News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The next SOPA by snowwrestler on Friday January 20, 2012 @01:36PM (#3490567)
But I like to watch movies. I think a lot of movies are great--great enough to pay for them. Why should I shoot myself in the foot to keep someone else from shooting me in the foot?

This idea that the root cause of all bad legislation is political donations: it's wrong, and not supported by the data. The vast majority of political donations are made by people who are not lobbyists.

No one raised more political money in the history of this nation than Barack Obama during his presidential campaign, and the letter from his administration helped kill the bills. How about Rep. Issa and Sen. Wyden? Guess what, they got into office by spending donated money as well.

The problem isn't money, the problem is engagement. The tech industry, particularly on the Internet entrepreneurial side, has long prided itself on staying out of Washington. Well, now we see the consequence of that approach: it took a last-minute emergency OMG shitstorm to stop some bills--bills that could have easily been shaped, adjusted, or stopped much earlier if the industry had been engaged and paying attention.

The U.S. government is participatory. It will respond to citizen wishes, but only if citizens actively and continuously make their wishes known.

And it is inclusive. No matter how much you might think copyright should end, or that the MPAA should just go away forever and die, there are enough people who disagree with you that it's just not going to happen. Internet companies and advocates need to get comfortable with continuously engaging content companies in the legislative process, seeking common ground, and compromising.

IP law is not a winnable war. It is an ongoing negotiation that must be managed forever.

Re:The next SOPA by sounds on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:25PM (#3490827)
I disagree. IP law is a new term, so why not frame the debate around the original ones?

Copyright and patents have the U.S. Constitution to back them, but copyright has been diverted to serve large media companies -- through copyright term extensions that are frankly unreasonable.

Ideas are not property. Piracy is not theft. Copying and hacking should not be de facto crimes. Copyright should not be retroactively extended to re-copyright works that entered the public domain.

That doesn't make me extreme. To the contrary, it hilights the extreme political stance of the large media companies. I'll pick one as an example:

Rupert Murdoch, Jan 14, 2012:

"""So Obama has thrown in his lot withSilicon Valley paymasters who threaten allsoftware creators with piracy, plain thievery."

"Piracy leader is Google who streams movies free, sells advts around them.No wonder pouring millions into lobbying."""

Re:The next SOPA by zaphar on Friday January 20, 2012 @03:01PM (#3490980)
In practical terms how would you go about go about educating enough people to make a change? I ask this because while you're statements may be logical and internally consistent it bypasses the entire practical side of this whole debate. As soon as you enter the reality of the political arena the OP's points become valid. It's a negotiation.
Re:The next SOPA by sounds on Friday January 20, 2012 @03:11PM (#3491021)
I probably am misunderstanding you (please clarify), because what I hear you saying is: "in the political arena there will always be corrupt politicians, and there will always be large media companies paying them to re-introduce SOPA."

Yes, but it's easy enough to educate people about what's going on. Young people inherently understand the things I'd try to teach them -- but don't know what to do about it. Older people know what to do -- but don't care or pay attention to these issues. Networking with people can be rewarding and fun!

Re:The next SOPA by zaphar on Sunday January 22, 2012 @10:53PM (#3498930)
Actually I wasn't saying anything so much as asking. Given our current political realities what practical ways would you go about changing it? I ask because I truly do not know what practical ways would have any chance of success short of political negotiation.
Re:The next SOPA by Dn_Ab on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:49PM (#3490927)
>This idea that the root cause of all bad legislation is political donations: it's wrong, and not supported by the data. The vast majority of political donations are made by people who are not lobbyists.

You make a very bold statement without backing it with any line of reasoning or pointing to any supporting material. I am no expert in this matter so I can not know if you are wrong.

But in an older thread someone posted this excellent talk by Lawrence Lessig: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ik1AK56FtVc. It's well worth watching and counters your statement. His arguments are very well presented and reasoned. He also shows some supporting data.

Given that, I cannot attribute much weight to your statement.

Re:The next SOPA by rd108 on Friday January 20, 2012 @08:15PM (#3492147)
I just watched the video. Thanks for adding that link.
Re:The next SOPA by mrdingle on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:21PM (#3490806)
"Why should I shoot myself in the foot to keep someone else from shooting me in the foot?"

Because sometimes democracy is harder than just doing what you want to do.

"This idea that the root cause of all bad legislation is political donations: it's wrong, and not supported by the data."

Of course bad legislation has no root cause, but money surely contributes. $94MM in contributions last year focused on one issue.

"No one raised more political money in the history of this nation than Barack Obama during his presidential campaign"

I think you're confusing raising campaign money with taking political donations and going out to thousand dollar meals with lobbyists.

"The tech industry, particularly on the Internet entrepreneurial side, has long prided itself on staying out of Washington."

No we haven't, but we've certainly been busy working and trying to ignore it. Plus, they never really came after us directly before.

"IP law is not a winnable war. It is an ongoing negotiation that must be managed forever."

Thats a terribly lazy reason to not protest something. We give them power through direct consumer spending. One great way to reduce that power is to educate each other about where our dollars go.

Re:The next SOPA by scott_s on Friday January 20, 2012 @04:33PM (#3491314)
I agree with your conclusion, but your statement on political donations is contrary to my understanding of the process.

Donations don't literally buy votes, but what they do literally buy is face time. That is, people in Congress will hold fundraisers, and lobbyists pay to attend those fundraisers. The understanding is that the lobbyists who attend those fundraisers will have time to talk to the politician about the issues their clients care about.

This episode of Planet Money clearly demonstrates this: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2011/11/01/141913370/the-tues...

Now, if you have two sides to an issue, and only one side of that issue has active lobbyists who buy that face time with people in Congress, then you will have a situation where the people in Congress only understand one side of the issue.

Re:The next SOPA by kiba on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:24PM (#3490825)
The U.S. government is participatory. It will respond to citizen wishes, but only if citizens actively and continuously make their wishes known.

It is an opportunity cost for industries to be spending their money on lobbying instead of spending their money on R&D that will benefit society. Industries or citizens should not have to be constantly talking to representative in Washington to make sure that they will not do anything wrong when they're not looking.

The U.S. government may be participatory but only the one that shouts the loudest get heard.

Re:The next SOPA by PaulHoule on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:03PM (#3490720)
I also think that articles like that are counterproductive. The political class and most people will think we're a bunch of freaks if we talk like that.

Yes, Hollywood has done many things wrong -- the TV sector in particular is in long-term danger because the "bundling" business model of cable doesn't give consumers any way to give feedback about the quality of content. (I'd much rather watch Al Jazeera on Youtube and re-runs of Star Trek on AMZN Prime than watch Spongebob Squarepants, Adventure Time, CNN Fox News, or any of these reality shows about Coupons and Pawn Shops that never stop.)

On the other hand, Hollywood employs a lot of people in good, largely unionized jobs that aren't in danger of being exported to China. People like a lot of stuff that they make, and they invest a lot of money to make it -- they deserve to get some return on their investment.

The question is having some regime that's fair to everybody.

Re:The next SOPA by nitrogen on Friday January 20, 2012 @06:14PM (#3491681)
People like a lot of stuff that they make, and they invest a lot of money to make it -- they deserve to get some return on their investment.

I think that framing a discussion in terms of what people "deserve" is dangerous, because everybody has a different idea of what someone else deserves.

Re:The next SOPA by techiferous on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:37PM (#3490867)
> seeking common ground, and compromising

> negotiation

This. Realizing that the other side is not the devil and has legitimate interests of their own, even if they are clumsy in communicating them or harmful in their actions.

Viewing the other side as evil is lazy. Coming to authentic, common ground is very hard work.

Re:The next SOPA by beagle3 on Friday January 20, 2012 @03:15PM (#3491030)
Not this.

The truth is, there is a small group (MPAA/RIAA members) that can profit immensely from an act that is detrimental to the rest of society, and they pursue it.

It's about as "evil" as one basketball team can consider their opponent "evil"; the title is useless.

But just like on the basketball court, you have to do your best to defeat the other team, because they are doing their best to defeat you. And unlike the basketball court, they have so far had the upper hand every single time (e.g. DMCA, Mickey Mouse Protection Act a.k.a Sonny Bono Copyright Extension Act, government passes NBC commercials as official position, etc).

SOPA/PIPA is probably the first time they have had a real setback. I think they'll still win, unfortunately -- the overton window keeps shifting.

Re:The next SOPA by techiferous on Friday January 20, 2012 @04:32PM (#3491307)
I don't disagree with what you're saying.

I just think that if we techies try to understand some of the concerns of the copyright holders, we are in a position to propose legislation of our own. Until then, we are resigning ourselves to playing defense.

Re:The next SOPA by beagle3 on Friday January 20, 2012 @09:26PM (#3492344)
I was disagreeing with

> Coming to authentic, common ground is very hard work.

Or rather, with the implied meaning that coming to a common ground is at all desirable. It is not. They (MPAA/RIAA) out to get us (complement of MPAA/RIAA in the set of people) for monetary and political gain, and we should aspire to make it impossible for them to do that, and take back what they have already won (e.g. reverse the Mickey Mouse Protection Act)

Re:The next SOPA by steauengeglase on Friday January 20, 2012 @03:57PM (#3491189)
As Louis XIV said, never sign a treaty you don't intend to break and until the technological playground settles into a few large, relatively static players there is always room for a more lucrative treaty.
Re:The next SOPA by DanI-S on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:42PM (#3490897)
This idea that the root cause of all bad legislation is political donations: it's wrong, and not supported by the data. The vast majority of political donations are made by people who are not lobbyists.

If lobbyists' money didn't give their words extra weight, why would they donate any of it?

Re:The next SOPA by marchdown on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:57PM (#3490964)
There are two interlocked selection mechanisms: politicians select the issues they pursue, and sponsors select the politicians whom they want to give voice (and money).

In dumb evolutionary environments and in anthropics, there is no direct feedback between these two mechanisms. Bacteria get born, behave in a predefined way, and either procreate or die. Successful bacteria are not smart, but simply lucky. They are selected for fitness by a dumb process.

Similarly, activists enter politics to pursue certain interests, these interests do not change significantly, and then the newcomer either gathers enough support to get elected and influence public opinion, or doesn't. Sponsors select the politicians which have already taken a favorable stance, and help them get heard and get elected. Successful activists are those which pursue important issues which attract support and sponsorship.

I suspect that this is how the system is supposed to work, but it breaks when politicians can be adjusted, that is, bought.

Re:The next SOPA by scott_s on Friday January 20, 2012 @04:36PM (#3491322)
It's not that money gives lobbyists's words extra weight. Money allows their words to be heard. That is, without the contributions, you don't get to talk to the politician. Contributions are an entry fee to a meeting.
Re:The next SOPA by twentysix on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:40PM (#3490883)
The problem is not engagement. It is the duty of citizens to elect representatives and its the duty of legislature to make laws in accordance with the constitution. They are the ones who should be doing the research to find an optimum solution to the problem. It's their job after all. What you are suggesting is that we should guide them like children and show them the way so they can do what they were supposed to do in the first place. If they are our representatives why do we need someone else to represent ourselves to our representatives? When elections come there are'nt any better alternatives either. The power of voting is over rated doesnot amount to much.
Re:The next SOPA by khafra on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:07PM (#3490743)
I think you're right, but I hate that you're right. I wish government could just be sensible without needing a pressure group of sensible people riding herd on them forever.