Email spam is illegal (CAN-SPAM Act). I hope that one day spamming peoples websites is also illegal.
So it's not criminal to use Xrumer but in my opinion people who use it are on the same moral footing as common email spammers.
CAN-SPAM didn't stop spam. Bayesian spam filtering did.
Every little annoyance in life shouldn't be subject to federal regulation.
Really? Not taking out some big botnets? Not a move away from email and onto social networks? This article suggests that email spam, at a three year low, is still at 70% of all email.
(http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9222447/Symantec_says...)
Also this isn't a little annoyance, it's wasting time and resources for everyone just like email spam is. Daily me and some volunteers on my site spent time cleaning up the junk that these blackhats use.
Not that I don't share your frustration. I run a small wiki that was so overrun by spam I had to install reCaptcha. Now the few people that still try and spam are actually doing the public a service by transcribing books. :)
Today of all days, be careful what you wish for.
Even so I feel a bit like playing devils advocate here, but Xrumer profile creation seems to me one of the least annoying activities in comparison to blog comments or other "visible" activities.
Plus the "illegal" argument is always a double edged sword. Just imagine someone else Xrumer'ing your own website and the consequential explaining you have to do afterwards. As soon as Google (or law...) declares a specific tactic as bann-worthy people will use it against their competitors.
While this tactic doesn't always work, the article's author was quick to mention that given a relatively young site, it can be extremely helpful in getting rid of the competition.
I thought that was a very dickish thing to do.
BlackhatSEO might not be illegal, but is ethically and morally wrong, plain and simple. And it makes the internet a crappier place. That's a good enough excuse to go on a BlackHat SEO crusade.
The problem is that link spammers like to sound tougher than they are so they say they do blackhat seo instead of what they're really doing, which is grey. Link spam won't send you to jail. Hacking a site can send you to jail.
I've spammed millions of links in the last few years, and I am most definitely not a real blackhat.
Blackhat SEO is using programs like Xrumer and Scrapebox to build backlinks en masse, hiding content from search engine spiders by inspecting user agents, and building low-quality content farms of keyword-laden articles. Phishing and credit card fraud are totally separate.