023 @02:48PM (#34948701)
Nuance in phrasing. We're in agreement I think. There's context to the phrase, but the poll itself provides no context or further explanations for the question.