News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Loyal to the Company by AlbertCory on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:52PM (#34777268)
My Dad worked for Swift & Co. for 45 years. Nonetheless, when I quit my first job, he said to me, approvingly, "They're not loyal to you, so why should you be loyal to them?"

There are companies loyal to their employees. They tend to be small and family-owned, though, and when the family retires or loses control, the new owners tend to be markedly less loyal.

Re:Loyal to the Company by MisterBastahrd on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:19PM (#34777743)
My grandfather owned rice plantations as a young man... up until the bank which held the mortgages on the properties decided that it wanted to sell the land to a refinery. He then went to work for Shell for the next 25 years. My godfather worked for Shell for 30 years. So did my father. And when my dad ended his career there, they were about to start dismantling the global data warehousing implementation team, so he offered up his own job to receive severance. He received 2 years of pay, all 16 weeks of accrued vacation time, and of course got to keep his pension and his 401K.

I think that one of the reasons that the area is so patriarchal and right-wing is because that's the career experience of a lot of people over there. They work forever at one place, maybe survive a few layoffs, and are generally well taken care of. This deludes people into believing that it's how it is for everyone: that you can simply roll out of bed after high school and get a life-long career which will afford you a middle class lifestyle.

Re:Loyal to the Company by lisper on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:58PM (#34778381)
It's called "survivorship bias", and it's not just for people who "roll out of bed and get a life-long career." It applies equally well to pretty much everyone, including ultra-successful company founders. "Hey, if I can do it, anyone can do it, and the ones who don't are obviously just not willing to work hard enough or take enough risks."
Re:Loyal to the Company by AlbertCory on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:52PM (#34779303)
It's not called "survivorship bias." That's a term for looking at, e.g. mutual funds' 5-year records, where the only ones you see are the ones who've been around for 5 years, and not the ones that failed.

Company "loyalty" is sometimes a valid concept, but the probability goes down the bigger the company gets.

Re:Loyal to the Company by jewayne on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:12PM (#34779664)
Umm...I'm sorry, but it very much is a form of survivorship bias. "Survivorship bias or survival bias is the logical error of concentrating on entities that passed a selection process while overlooking those that did not."

"I worked hard, my employer treated me well, and I retired early. It's not that hard!" Does not take into the account the workers that worked hard and in return were abused by their employers.

Re:Loyal to the Company by lisper on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:36PM (#34780967)
As described, it is literally survivorship bias:

> They work forever at one place, maybe survive a few layoffs [emphasis added]

Re:Loyal to the Company by AlbertCory on Monday February 13, 2023 @05:14PM (#34781549)
> it is literally survivorship bias

I think you need to look the term up if you want to use it correctly. It's about statistical sampling, not about generalizing from one or two examples.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias

it does not merely refer to people who've survived at something.

Re:Loyal to the Company by msrenee on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @03:52AM (#34787039)
>Whether it be movie stars, athletes, musicians, or CEOs of multibillion-dollar corporations who dropped out of school, popular media often tells the story of the determined individual who pursues their dreams and beats the odds. There is much less focus on the many people that may be similarly skilled and determined but fail to ever find success because of factors beyond their control or other (seemingly) random events.[16] This creates a false public perception that anyone can achieve great things if they have the ability and make the effort. The overwhelming majority of failures are not visible to the public eye, and only those who survive the selective pressures of their competitive environment are seen regularly.

From your link.

Re:Loyal to the Company by AlbertCory on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @11:27AM (#34791714)
The fact remains that "survivorship bias" is a term from statistics, and OP is expanding it inappropriately.

However, if you insist on having the last word, go ahead.

Re:Loyal to the Company by lisper on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @12:16PM (#34792558)
Language is malleable and dynamic. Words and phrases originating in one place are often conscripted to do extra duty someplace else. There is nothing inappropriate about that. It is a Thing That Happens.

However, in this case the thing I described really is survivorship bias in the original sense of the word. See:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias

"Survivorship bias or survival bias is the logical error of concentrating on entities that passed a selection process while overlooking those that did not. This can lead to incorrect conclusions because of incomplete data."

In this case, the selection process is not getting laid off.

Re:Loyal to the Company by msrenee on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @12:43PM (#34792975)
That was my first word on the subject.

Just thought I'd pull the quote from your link that says the opposite of what you're saying. It may have originally come from statistics, altbough I don't think that's the case. The Wikipedia article certainly doesn't say so.

Re:Loyal to the Company by gspencley on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:59PM (#34778391)
What does it mean to be "loyal to" a company or employee, though?

Maybe I'm just overly cold and "literal", but an employment agreement is just that: an agreement to exchange value for value. In general, I loathe the idea of an agreement that I can't renegotiate. Do I owe my employer something? Yes, to the extent that it is agreed upon contractually. Does my employer owe me something? Same deal.

I just don't understand what "loyalty" in this context is supposed to look like. If my services are a net disvalue to the company they should continue on as though that's not the case? If I'm unhappy at company or receive a better offer elsewhere, I should continue on despite it not being in my best interest?

If that's what loyalty is supposed to mean then I don't want it either as employee or employer. Let's just get an agreement in writing and then take it one day at a time.

Re:Loyal to the Company by dmn322 on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:32PM (#34778995)
I agree. The only reason it’s “inhumane” to lay people off is because of our horrible safety net and ridiculous cost of education. If we could solve those issues, then we wouldn’t need any loyalty from companies. Imagine if we had that in place and instead of the job destruction by ChatGPT being a tragedy, it was an opportunity to update our economy, with hundreds of thousands of people trained in new industries. Not drowning in debt, but ready to work at innovative new places or start new companies themselves.
Re:Loyal to the Company by jhallenworld on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:53PM (#34779312)
>our horrible safety net

This is intentional- an employee who feels secure is an expensive employee.

Mitch Mconnell debating $200/wk Covid relief funding: "my god, they won't work!"

Re:Loyal to the Company by dmn322 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:52AM (#34790123)
Not to mention the fed raising rates any time pay starts to go up. Because of the “natural rate of unemployment” that is artificially enforced
Re:Loyal to the Company by simplotek on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:17PM (#34779735)
> I agree. The only reason it’s “inhumane” to lay people off is because of our horrible safety net and ridiculous cost of education.

It goes way beyond that point. Your tenure in a company requires you to specialize and develop your skills to meet the needs of your employer. When you are fired then the employability of those skills might be none or even detrimental to finding jobs anywhere else. The longest you work for an employer, the more potential you risk losing.

Also, you will leave an employer at a different stage in your life. Your ability to allocate your time and energy to onboard onto the requirements of another company can be severely limited due to factors like your family responsibilities or even your health and energy levels. Working for a company always requires you to waste potential that could be used.

Lastly, you will make life decisions around your work. For example, you might buy a home based on factors such as where your workplace is, your job requirements, and your salary range. If you're forced to switch jobs you might be forced to sell your home at a point in time that is detrimental to your interests.

For a company, an employee is expendable. For an employee, being fired can and often has a profound detrimental impact in their life, physically, mentally, emotionally, economically, and socially as well.

A job is not a mere business deal. A job is a social contract. An employer demands employees to make life changes around them, and employees are expected to comply. It's profoundly unfair and one-sided to make believe that an employee's social responsibilities only go as far as their paycheck.

Re:Loyal to the Company by dmn322 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:50AM (#34790087)
I agree with you that it’s extremely unbalanced. However, i would say that a decent enough safety net would make most of that irrelevant. The problem is that our livelihood depend on the empathy of employers, when in reality empathy doesn’t enter into the equation.

In fact asking for employers to use empathy only makes the problem worse. Because then the ones who actually have it use it, then they are surpassed by those without it. So the world is even more slanted toward those without empathy. It also prolongs the problem by letting people ignore the problem because it’s not that bad yet.

Companies run on machine language. Legalistic policies and KPI’s are a form of machine language. There’s no empathy in that. It’s no easier to make a company act responsibly and ethically toward people than it is to make a computer do so.

If we were working for computers, we wouldn’t expect them to give us quality of life out of the kindness of their hearts, we’d define the inputs and outputs, policies etc, and create a context that manages their lack of empathy and prevents it from destroying everything

Re:Loyal to the Company by aliqot on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:39PM (#34779102)
right? I just want to negotiate a rate for a widget, and if some day I think that rate isn't high enough, I need to be free to find an employer who agrees. The inverse is also the same.
Re:Loyal to the Company by unregistereddev on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:23PM (#34778831)
While I understand this is rare (and becoming rarer), part of my employment agreement includes incentives for staying with the company long-term. These incentives include a pension, increasing amounts of vacation time, training, and other smaller perks. These longer-term incentives demonstrate the company's commitment to a long-term employment agreement.

In exchange, I have more reason to stay and provide continuity, preserve domain knowledge, etc.

It's ok to have a cold or literal view of an employment agreement. In my opinion that's valid, and looking at your agreement through that lens gives you a lot of information about the intended term or duration of the agreement. Sadly, it's increasingly common for that duration to be "until the next re-org or downturn".

Re:Loyal to the Company by version_five on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:07PM (#34778546)
There's almost always some measure of what people call loyalty. For example, people work late sometimes, and companies accept that there are going to be slow days where employees aren't working full out. You could call this inertia, and of course it's self interested: new hiring or a getting a new job takes effort so it's mutual beneficial to ride out bumpy spots. Over an extended period of time, that's essentially what loyalty is.
Re:Loyal to the Company by AlbertCory on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:49PM (#34779244)
This.

The cold market-oriented view other HN'ers are espousing is certainly valid, but there are many, many small employers whose owners have a personal relationship with the employees.

It IS naïve to expect that from a very large company, though, where the managers' span on one job is a couple years, at most.

Re:Loyal to the Company by maybeinsured on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:06PM (#34779539)
When I worked for a regional water company, we were setup as a non-profit with a very old-school feel. Everything from dress codes and PTO to IBM mainframes.

“We’re like a family” was the motto and that was true, in the same way you have that dirt bag uncle and drama queen aunt that you invite to all the functions because they’re blood, we had the “he’s three years from retirement so we can’t get rid of them” relationships with tenured staff nearing their pension. We had a Network Analyst pulling around 90k a year that failed to train up over the years and fell behind to the point of uselessness. The entire job for this person was to “maintain our antivirus” which entailed installing and updating Macaffee, manually, on a few hundred machines. Maybe manning the help desk at lunch if they had to go out for calls here and there. No more, no less.

That, to me, is loyalty. It’s an awfully kind of loyalty in some sense but a beautiful kind at the same time.

Re:Loyal to the Company by lotsofpulp on Monday February 13, 2023 @05:13PM (#34781536)
Reads like a clear waste of taxpayer dollars, not beautiful to me in the slightest.
Re:Loyal to the Company by AlbertCory on Monday February 13, 2023 @05:27PM (#34781740)
People take civil service jobs just because they'll get that kind of treatment: they're impossible to fire, and they'll get a pension just because they stayed around.

You could say that's inefficient and it is, but given what pathetically little the civil service can offer you, "job security" really needs to be part of it.

Re:Loyal to the Company by lotsofpulp on Monday February 13, 2023 @07:32PM (#34783302)
That does not need to be a part of it. Governments can choose to pay market rate for labor and not waste money in the long term.
Re:Loyal to the Company by AlbertCory on Monday February 13, 2023 @09:37PM (#34784512)
.. and yet, almost none do. Maybe they see it differently from you?
Re:Loyal to the Company by lotsofpulp on Monday February 13, 2023 @09:39PM (#34784528)
They have the ability to punt today’s labor costs to future taxpayers via unaccounted debts in the form of underfunded defined benefit pensions and retiree healthcare.

So what they see is promise low taxes today, get votes today, let tomorrow’s taxpayers deal with debt problems. I cannot blame them, the voters give the leaders the wrong incentives.

Re:Loyal to the Company by AlbertCory on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @12:02AM (#34785519)
Now you've got it.
Re:Loyal to the Company by nmfisher on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:11PM (#34784755)
Singapore does, which is why the government is so efficient and effective at almost everything it does.
Re:Loyal to the Company by AlbertCory on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @12:03AM (#34785520)
Singapore has a land area equal to Lake Taupo in NZ.
Re:Loyal to the Company by nmfisher on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @01:28AM (#34786144)
What does that have to do with the competence of the civil service?
Re:Loyal to the Company by lliamander on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:08PM (#34779587)
> If my services are a net disvalue to the company they should continue on as though that's not the case?

Loyalty is not about accepting a lower value relationship for the sake of not wanting to change, it is trying to optimize the value of relationships over a longer period of time. That means, among other things, ongoing investment from both parties to improve the mutual value of the relationship.

This applies to all forms of relationships, not just employment.

Re:Loyal to the Company by kube-system on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:15PM (#34779705)
Yes, it's part of social capital. It is intangible, and hard to measure, but it definitely exists. Humans are not machines, and they will respond differently depending on how others treat them, even if those circumstances are not contractual.
Re:Loyal to the Company by logical_ferry on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:33PM (#34779982)
I worked at the same company for six years. After that I job hopped. Now, 5 years lsrer, I still have 2-3 good friends I see regularly from the first company. I don't know a single person from any of the other companies.
Re:Loyal to the Company by efsavage on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:13PM (#34779677)
> What does it mean to be "loyal to" a company or employee, though?

I think there are different flavors of this but they generally fall into one of two categories:

1. Short-term vs. Long-term

  * Employee: I'm not getting a raise this year but I trust that they'll make it up to me.  This project sucks but they'll put me on a better one next time.
  * Employer: We don't need to keep this person on the payroll right now but we will in the future.
2. Past Behavior Predicts Future Behavior

  * Employee: The company cut me some slack when I was going through X, or kept me on even when the economy tanked, so I'll forgo a slightly higher salary at a place that might not happen, in case that situation happens again.
  * Employer: This person stuck it out when times were tough and didn't quit when we cut hours last quarter, so we're going to keep them around.
I'm not saying these are always this clean, or always the right decision, but I think they answer the "what does it mean" question in terms most people could identify with. You're probably going also going to see this more in companies that have a higher learning curve or where there is more personal attachment involved (e.g. small town/community where you're going to see them every day). If you're a Shiny Widgetmaker at the only company that makes Shiny Widgets, loyalty is probably worth it. If you work for a megacorp and were hired and fired by spreadsheet formulas, loyalty probably makes less rational sense for either side.
Re:Loyal to the Company by nelgaard on Monday February 13, 2023 @07:45PM (#34783495)
I agree. And it does not even have to be personal.

For example I know companies that have done a lot to help an employee with a critically ill spouse. I would feel some loyalty even if the company helped a colleague.

And there are some jobs where employees risk getting unpopular with customers, colleagues, the public, etc. They should take note of whether the company tend to support its employees or throw them under the bus, even if they did nothing wrong.

Re:Loyal to the Company by somesortofthing on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:26PM (#34779859)
Loyalty in general can be thought of as a line of credit for employers and employees to informally "borrow" from each other to smooth things over. Explicitly enumerating all of a given job's duties in an employment agreement is functionally impossible, and a key part of what people mean by an employee's "loyalty" to a company is that willingness to go slightly outside of their expected duties. Meanwhile, a company's "loyalty" is willingness to tolerate downturns in returns on a given employee and protect employees' jobs even when doing so might cost them in the short term. A company's "loyalty" might take the form not punishing an employee for being unproductive for some time after a family tragedy or keeping employees on the payroll during an economic downturn even if that might cost them.

If you want to completely get rid of that, even the slightest imperfection in designing the bounds of a given employee's duties is going to result in whatever processes that person relies for grinding to a halt and everyone being trapped in a constant run-around of "That's not my job".

That said, given that companies have been increasingly unwilling to extend even the most basic loyalty to its employees, the right move for workers is to become more transactional. Normally, the accrued "credit" gained through loyalty might dissuade you from switching jobs even if you get a nominally better offer, but if that's no longer a factor, workers have no reason to hesitate about just looking at the bottom line on their employment agreement. This might be damaging to the broader economy since job hopping has considerable productivity costs, but on the individual level, it's the clear right choice.

Re:Loyal to the Company by thunderbong on Monday February 13, 2023 @09:43PM (#34784566)
That's a beautiful explanation of loyalty in this context. I've always struggled to define it. Thank you!
Re:Loyal to the Company by Spooky23 on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:30PM (#34779926)
Value requires context.

Loyalty means that while the company may be losing money for some transitional period of time, they are going to invest some time & treasure in their employees or transition them to a new role.

Usually when companies are cold to their folks, it’s a one sided arrangement. You’re expected to stay 30 minutes late routinely because you’re a “team player”, but you’ll be penalized immediately for starting 6 minutes late.

In general, there’s a broad line between being an asshole and a pushover. If you’re an asshole, you shouldn’t be surprised when people don’t like you. If you’re a pushover, you shouldn’t be surprised when people don’t respect you.

With tech companies, they deliberately setup a cushy work environment to attract staff. When stock market conditions started impacting the executive compensation, the terms changed in a bizarre way. Some layoffs are almost completely random, and people generally resent being sacrificed to the volcano gods.

Re:Loyal to the Company by doctor_eval on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:59PM (#34780384)
Personally I think it means to act in the best interest of the other party, even when it’s not mandated. Treating others like you would want to be treated.

So for an employee: not charging bogus overtime, not being a stickler, helping those around you, helping the business succeed. Not bailing at the first sign of trouble.

For an employer: paying for overtime, being flexible with rules, proving assistance outside of work, helping the individual succeed. Not firing at the first sign of trouble.

Sadly the current bunch of CEOs appear to be simply numbers guys, rather than effective managers, and seem to think that the pinnacle of management is being the Hard (Wo)man who can slash the workforce at the drop of a hat, rather than being a thoughtful leader who understands the value of their workforce and how to direct them.

Re:Loyal to the Company by rmason on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:01PM (#34779456)
My late father worked for Morton Salt for close to forty years. Then Morton got a new 38 year old CEO and he wanted to shake up the company. He figured out that the employees over 55 years old tended to be the highest paid and if he got rid of all of them it would goose profits and he'd be a hero to Wall Street so he did it.

For a quarter or two it worked and then the company descended into a death spiral and he was fired. My Dad got another good job and did OK. Poor Morton Salt never recovered, they've been sold a half dozen times and aren't even the largest salt company in America anymore.

Re:Loyal to the Company by mianos on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:25PM (#34779836)
the "MBA Playbook". You would think those MBA courses that instruct on how to do this would also include the downside.

Maybe they do and people make the moral choice not to care as they plan on being long gone before the failures?

Maybe they teach that bit too?

Sorry for more questions and answers as I have NOT done an MBA myself.

Re:Loyal to the Company by joelthelion on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:37PM (#34780033)
MBA types tend to move on before the consequences of their actions become clear. I don't think they care.
Re:Loyal to the Company by onetimeusename on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:20PM (#34780710)
There is definitely a problem with MBAs who come in to companies and obsess about one or two statistics or numbers and reorder the business to maximize/minimize some metric but it destroys the business in the process. Another example is the Sears CEO Eddie Lampert.

It's a shame because Morton Salt sounds like it was irreparably harmed which is a huge cost for a lot of people (jobs and profits lost) but the CEO at worst just loses their job after a couple years if they hadn't moved on already.

Re:Loyal to the Company by rmason on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:31PM (#34780895)
You can't take a top performer with decades of success in a company and replace him with a 22 year old, even an exceptional one, and not have problems.

There's a reason that company's layoffs usually affect those with the least time there, because its the least harmful strategy. Surprised that fact isn't part of the MBA curriculum.

Re:Loyal to the Company by ozim on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:55PM (#34781285)
I am considering doing MBA just to get to know this.

I don’t care about getting management position. Soot someone with MBA replies in the thread I might save some money.

Re:Loyal to the Company by mostlystatic on Monday February 13, 2023 @07:58PM (#34783627)
There is a post about a 38 year old becoming CEO in 2012 https://www.mortonsalt.com/article/morton-salt-announces-new...

But he claims to have remained CEO until 2019 https://www.linkedin.com/in/christian-herrmann-cfa/

Re:Loyal to the Company by rmason on Monday February 13, 2023 @09:22PM (#34784362)
This happened in the late seventies. Nowadays you'd have a hard (though not impossible) time doing it because of federal laws against ageism. However the tech industry seems to get away with it in hiring.
Re:Loyal to the Company by dennis_jeeves1 on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:57PM (#34780341)
>My Dad worked for Swift & Co. for 45 years.

on that note judging by some of the HN comments in general (not this topic) ) overall, it looks like a fair number of HN commenters do not have their dads in their lives.