Re:Justice Department says Google destroyed evidence related...
by dragonwriter on Friday February 24, 2023 @07:47PM
(#34932449)
> Just let the plaintiff or prosecuter decide what evidence they would have liked to find and instruct the jury to assume it was found.
We already have a form of that (and more). Rule 37(e) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, permitting a court, when finding intentional destruction of electronic evidence that should have been preserved, to presume, and/or instruct the jury to presume, that the evidence was adverse to the jury or to summarily dismiss the claim or enter a default judgement (depending on which side destroyed the evidence).
Literally, the court can decide “You destroyed evidence, you lose the case, game over”.
We already have a form of that (and more). Rule 37(e) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, permitting a court, when finding intentional destruction of electronic evidence that should have been preserved, to presume, and/or instruct the jury to presume, that the evidence was adverse to the jury or to summarily dismiss the claim or enter a default judgement (depending on which side destroyed the evidence).
Literally, the court can decide “You destroyed evidence, you lose the case, game over”.