News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by cornholio on Friday February 24, 2023 @02:23AM (#34921882)
But should Stanford really adopt constitutional standards for criminal proceedings if it's not holding a criminal inquiry?

One of the important conclusions of the "Me too" debacle was that victims cannot make their accusations in public - in fact, many tried, for many years - because they face a much higher cost of doing it than the agresor. It's only when they are organized as a group that their individual accusations gain power leaning on one another, otherwise each of them taken individually is only a (major) image cost for the accuser, up to removal from the field. The traditional criminal system was powerless to give them justice before this.

So as long as participation in this anonymous process is entirely voluntary for the accused and the texts are treated as entirely made up until proven true, then they can be interpreted as a way of organizing a larger number of anonymous victims who don't know of one another, and a way for management to get an early warning of things they need to look into more closely.

If a certain academic is accused by ten anonymous people of sexual harassment, it could be an organized smear campaign from a disgruntled student or peer. If, however, those accusations follow them across multiple departments and academic years, there might be more there than meets the eye.

There are no comments on this comment yet.