Show HN: Sora, Personal Publishing Platform
We wanted to create, to express ourselves without being judged either by strangers or some algorithm. We wanted our own space on the internet, where our photos and words would matter.
So we started to build an app that can showcase our content, without having to pick a platform. You can use Sora to publish a few different content types.
- Blog - Polaroid - Poster - Microblog
You can either display them all on your Sora profile as a summary (like mine https://topcat.sora.city), or put any of them forward for the world to see.
We plan to run this app for a long time and looking for feedback, so let us know what you think! ([email protected], or link on website)
---
Our stack today is Node, Typescript, NextJS, atomic CSS, with everything stored on Supabase.
(
56 comments
| 14 points
| on HN
)
1. What are your funding plans? If you plan on being free, what sort of user data will you be selling to pay for your costs?
2a. You mention on the bottom that Sora is Forever: "We're building Sora because we need a place to showcase our content too. We're bootstrapped and in for the long run." What sort of longevity plans do you have in case your servers/your backups/your company/your team goes under?
2b. Do the users get to own their data and move it elsewhere? Is your software FOSS so that users can run their own instances?
1: Won't sell any data, ever. Bootstrapped for now, user funded once we scaled up. We might temporary suspend signups at a point to ensure uninterrupted service.
2a: Good callout, will update the site with future plans!
2b: We're actively working on making content exportable, so you'll be able to take all of your stuff. No short term OSS plans, but might consider down the road!
Appreciate the questions!
Until someone buys the company, and the new owner sells the data. We have all heard this before.
Although this has nothing to do with selling users data—will work on our tos to communicate our expressed intents more clearly.
If the system were open source, decentralized, and/or if user PII was end to end encrypted then you could prove you literally lack the technical means to collect or sell data.
All data that is valuable and technically able to be sold, will eventually be sold.
Can you give me a ballpark?
Is this clearly stated in the terms and condition, including what happens if you sell the company in the future?
If it's not, then your words are meaningless, sorry.
> So we started to build an app that can showcase our content, without having to pick a platform.
So… you built a platform in order to not have to pick a platform? I’m not sure I understand.
It’s also not clear to me from the landing page what Sora is, other than maybe yet another blog hosting service.
Naming is hard, you won't be tied to this "platform".
[1]: https://jisho.org/word/%E7%A9%BA-1
Please remember that Sora is (and will remain) completely ad-free, and it was built by only a few people. We aren't a big company (yet ;) and we aren't vc-backed.
Why is your software worth $100+ a year to me? I can go with Ghost and save $1 a month over your price.
I also use this as my "share" site, and for a bunch of other uses, so my ~2gb of image hosting is just a fraction of that yearly $60.
The major catch is they don't offer dynamic image resizing. I only resize my images to a few standard sizes and just use a small script to resize + upload in one shot.
I don't even know WTF I'm "try[ing] for free, no credit card required", this looks more sleazy than pr0n sites to be giving out card numbers to.
For however much of my money they want (they don't say), that money would be better spent purchasing a proper web hosting plan with a proper hosting provider and registering a proper domain name with a proper domain registrar. I would really have my own space on the internet then.
> You'll be able to download a snapshot of your content, store and view it locally with a light version of Sora.
Leaving a blog engine should be no different than changing an email provider. Point DNS somewhere else and optionally backup/restore via IMAP to the new service.
First of all, I love the clean design + aesthetic. I also like the fact that you don't seem married to one format, unlike most blogs, which are married to...linear blogs only. I hope this leads to more types -- in particular, I dream of having a CMS that can create a site as powerful as Gwern's [0] without the headache of having to maintain it. Things like table-of-contents, built-in citation tools, popovers to other pages, etc. sound like they could work well, if they were a separate type from what you currently offer. But this is just me wishing and dreaming.
If I had to articulate anything, it would be that I hope (but do not see) you offer support for custom domains? Custom domain support typically is a given with paid plans. I can see this being future-work related though.
Typographically, I really like everything. The design is really fresh. It looks well thought-out. I genuinely really like everything you've done!
[0]: https://gwern.net/problem-14
> Things like table-of-contents, built-in citation tools, popovers to other pages, etc.
This is on our roadmap already. You will be able to create a book-like page with Sora later.
> If I had to articulate anything, it would be that I hope (but do not see) you offer support for custom domains?
This is also coming. We just have to change providers for this as Vercel doesn't support multiple external domains on a single project.
Let's say - I'm an average internet user who likes to create and share content and yes I've been using social media platforms for it because for us, there aren't many other options these days.
I don't think I need to tell you what makes me so angry about social media because you know it all better than me.
On Sora, I can create a personalized profile with the info I want to share about myself and I currently have two blogs of different topics, a microblog for my random thoughts and a polaroid collection and you can reach all of them when you open this same profile. For me, sharing the profile page with all my content on it, too, gives the feeling that I have some kind of "online personality" I build and control, in other words, I can be fully seen - it's something social media would never give me, especially because I have to share all my content on separate sites.
It's everything I want to share at one place. I have many options to customize my stuff, another thing I, the average user would never get from the big platforms.
You see Sora simply as a blog engine and you've seen enough of those already.
Difference is that it's much more complex than that. It's something I've been looking for for years and I couldn't find anything similar to it.
What I want to say... is that when you can build your very own blog engine or you can find a more complicated one that satisfies your needs then Sora isn't for you and that's cool.
For those who are looking for a less toxic alternative to social media (and they don't necessarily need it to be another form of social media), it could be something interesting. (Even when you can but you don't want to put all that effort into creating it yourself, it's worth a look - and when you don't understand what should you see then again, it's not for you and that's still cool.)
I still think it has a lot to offer, just look at it from a different perspective.
Even with your description I don’t get it. If I make a website, which is easy to do nowadays, I can also share that link.
What exactly is the revolution here?
> [if] you can build your very own blog engine or you can find a more complicated one that satisfies your needs then Sora isn't for you
Why did you opt for Supabase instead of headless CMS like Netlify?
Why did you opt for Atomic CSS instead of Tailwind?
I've been using Tailwind since 2019, and I would recommend Tailwind to anyone, but I still don't understand why people always try to get others to use it over something else. Is something wrong with Atomic CSS?
We love tailwind as everyone else in their right mind, but we're using our own flavor of the concept I started years ago: https://fractures.dev
On the why: We plan on having a lot of novel, one off interfaces, which TW isn't just right for. CSS is. We also don't have an frontend scaling problem, as I'm the sole developer here.
I think you misunderstand Tailwind, but there's nothing wrong with your technology choice. :)
The $9.99 hop from basic blog to micro blog, polaroid, poster is to high. I don't know what exactly I'm getting for that price. Even if there was a credit card gated trial, that would be too high friction for people.
Especially given there is no transparency about the team, investors, customer success stories to help with trust.
Go here https://topcat.sora.city/found Tap an image, use the back button of the browser and you’re all the way back to the client-side no-cache loading of the profile.
Or again, tap an image, try to copy the description. It swipes to the next image or something (on mobile). Very weird usability.
Or tap one of the last images, close it with the close button and Safari will scroll all the way to the top again.
Imho, the SSR experience of most personal blogs is quite important if you want to compete with other platforms, because broken back buttons and obnoxius content loading is what you get from places like Medium or LinkedIn. A SPA is totally the wrong way to go here I think.
In short: it looks nice but feels shitty.
> Or again, tap an image, try to copy the description. It swipes to the next image or something (on mobile). Very weird usability.
Will spend some time on this too—not too easy to keep the swiping natural and maintain all expected behaviors.
> Imho, the SSR experience of most personal blogs is quite important if you want to compete with other platforms, because broken back buttons and obnoxius content loading is what you get from places like Medium or LinkedIn. A SPA is totally the wrong way to go here I think.
Pages are loading from cache most of time (sub 100ms), but SSR does need some time to populate SEO data for bots. But agreed that perceived speed is very important, we have some tweaks coming in this area as well.
Actually I'm on mobile right now and I was impressed how speedy it was.
> Go here https://topcat.sora.city/found
> Tap an image, use the back button of the browser and you’re all the way back to the client-side no-cache loading of the profile.
> Or again, tap an image, try to copy the description. It swipes to the next image or something (on mobile). Very weird usability.
Works for me just fine (maybe been fixed in the meantime?) on Firefox on android.
> Or tap one of the last images, close it with the close button and Safari will scroll all the way to the top again.
Again no problem here on Firefox for android.
> Imho, the SSR experience of most personal blogs is quite important if you want to compete with other platforms, because broken back buttons and obnoxius content loading is what you get from places like Medium or LinkedIn. A SPA is totally the wrong way to go here I think.
> In short: it looks nice but feels shitty.
I don't agree compared to many other offerings this feels quite snappy IMO.
This is actually hilarious though. Terrible for a ToS, but hilarious.
> Sora isn't available in Belarus, Hungary and Russia.
Why these countries in particular? I guess it's about having oppressive/authoritarian regimes and being in Europe, but why to restrict it that way?
Edit: or perhaps it's because of the war, but Hungary doesn't seem to be involved as much. Though maybe I missed something there.
It's more like a principle question than anything else—we know it won't make a dent in the world, but we aren't comfortable providing service for countries that openly pro-war.
It looks like this could be:
Creators use a dynamic system for creating/publishing
Readers consume a static website that’s is generated incrementally upon create, edit, etc of a writer.
And how did you determine whether there would be a market for this? Was it more something you built for yourself, or did you have some feeling there would be an audience for this on HN (or elsewhere)?
> Was it more something you built for yourself, or did you have some feeling there would be an audience for this on HN (or elsewhere)?
It was 100% for ourselves at the start, but figured others would love it too, so second time I built it to scale. HN is not especially our target audience, but wanted to show it off, stress-test and get at least some outside feedback. :)