Re:The age of cargo cult Agile must end
by webmaven on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @04:26PM
(#34903051)
One approach is value-based contracts: "we'll work with you and charge X% of the value we deliver."
Re:The age of cargo cult Agile must end
by lelanthran on Thursday February 23, 2023 @02:24AM
(#34907813)
> One approach is value-based contracts: "we'll work with you and charge X% of the value we deliver."
Which still loses to the other bidders who say "$X in $Y months for $Z dollars".
No, not necessarily. It depends on how often and badly the org has been burned on past project failures.
Typically, the intermediate step is to tie some compensation (such as a bonus) to a particular metric, but why not just go whole hog?
Possible? Sure. Just like it's possible that I could win the national lottery.
In practice, multiple companies bid for contracts, and all of the bids have to be of the form "Deliver $X in $Y months for $Z dollars".
No company is going to accept "Choose us, and we'll work until you're happy with the product or you run out of money, whichever comes first".
Agile doesn't work where there's competition for the project. It can't, because the buyer of that project cannot evaluate "we'll work until your money runs out" against the other bids that state "$X in $Y months for $Z dollars".
Agile works well for internal teams that are sheltered from having to provide competitive bids.