News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by martincmartin on Friday January 20, 2012 @08:48AM (#3489416)
That's because it had servers in the U.S. SOPA is aimed at companies that keep their ops outside the U.S.
Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by bproper on Friday January 20, 2012 @08:51AM (#3489428)
I see. But the company was based in Hong Kong and the founders in New Zealand. Dutch, German and Slovakians citizens were arrested.

So as long as there are some operations based in U.S., they can get to all these folks?

MegaUpload was cited a number of times during the Judiciary Committee Hearing. But they mispoke more often than not.

Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by tzs on Friday January 20, 2012 @03:42PM (#3491124)
> I see. But the company was based in Hong Kong and the founders in New Zealand. Dutch, German and Slovakians citizens were arrested.

If the allegations in the indictment are true, then MegaUpload was likely violating the law in those countries to.

Contrary to widespread belief, the US is not the only country with copyright laws that criminalize commercial piracy.

Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by lomegor on Friday January 20, 2012 @09:04AM (#3489467)
Yes, if they have operations in the US they can be prosecuted, I believe. What's even worse for Megaupload in this case is that they had started legal proceedings themselves in the US. If they can use the US law, they have to abide them.
Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by Iv on Friday January 20, 2012 @10:50AM (#3489847)
So if my operations based in another country infringe US laws, they can get me and bring me there to be judged ? What do we call that when North Korea does that again ? Kidnapping.

If every website suddenly has to obey the laws of every country, it will be an interesting time.

Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by cbs on Friday January 20, 2012 @10:53AM (#3489857)
Please, lets be reasonable here. You're drawing a gigantic false equivalency between the extradition process based on international agreements, and the North Koreans black-bagging someone.

If every website suddenly has to obey the laws of every country

The DMCA was the US implementation of two international treaties.

Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by burgerbrain on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:51PM (#3490936)
" You're drawing a gigantic false equivalency between the extradition process based on international agreements, and the North Koreans black-bagging someone."

I'm sure those kidnapped will be glad to hear this.

Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by commandar on Friday January 20, 2012 @09:31PM (#3492359)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extradition

Not really a new or particularly controversial legal construct. The host country can refuse to extradite if they disagree with the charges.

Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by jonhendry on Friday January 20, 2012 @10:31AM (#3489756)
"So as long as there are some operations based in U.S., they can get to all these folks?"

If there are extradition agreements, sure.

Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by iamandrus on Friday January 20, 2012 @11:44AM (#3490066)
The US had jurisdiction since MU rented about 500 (?) servers in Virginia. If all of their servers were outside the US, they couldn't have done much about it.
Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by thebigshane on Friday January 20, 2012 @12:23PM (#3490241)
I don't think that's true. If we are talking about SOPA here, it wouldn't matter where the servers were. They were using a US based TLD MegaUpload.com and therefore their domain could be "erased". If they didn't have a domain address, then they could look at where the servers were.

Meaning: If they were MegaUpload.ch, they would have needed to SOPA to take the domain down. But they still would not have been able to seize the servers and arrest the operators.

tl;dr: Relating this to SOPA is a bit of a stretch.

Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by andyakb on Friday January 20, 2012 @11:23AM (#3489981)
This isnt entirely true. In the case of megaupload, I am pretty sure I read they had servers seized in the Netherlands and most [all?] of the arrests were done in foreign countries.

Further, I know it was definitely not the case with the online pokersites [PokerStars, FullTilt, and UltimateBet/Absolute] being shut down in April. AFAIK, ICANN is based in the US and oversees .com [among other] address. Because of this, with a court order, the US gov't can seize a domain name, with or without SOPA and they have already done this with online poker sites that have no physical presence in the United States.

Megaupload is in the same spot as those sites; they violated US law, a case was filed against them, and the US gov't seized their domain, servers, etc. Due process was followed. It is a little far-reaching the the US can so easily seize .com domains, and that is why you now will see very few online poker sites that serve the US use a .com [instead they use .eu or .ag, primarily]. If a company break US laws, the US gov't can pursue them, regardless of where they are. Whether or not they should be able to do that so easily is another question.

Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by SoftwareMaven on Friday January 20, 2012 @11:33AM (#3490017)
"""If a company break US laws, the US gov't can pursue them, regardless of where they are."""

Do you really mean that as broadly as it's written? Shouldn't it be "If a company break US laws on US soil, the US gov't can pursue them, regardless of where they are." while the Internet has made the world smaller, nations are still sovereign and should be treated as such. Frankly, I'm really tired of my government feeling like it has to police the world.

Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by andyakb on Friday January 20, 2012 @12:33PM (#3490276)
I dont mean it 100% literally and dont really write my posts to be semantically perfect and IANAL, so I hope they arent interpreted to be anything more than they are. The hard part is defining "on US soil," because with the internet companies have a much further reach than just their home base.

For the poker sites, they do not [and did not] have a physical presence in the US, but still involve US citizens in their business and it was argued that US banks were involved in money laundering and other crimes that took place "on US soil." So it is pretty similar to the megaupload case; if you dance around the word of the law and profit from US customers, the US gov't will likely pursue you if you are a big enough target

Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload by a9 on Friday January 20, 2012 @04:32PM (#3491305)
But the US did not order anyone to be arrested abroad or extradite anyone did they? They arrested one of the developers when he deplaned in Las Vegas.

These cases are not all the same. Different criminal laws are being violated, by people in different places, involving different US-based businesses.