That was his mandate when getting hired.
If you want to prove government is inefficient, hire people to make it inefficient.
It’s one of the reasons I think the “prioritizing profits” narrative rings hollow. Any profits they would have preserved by not-stopping for the first hotbox detector? Already burned by the costs of the closure and the response so far. If anything, chasing profits better would have prevented this.
Like these powerful people can't look through history at what comes when the line is finally crossed for enough people.
People who make decisions like this don’t like the inconvenience of someone questioning her decisions.
It would help me rationalise why no decisions maker ever goes to jail after their decisions kill people, even when they are private companies
It also seems to ignore that the same company participated in claiming that the workers' often stated concerns for safety were just people being greedy and that they would lose some profit if they implemented safer conditions.
No. Chasing profits is the reason the train did not stop after the hot box detection. It would have been late.
It's not about this incident, it's about all the other times they did the same thing and got away with it. Every train that didn't stop in a similar situation and didn't cause a major problem was a win to the company. Whatever stopping a train costs, they saved that amount every single time they didn't do it, and if they did this regularly that number probably adds up.
There's a concept in risk management called the swiss cheese model[1] where you think of your layers of protection like a stack of swiss cheese slices. Every individual layer has its holes, but as you stack them up the number of paths through the whole stack gets smaller and smaller. In a sufficiently protected system, causing a major problem should require multiple layers to fail or be bypassed.
The trick of course is that this also generally means that when commercial pressure and/or individual laziness leads to one or more of the layers being bypassed it won't usually cause an immediate problem because other layers are still covering most of the holes, but the safety margin might now be a single layer instead of three so one more failure can cause a catastrophe.
Layers of protection cost money so it's not exactly rocket surgery to understand why those focused on profits, especially those who are primarily interested in short term profits, constantly apply pressure to bypass or shortcut those layers as much as people feel they can get away with.
I don't see the reasoning as to why state run services would be somehow safer. The state should set out the rules and enforce strictly
compare that to an amtrak train derailment where someone literally falls asleep killing people and he wasn't even fired.
Don't get me started on police union investigations...
https://nypost.com/2014/10/28/engineer-fell-asleep-before-de...
That's like $6 million per person they've killed, very cheap. In UK NHS paid over $45 million for non-lethal medical mistake. [1]
> someone literally falls asleep killing people and he wasn't even fired
If some accident has ever killed >50 people, it can never be the fault of one person on minimum wage.
People fuck up, that's a fact of life, that's why we have co-pilots in planes, FAA was suppose to check Boeing's design, and one person going crazy can't launch the nukes.
The article you linked details numerous failures by the company. You should assign responsibility up to decision makers that made tragedy inevitable, not down to pawns that happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.
At least it's easier to hold public officials accountable - you can get rid of them by voting - than to hold companies accountable.
I disagree because most of the public officials who would be accountable are appointed to these positions, not directly elected. The representatives we elect - mayor, house representative, senator, etc. - all have a good degree of distance from direct accountability.
Plus, I feel like regular partisan politics and gerrymandering also make accountability much harder to achieve.
>Documents show that when current transportation safety rules were first created, a federal agency sided with industry lobbyists and limited regulations governing the transport of hazardous compounds.
I really don't think government owning the company is going to help.
Regulatory capture is a lot harder if there is no industry with corporate interests to do so.