Re:Clojure Turns 15 panel discussion video
by jjnoakes on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:16PM
(#34779716)
> treats you like an adult who can make responsible decisions on their own
I have to disagree with this characterization. It also seems a bit patronizing.
Having more choice can be good in some cases, and having fewer choices can be good in other cases. One isn't treating you less like an adult than the other.
Re:Clojure Turns 15 panel discussion video
by KingMob on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @06:35AM
(#34787999)
> doesn’t force me to follow a certain style or paradigm; it provides many different choices (“providing more” instead of “taking away”) and treats you like an adult who can make responsible decisions on their own.
This is really not correct. Certain choices Hickey made, prevent you from coding as you like. E.g., Hickey doesn't allow strong reader macros or inheritance in Clojure.
But it has also been a fun and liberating experience, after I went down the static type route for some years. I feel like Clojure just doesn’t get in my way and doesn’t force me to follow a certain style or paradigm; it provides many different choices (“providing more” instead of “taking away”) and treats you like an adult who can make responsible decisions on their own.
Although I missed the linguistic art of domain modelling through type definitions, spec gave me some of that back and even provides stuff like generative testing, which is pretty awesome. Of course, it is not meant as a replacement for static typing and has a different philosophy (see Rich Hickeys talks about it), but for me it is the best of both worlds.
The dynamic development style is something that I experienced before through learning Lisp/Scheme and it is also one of the thing that I enjoy most about Clojure. Coding “experimental”, building functions from individual pieces that I iteratively design using the REPL as my assistant (which actually means - as parent wrote - communicating with it from the editor itself, which we mostly do), feels so natural and I would miss it now that I am so used to it.