News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spy Balloon Simulator by dang on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @04:16PM (#34887487)
"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

If you know more than others, that's great, but then please either (1) share some of what you know, so the rest of us can learn; or (2) don't post. Supercilious putdowns only make things worse.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...

Re:Spy Balloon Simulator by deepsun on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @05:48PM (#34888823)
But it's not a shallow dismissal. It gives a feedback of a particular shortcoming that makes the whole idea very misleading -- imagine a journalist making a conclusion that there's no way a baloon could fly over US territory based on such or similar simulation.

It's possible to fix that shortcoming and make the idea useful.

Re:Spy Balloon Simulator by dang on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:29AM (#34892358)
It was shallow in the sense that it didn't explain why. When people post comments that simply dismiss what someone else has done without being explaining why or teaching the reader, that's what we mean by shallow dismissal.

Both your comment and the GP's follow-up do contain a little more explanation—that's good—but even better would be to give more: walk us through what the issue is here, why it matters, and what an improvement would look like.

If you just focus on what you don't like about something, how useless or dumb it is, that puts a nasty torque on conversation which is hard to get out of.

Re:Spy Balloon Simulator by mlyle on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:44AM (#34898328)
> It was shallow in the sense that it didn't explain why

I was a passenger in a car en route to a funeral. I felt like the post was a little troublesome and I provided what context I could in the limited time I had to reply.

I do wish I had said "deeply misleading" instead of "useless", though. Which-- deeply misleading is even worse than useless, unfortunately.

> walk us through what the issue is here, why it matters, and what an improvement would look like.

In this case, there's a state actor (China) deliberately conflating weather balloons and surveillance craft. Typical weather balloons drift freely and cannot maneuver; capable balloons that can control their altitude can maneuver far more freely than most people expect. "Narrative" may sound sinister, but we have a deliberate counterfactual being used in the furtherance of surveillance and geopolitical conflict.

In turn, we have this "Spy Balloon Simulator - With real atmospheric data" that makes it pretty much impossible to control a balloon. It may be an accidental misstep, but it's at the very least a somewhat dangerous one.

Re:Spy Balloon Simulator by mlyle on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @08:02PM (#34890083)
The problem is, this “simulator” leads to very misleading conclusions because of the inability to control altitudes. It potentially fuels a false narrative that balloons drift at random and are not useful for surveillance, while Loon flew something like 40 balloons in a row to dwell over South America for sustained periods.

I’m sorry that the dismissal was short, but I did name the key problem.

Re:Spy Balloon Simulator by dang on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:19AM (#34892302)
If you had posted this in the first place it would have been better. Better yet would be to drop provocations like "false narrative", which implies something sinister, and just focus on contributing correct, interesting information about balloons (or whatever the topic is that you know about).

It's all too easy to underestimate the impact of putdowns in internet comments—impact on the readers, on other commenters, on the site as a whole, and (if they see it) on the author or creator. When we post putdowns it usually feels innocuous, as if we're just adding a little extra emphasis, but to the reader it often comes across as much larger than the rest of the comment put together—especially when there isn't much other information.