News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by foob on Thursday January 19, 2012 @02:45PM (#3486261)
I just won (#7 - foob) and I felt the need to post here to tell people that the person I spoke with from Quixey afterwards was very friendly and that I enjoyed talking to him. I was really just playing for the $100 but after speaking with him I felt like I should inquire about job opportunities. This is pretty much the opposite of what happened after my only other programming challenge experience.

I don't know if people saw this or not but a while back Instagram had a programming challenge inspired by the Darpa Shredder Challenge. They were offering a t-shirt for correct solutions and promised explicitly that every solution would get a personal response. They got more entries than they were expecting and didn't give t-shirts to everyone (which is somewhat understandable). What is much worse is that they didn't even bother to respond to correct solutions. I spent over an hour on it (including the bonus part) and they couldn't even send me a copy and pasted letter of something like "Thanks for playing! We got more attention than we expected and won't be able to give you a t-shirt but we do appreciate you playing." I would never consider working for a company that would respond to an unexpected number of solicited entries by simply ignoring them. I doubt that I'm the only person who was permanently turned off about Instagram by having my email and solution simply deleted without being looked at or responded to.

Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by eru on Thursday January 19, 2012 @09:39PM (#3488038)
I guess they should have written something like "We promise a personal response to the first 5000 correct solutions."
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by DannyPage on Thursday January 19, 2012 @01:24PM (#3485817)
Maybe it's just me, but I don't think you should have to sign-in to do the practices.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by mattwdelong on Thursday January 19, 2012 @01:36PM (#3485884)
Agreed. I'm not at all interested in giving my email out just to see what this is all about.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by alphamale3000 on Thursday January 19, 2012 @03:14PM (#3486431)
Mailinator, anyone?
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by StavrosK on Thursday January 19, 2012 @06:06PM (#3487353)
33mail.com is what I swear by.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by Liron on Thursday January 19, 2012 @01:39PM (#3485896)
I agree, we will get around to implementing more functionality for cookie-only users.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by babarock on Friday January 20, 2012 @06:18AM (#3489105)
Why not make the logging in process easier? I don't want to register to your website, but I wouldn't mind authenticating with my Google open-id.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by bjornsteffanson on Thursday January 19, 2012 @02:58PM (#3486334)
Agreed. This is where I quit.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by manmal on Thursday January 19, 2012 @05:14PM (#3487077)
+1
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by translocation on Thursday January 19, 2012 @03:58PM (#3486665)
Haha, just won- and the algorithm happened to be one that was posted on the front page of HN earlier this week! It just goes to show, there's no reason to get work done when you can be reading articles on HN- it could turn out to be important.

But I have to say, I haven't heard of Quixey before- it looks like they're building a search engine for software. Are they just trying to replace platform-specific app markets, or is it something trickier than that?

Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by Liron on Thursday January 19, 2012 @04:23PM (#3486799)
Right now, all your devices are magic wands. It would be better if they were genies. We do wish-to-spell conversion.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by CJefferson on Thursday January 19, 2012 @01:01PM (#3485687)
Unless this has been changed since last time, there should be a big proviso. You can only get money if you live in the US. This should really be made clearer, earlier.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by Liron on Thursday January 19, 2012 @01:05PM (#3485712)
We're currently sending to any PayPal email.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by maccylo on Thursday January 19, 2012 @01:04PM (#3485710)
This isn't right - they gave money to people outside of US last two times.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by theycallhimtom on Thursday January 19, 2012 @02:14PM (#3486092)
Won the $100 :). It took me about 15 minutes start to finish. You have to do 3 practices then wait a bit before you can do the real thing.

You are given about 10 lines of code and need to change one line to make it correct. The problems are things like binary search, topological sort, shortest paths, etc.

Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by Liron on Thursday January 19, 2012 @03:32PM (#3486534)
$400/hour isn't bad :)
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by greenpizza13 on Thursday January 19, 2012 @01:09PM (#3485732)
Doing this ONLY is python is a shame.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by artoonie on Thursday January 19, 2012 @01:28PM (#3485831)
Agreed, I just lost because of improper python syntax. Hardcore C would be more fun, with memsets and frees such that bugs can exist in memory management.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by eridius on Thursday January 19, 2012 @08:20PM (#3487817)
Yeah. I'm no Python programmer, so I screwed up one of the practices by writing `set.push(node)` instead of `set.add(node)`. Luckily that didn't matter on the challenge itself (except for the wasted seconds checking all my assumptions about what the python functions were doing).
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by jholman on Thursday January 19, 2012 @06:13PM (#3487378)
It sure would be nice if it didn't require Skype. Still, I'm enjoying doing the practices.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by sirclueless on Thursday January 19, 2012 @08:33PM (#3487862)
Does it actually require Skype? That's how they plan on notifying people, but there's also a big countdown board you can watch if you like.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by jmilloy on Thursday January 19, 2012 @02:13PM (#3486087)
I tried the practices, and I didn't like it because they don't provide sample input, and you can't test your changes in browser. Most of my seconds are spent copying and pasting, and setting up sample input. I guess other people are more perfect typists, but I make typos and so my solutions were often wrong if I didn't test them.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by jakubw on Thursday January 19, 2012 @03:00PM (#3486343)
I don't think testing would be of much help. These challenges are so designed that there is precisely one error in the function and precisely one way to fix it and either you notice it or you don't. If you were able to test your changes on the fly you could just as well try all the different modifications you can think of (of which there aren't many) without thinking too much.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by gibybo on Thursday January 19, 2012 @06:07PM (#3487356)
I also just won (gibybo) and am pleased with the process. Overall it was smooth and what I expected, although it would have been cool if the challenge problem I got had sample input/output like some of the practice ones.

My strategy for those who might benefit: I checked out the profiles of all the previous winners today and found that the challenge question was always one of three. I looked up the algorithms and practiced by implementing a python version of each, noting where the tricky parts were. Then when I entered the challenge I used my reference python version and compared them. I was a bit lucky in that the challenge code was roughly laid out the same way as I happened to do it earlier.

Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by kruhft on Thursday January 19, 2012 @01:53PM (#3485994)
I don't really feel like registering for the practices, so how does this work? Do they give you a piece of code that has a bug in it and you're supposed to find it and fix it?
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by nfriedly on Thursday January 19, 2012 @03:46PM (#3486614)
Yea, prettymuch. You have to complete 3 practice runs correctly first, and then you can do the actual challenge. (Over skype, apparently)

The practice runs were all 5-10 lines of python where exactly one line had to be changed or added to correct the bug. I didn't come across any syntax errors, just logic errors, so I finished the practice runs pretty easily despite having almost 0 python experience. (I did miss one because I was too slow though. I found the bug and correctly guessed at the python syntax to fix it, but it took me 67 seconds.)

Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by habudibab on Thursday January 19, 2012 @02:04PM (#3486047)
Would it be possible to show some examples on the page? Like previously corrected bugs?
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by Liron on Thursday January 19, 2012 @02:19PM (#3486127)
Good idea. Check out the video here: http://blog.quixey.com/2011/10/03/quixey-challenge/
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by habudibab on Thursday January 19, 2012 @02:31PM (#3486196)
Which is staged. I wonder whether the real challenges are in similar style and difficulty. Looking at the problem in the video it would help to just quickly pull out template code and compare it. Would help to have an easier way to know whether this is something I could accomplish or is completely over my head.

$100 bucks, I could need those.

Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by weaksauce on Thursday January 19, 2012 @03:15PM (#3486446)
similar in scope and, depending on your grasp of the algorithm and python, roughly the same difficulty +/- a little bit.
Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by o2sd on Thursday January 19, 2012 @08:21PM (#3487818)
1. Register (with email) for practices - THAT INFORMATION WAS NOT PROVIDED BEFOREHAND 2. Python only - THAT INFORMATION WAS NOT PROVIDED BEFOREHAND 3. Skype required - THAT INFORMATION WAS NOT PROVIDED BEFOREHAND

-1 fail and don't send me any spam on my email addy.

Re:Quixey Challenge: Fix a bug in 1 minute to win $100. Refe... by jodrellblank on Thursday January 19, 2012 @09:36PM (#3488030)
You're wrong on two counts:

"The algorithm will be implemented as a Python 3.x function". - The instructions page, the first item. (http://www.quixeychallenge.com/instructions).

About page: "Add Skype user quixeychallenge as a contact. A working microphone and speakers/headphones are required. [..] We'll Skype call you when it's your turn."

And since the registration form is required before you do anything, and it is one form needing an email address, I think that counts as 'telling you about the need for an email address before you get involved' too.