"just eat less"
it's that easy. the people who don't do it are just stupid or lazy (in the mind of the fat haters)
Yes. Just do it.
You had a lot of extra fun stuffing yourself with food, you will have to pay the price for that at some point(either with hunger or with health problems if you don't lose the weight)
It's very simple to lose weight, it really is, just don't eat. The problem is that it's not fun(hunger is not fun, obviously).
But the bill comes for the extra fun you had with food, it's either hunger or serious health issues.
I hope you'll reconsider but if that's how you're going to behave there's no productive conversation to be had.
I can't imagine someone saying "the gravity theory of plane crashes is exploded" even though when we look at how to prevent plane crashes we look at other causes.
Yes, calorie imbalance is a thing, but you can be a 300 lb person who eats 2750 calories a day, also be a 200 lb person who eats 2750 calories a day, with each performing a similar amount of exercise.
While calories in/calories out will help anyone lose weight, for some, even with the advantage of math - its still much harder, sometimes an order of magnitude harder.
I've done this before, and I lose around 100 lbs, and I've kept off about 60 of it - but for the entire two years, I had a gnawing, burning pit of hunger whenever I was away. It never stops, and I never stopped being hungry. I just did my best to ignore it.
On top of that, look how many social occasions revolve around food, to stick to any essentially effective diet requires refraining in those situations. That's even harder. "oh, everyone is going for fast food after the thing, I guess I can just have some water? okay, I guess that's okay" because one fast food meal exceeds your calorie goal for the entire day.
Now you tell me, how easy is it to eat less if you never felt satiated, never stopped being hungry?
My point here, is while calorie counting and exercise works, there is clearly more going on than just that.
To me it seems to be a majorityu of cultural & calorie intake thing rather than a medical issue. Not to say it's easy (it's not) and not to say there aren't people with medical issues.
Us having enough calories available and the kinds of work around where people can lead a defacto life of leisure (by comparison to every other period of time).
Any time humans have an extended lack of scarcity the natural biological programming that makes someone fatter, takes over.
Also, love your username ^^
So yes, humans are a thermodynamic system, but that isn't a model that explains the dynamics of what your body does with it's tissues. It's more complex than that.
Additionally there's a moralizing component where people erase this complexity in order to blame people for their medical problems and frame it as an issue of irresponsibility.
when you say this, you reveal your ignorance of the biology that makes it far more challenging for some people to "eat less" than others, and that changes their metabolism to combat the weight loss if they do happen to "eat less" for some time.