News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by bombcar on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:40PM (#34777055)
The verbs here are a bit alarmist - descended from 2200 to 800 feet over 45 seconds sounds less horrible - though this should have been reported even if just to NASA.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by blessedwhiskers on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:50PM (#34778218)
"Flight tracking data analysis revealed that the Boeing 777-200 had reached an altitude of roughly 2,200ft when it began a steep dive, descending at a rate of about 8,600ft a minute"

The article additionally says the entire ordeal lasted 45 seconds, but clearly part of that 45 seconds was a steep dive.

Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by LeFantome on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:03PM (#34778464)
Ya, at the rate described, it would have been more like 10 seconds of dive. Pretty scary if you are looking out the window I imagine. I mean, at the rate given, they were about 5 seconds from the water. I think that would have felt plenty dramatic to me.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by pdx_flyer on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:16PM (#34778708)
I would assume that situational awareness for those inside the plane would have actually been pretty poor. They were climbing through clouds when the dive began so seeing the orientation of the plane to the earth would have been very spotty.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by cactacea on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:42PM (#34779152)
As a passenger, even if I couldn't see out the window, you'd definitely know you weren't going "up" anymore at that rate of decent. Combined with "we just took off" I'm certain that at least a few people in the cabin knew something really bad might have been about to happen.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by inferiorhuman on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:46PM (#34780176)

  As a passenger, even if I couldn't see out the window, you'd definitely
  know you weren't going "up" anymore at that rate of decent.
No, you really wouldn't. Even for the pilots spatial disorientation is a real problem and they have instruments to show which end is up.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by runnerup on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:41PM (#34781060)
I follow most of my flights (especially takeoff/landing) with all the sensors in my smartphone. In flights without emergency events, the most useful for me is barometric pressure. When they suddenly drop the pressure by 20+% after achieving cruising altitude, half the plane shortly goes to sleep. I presume due to the lower partial pressure of oxygen.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by inferiorhuman on Monday February 13, 2023 @05:36PM (#34781880)
Sure, but then you're talking 10,000 ft or more. The pressure differential between 2,200 ft and 775 ft is much smaller. It's possible some folks' ears popped, but IMO unlikely that they would've attributed it to a steep descent. Instead I'd expect folks chalked it up to the cabin pressurizing if they even noticed. If passengers noticed and thought there was something wrong this would've made news much sooner.

  I presume due to the lower partial pressure of oxygen.
Probably the lower oxygen content. My pilot friend claimed to have raised the cabin altitude a smidge back in the DC-10 days if FAs complained about e.g. noisy babies. I assume he's full of shit, but you never know.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by runnerup on Monday February 13, 2023 @05:43PM (#34781986)
> The pressure differential between 2,200 ft and 775 ft is much smaller.

Irrelevant. The cabin pressure is controlled independently of the Earth's environmental altitude pressure.

> Probably the lower oxygen content.

That's literally exactly the same thing as the thing that I said.

Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by inferiorhuman on Monday February 13, 2023 @06:31PM (#34782560)
The cabin won't be noticeably pressurized at 2,200 ft. While a 777 will pressurize the cabin slightly before takeoff the max cabin altitude is 8,000 ft. So, yes, there is a bigger change in pressure during an approach (from 8,000 ft cabin altitude to roughly the altitude of the field) than there is going into a steep dive from 2,200 ft.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by runnerup on Monday February 13, 2023 @06:42PM (#34782676)
I might be stupid but I don’t understand what point you’re getting at?
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by throwaheyy on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:38PM (#34781004)
No. In flight you are subject to variable G-forces so you can't know that you are moving in the way that you "feel" you are moving.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by bombcar on Monday February 13, 2023 @05:05PM (#34781428)
If you (or anyone) wants a really, REALLY good experience around this, go to your local small airport and find a flight instructor and ask them to show you "unusual attitudes" - they'll have you close your eyes and put your head down, do stuff with the plane, and then ask you what the plane is doing - you will say "turning down and to the right" and be in a climb to the left. It's freaky.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by cactacea on Monday February 13, 2023 @08:42PM (#34783982)
That's fair, I suppose a better way to word my point would be that any sort of "extreme" maneuver, absent some warning from the pilot about a rough takeoff or landing (or turbulence while in flight) is unusual for a passenger plane. Having that happen just after takeoff we're near the ground would give me some concern regardless of which direction I subjectively felt we were moving in, up or down. I've been through plenty of rough takeoffs and landings as a passenger and I just find it hard to believe that not a single person on the flight didn't at least think to themselves "hey, this isn't a normal climb to 10k".
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by netsharc on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:01PM (#34778431)
2200-775 = 1425ft total dive.

At a rate of 8600ft/min, they were in a dive for about 10 seconds. But obviously levelling off means a rate of dive a lot less than 8600ft/min.

Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by inferiorhuman on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:52PM (#34780260)

  The verbs here are a bit alarmist
Nah, they're appropriate. Getting that low (less than 775 ft) is bad, doing that on climb out is worse. There's no margin for error at that height. Moreover the plane pulled 2.7G which is in excess of what the plane is rated for (2.5G). The pilots should've returned (to Maui or the Big Island) for an inspection instead of continuing on with the flight.

  though this should have been reported even if just to NASA.
What I've read is that the incident was reported after the flight landed at SFO.
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by mdmglr on Monday February 13, 2023 @05:46PM (#34782025)
What would NASA do with this information? Do they have an aviation incident response I’m not familiar with?
Re:United flight from Hawaii plunged to within 800ft of Paci... by sveiss on Monday February 13, 2023 @06:14PM (#34782363)
Yes, they operate the Aviation Safety Reporting System[1] in the US.

It’s intentionally kept separate from the FAA, which has the enforcement role, to encourage reporters to come forward. The second ‘A’ in NASA is ‘Aeronautics’, after all, so it’s a reasonable place to put this function. Reporting to ASRS comes with a certain degree of immunity to enforcement actions, and keeping it separate from the FAA reinforces that.

They have a monthly publication, Callback, which includes anonymised snippets of reports, with each issue presenting lessons learned and usually centred around a specific theme. It’s worth a look if you have an interest in how the US aviation system tries to prioritise safety.

[1] https://asrs.arc.nasa.gov/