Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by polemic on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @03:06AM
(#3478586)
Physics might be pure, but Biology is fking amazing.
Makes me ponder my own place in the scheme of things - made up of many multicellular components, myself a component of a society, itself one of many that make up the Human species, one of many that form the ecology of this planet
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by dangrossman on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @08:07AM
(#3479431)
> Is the universe actually a giant quantum computer? According to Seth Lloyd—Professor of Quantum-Mechanical Engineering at MIT and originator of the first technologically feasible design for a working quantum computer—the answer is yes
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by ars on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @03:39AM
(#3478651)
It was a latent ability. Some yeast already has the ability to make multi cellular colonies.
When this was first published (on June 23 - not sure why it's back in the news) there was a section of criticism saying they should have used an organism without that ability. But I don't see this section in the wired article.
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by tylerritchie on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @04:21AM
(#3478743)
>... not sure why it's back in the news ...
The paper [1] was just published, the first round in the news was due to the presentation of their findings, but not the publishing of any papers (as near as I can tell). Thankfully it's an open-access article.
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by lusr on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @04:45AM
(#3478834)
I didn't quite know how to interpret "latent ability". Reading the article, apparently yeast used to be multicellular, which is a pretty valid criticism of this experiment having meaningful results in terms of how single-celled organisms evolved into multicelluar organisms.
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by padobson on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @07:31AM
(#3479286)
This comment seems to assume that evolution can only go in one direction - from simple forms of life to more complex ones. If a complex form of life evolves to become simpler and then evolves again to become more complex, then there's just as much to be learned from following a line of evolution that increases complexity.
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by ars on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @08:16AM
(#3479463)
If you look at those "simpler" forms of life you find that the genes are not gone, but rather they are disabled.
An example is Neoteny - the genes for adult forms are still there, but are unused.
That's why I don't think much of this experiment - I bet the genes for multi cellular life were already there, and just needed reactivation - which happened randomly (perhaps due to environment, or perhaps they always activate, but just for short times, and this experiment selected for those with the longest or easiest to trigger activation), but no new genes were needed.
To do this experiment properly do a DNA sequencing of the original and final forms. And I'm actually quite surprised that they didn't do that - wouldn't it be very useful to know which genes create multi cellular life? But I bet the genetic diff between them is tiny - just enough to activate genes that are already there in the starting yeast.
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by ZenPsycho on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @09:11AM
(#3479706)
DNA isn't quite exactly like a program that you compile into a living organism. The conditions for its reproduction and expression are partially determined by its environment- so a shift from single celled from multi-celled life might not be able to be pinned on any particular gene or set of genes as a direct cause. You might end up with what is essentially the same sequence, with different parts now triggered by a slightly different proportion of a particular protein present within the cellular membrane.
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by lusr on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @08:03AM
(#3479397)
You are absolutely correct, and it's a comment I anticipated, which is why I qualified my original statement: "meaningful results _in terms of_ how single-celled organisms evolved into multicelluar organisms". (Although in fairness, it probably gives a hint and will certainly lead to future experiments that may provide the beginnings of an answer.)
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by snippyhollow on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @04:16AM
(#3478728)
It is back on the news because: “Experimental evolution of multicellularity.” By William C. Ratcliff, R. Ford Denison, Mark Borrello, and Michael Travisano. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Jan. 17, 2012.
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by radarsat1 on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @10:41AM
(#3480208)
This is wonderful. It is so simple, and takes a short enough amount of time, that it would make a fantastic lab experiment for high school students. Every day, remove the heaviest yeast and place it in a new environment and feed it. After 2 months, see that the yeast has formed into a larger organism.
If this is highly repeatable, it could have a great role for science education.
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by gldalmaso on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @10:49AM
(#3480249)
An honest question: aren't there potentially dangerous repercussions in breeding multicelular organisms like that? Could an innofensive organism become dangerous for us if it suddenly became more efficient and specialized?
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by tintin on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @11:30AM
(#3480470)
From the article: "An evolutionary transition that took several billion years to occur in nature has happened in a laboratory, and it needed just 60 days."
When these transitions only took 60 days, why not take another look at the 'several billion years'? Maybe life did form much faster under certain conditions.
Re:Multicellular Life Evolves in Laboratory
by Sandman on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @12:42PM
(#3480832)
Ah. Sorry, I didn't quite understand you the first time.
Maybe life did form much faster under certain conditions.
You mean multicellular life here, obviously. Yeah, as the experiment shows, it probably did form fast under the right conditions. It's all about genes. If being a part of a multicellular organism allows one cell's genes to spread more rapidly, than that cell is going to have an incentive to be in a group.
Makes me ponder my own place in the scheme of things - made up of many multicellular components, myself a component of a society, itself one of many that make up the Human species, one of many that form the ecology of this planet
http://www.amazon.com/Programming-Universe-Quantum-Computer-...
When this was first published (on June 23 - not sure why it's back in the news) there was a section of criticism saying they should have used an organism without that ability. But I don't see this section in the wired article.
For example:
http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/80beats/2011/06/23/yeast-c...
http://www.sciencenews.org/view/generic/id/331789/title/Mult...
The paper [1] was just published, the first round in the news was due to the presentation of their findings, but not the publishing of any papers (as near as I can tell). Thankfully it's an open-access article.
[1] http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1115323109
An example is Neoteny - the genes for adult forms are still there, but are unused.
That's why I don't think much of this experiment - I bet the genes for multi cellular life were already there, and just needed reactivation - which happened randomly (perhaps due to environment, or perhaps they always activate, but just for short times, and this experiment selected for those with the longest or easiest to trigger activation), but no new genes were needed.
To do this experiment properly do a DNA sequencing of the original and final forms. And I'm actually quite surprised that they didn't do that - wouldn't it be very useful to know which genes create multi cellular life? But I bet the genetic diff between them is tiny - just enough to activate genes that are already there in the starting yeast.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dictyostelid
If this is highly repeatable, it could have a great role for science education.
When these transitions only took 60 days, why not take another look at the 'several billion years'? Maybe life did form much faster under certain conditions.
Maybe life did form much faster under certain conditions.
You mean multicellular life here, obviously. Yeah, as the experiment shows, it probably did form fast under the right conditions. It's all about genes. If being a part of a multicellular organism allows one cell's genes to spread more rapidly, than that cell is going to have an incentive to be in a group.