In a winner take all system, if there are more than two candidates, the dominant effect is the spoiler effect, where having more similar candidates makes it less likely that any will win. This means that anything more than two parties is degenerate, which implies that only the dominant eigenvector of political opinion will ever be reflected in an election. (Which in the US is typically the culture wars/identity politics, unless the economy is falling apart.)
I believe in the approval voting that you mention, there's a situation where candidate C would be able to win, which is also interesting.
That sounds like an excellent outcome. They might actually have to talk to each other, work out solutions that work for everyone, and refrain from doing things they can't all agree on.
There are certain due process, etc, arguments you can make at the edges, but the fundamental idea of SOPA/PIPA are squarely Constitutional.
Only in part. Only downloaded goods use the internet as a medium for commerce. The rest of the time, it's for communication (speech).
The regulations in question allow the government to censor websites, something that they are not given the power to do in the establishment clause, and are also strictly forbidden from doing in the first amendment.
If the bills simply entailed the power to require websites to take down IP violating content, then what you say would be true.
The fundamental ideas are not constitutional. I suggest you read the constitution. (Seriously, it was meant to be read. It doesn't take lawyers or judges to interpret it, it is written in pretty plain language.)
What does a prohibition on establishing a national religion have to do with DNS blocking? Perhaps metaphorically, unlimited-copyright is the religion of many politicians, but legally that seems like a stretch...
Compared to other government who actually do have complete unlimited power, your statement looks like a gross exaduration.
Do we have any other large decision-making systems that are proven to work? Because scale really seems to be the problem.
Many of these really egregious bills are unpopular with the majority of americans, but their opinions are not represented by the actions of government. There's little they can do to get real reformers elected because the "two party" system focuses on immaterial differences between the parties and on these issues the parties are pretty close. Most democrats and republicans voted for the PATRIOT ACT (and its renewal and extension under Obama) as well as NDAA, etc.
I'd love for someone to find a way to make democracy work. If there were a way to keep the US government constrained to the powers enumerated for it by the constitution, then we wouldn't have these problems.
But the only "checks and balances" on the government are all part of the government, and thus have long ago been compromised, there's no real oversight.
That's the fundamental problem.
If SOPA is "defeated" it will just rise up under another name in a few months.
SOPA itself is only the latest attempt to do this- they've been attempting to gain this level of control over the internet using the excuse of fighting terrorism for several years now.