Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload
by lomegor on Friday January 20, 2012 @09:04AM
(#3489467)
Yes, if they have operations in the US they can be prosecuted, I believe. What's even worse for Megaupload in this case is that they had started legal proceedings themselves in the US. If they can use the US law, they have to abide them.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload
by Iv on Friday January 20, 2012 @10:50AM
(#3489847)
So if my operations based in another country infringe US laws, they can get me and bring me there to be judged ? What do we call that when North Korea does that again ? Kidnapping.
If every website suddenly has to obey the laws of every country, it will be an interesting time.
Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload
by cbs on Friday January 20, 2012 @10:53AM
(#3489857)
Please, lets be reasonable here. You're drawing a gigantic false equivalency between the extradition process based on international agreements, and the North Koreans black-bagging someone.
If every website suddenly has to obey the laws of every country
The DMCA was the US implementation of two international treaties.
Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload
by burgerbrain on Friday January 20, 2012 @02:51PM
(#3490936)
" You're drawing a gigantic false equivalency between the extradition process based on international agreements, and the North Koreans black-bagging someone."
I'm sure those kidnapped will be glad to hear this.
Re:DOJ Didn't Need SOPA to Shutdown "rogue site" MegaUpload
by commandar on Friday January 20, 2012 @09:31PM
(#3492359)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extradition
Not really a new or particularly controversial legal construct. The host country can refuse to extradite if they disagree with the charges.