News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Justice Department says Google destroyed evidence related... by jeremyjh on Friday February 24, 2023 @06:58PM (#34932013)
Just let the plaintiff or prosecuter decide what evidence they would have liked to find and instruct the jury to assume it was found. This would never happen again anywhere.
Re:Justice Department says Google destroyed evidence related... by gameman144 on Friday February 24, 2023 @07:40PM (#34932396)
This seems like some insane government overreach, though. Like, make the penalties for destroying evidence super steep and criminally liable sure, but it seems pretty wild that you could be convicted of a crime without evidence. In that case, the government has an incentive to destroy evidence and its paper trail.
Re:Justice Department says Google destroyed evidence related... by hugh-avherald on Saturday February 25, 2023 @06:22AM (#34935770)
I don't want to alarm you but (a) it's definitely possible to be convicted of a crime without evidence and (b) the only things stopping "the government" fabricating evidence are the government officials themselves.
Re:Justice Department says Google destroyed evidence related... by shadowgovt on Saturday February 25, 2023 @10:06PM (#34942661)
How would the government go about destroying evidence in a defendant's possession?

(If you mean "Has the government failed to meet its burden of disclosure regarding evidence in its possession:" yes, it occasionally happens. The significant incentive against it is that it's immediate grounds for a mistrial and incredibly embarrassing to a prosecutor's office that has it happen on their watch).

Re:Justice Department says Google destroyed evidence related... by dragonwriter on Friday February 24, 2023 @07:47PM (#34932449)
> Just let the plaintiff or prosecuter decide what evidence they would have liked to find and instruct the jury to assume it was found.

We already have a form of that (and more). Rule 37(e) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, permitting a court, when finding intentional destruction of electronic evidence that should have been preserved, to presume, and/or instruct the jury to presume, that the evidence was adverse to the jury or to summarily dismiss the claim or enter a default judgement (depending on which side destroyed the evidence).

Literally, the court can decide “You destroyed evidence, you lose the case, game over”.

Re:Justice Department says Google destroyed evidence related... by jefftk on Sunday February 26, 2023 @07:17AM (#34944951)
The issue here is that companies are not generally required to retain a records indefinitely, and if something was deleted as part of a standard retention policy (instead of specifically because of its contents) the normal "assume the worst" policy doesn't apply. Which is, I think, why lawyers are excited about a default of having a short retention period.

On the other hand, litigation generally comes with needing to put your deletion policy on hold, and it sounds like that didn't happen here?