News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amiga with Titanic miniature shoot video taps is treasure... by dylan604 on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:30AM (#34770760)
There's a lot of opinion in this: "they supposedly showed the better 1.78:1"

By creating the 1.78, there is picture that has been cropped out and is no longer visible. The director/DP shot it in the original aspect for a reason. To create the non-OAR version, compromises were made. To say that the cropped version is better is a heavy bit of opinion to say the least.

"However it is a re-release of an old film so if your not keen on watching an old film then there isn't a point."

Wow, just so much wow. Yes, let's never watch a movie because it is older. That's like saying, never read a book that wasn't released in the past couple of years. You're cutting out a large percentage of material based on some very strange criteria.

Re:Amiga with Titanic miniature shoot video taps is treasure... by smackeyacky on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:24AM (#34771019)
Maybe. It's possible the 2.39 one is a crop of the 1.78. So which one is "better" might be a bit academic i.e. there might be more picture on the 1.78 one but its strips of stuff top and bottom the director didnt really want anybody to see.
Re:Amiga with Titanic miniature shoot video taps is treasure... by dylan604 on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:56AM (#34776151)
Did it hurt when you stretched that far to try to prove a point that's not even valid. did you read the words coming off your fingertips?

Does "that the director didn't really want anybody to see" sounds exactly like what the director is going to go back in to allow people to see on an anniversary release? Here's a quote never said by James Cameron: "yeah, you know, when we exposed for 2.35 aspect so we allowed all of the film gak to be in frame for a smaller aspect ratios, we should release that to the public since it will definitely enhance the experience of the viewer. that was such a mistake to not do that 25 years ago"

Re:Amiga with Titanic miniature shoot video taps is treasure... by smackeyacky on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @04:05AM (#34787105)
I was merely pointing out that it happens that 2.35:1 prints are sometimes produced from narrower masters.
Re:Amiga with Titanic miniature shoot video taps is treasure... by nebula8804 on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:55AM (#34771801)
>There's a lot of opinion in this: "they supposedly showed the better 1.78:1"

By creating the 1.78, there is picture that has been cropped out and is no longer visible. The director/DP shot it in the original aspect for a reason. To create the non-OAR version, compromises were made. To say that the cropped version is better is a heavy bit of opinion to say the least.

Good point, this assertion came from my research into this new version before selecting the theaters I was going to see the film in. The consensus appears to be that the 2.39:1 version is not ideal and there was disappointment in people who had gone to see the film to discover that it is not 1.78:1 on places like several subreddits(imax, titanic, amc and some more) as well as some discord chat rooms that focus on movie quality.

>Wow, just so much wow. Yes, let's never watch a movie because it is older. That's like saying, never read a book that wasn't released in the past couple of years. You're cutting out a large percentage of material based on some very strange criteria.

Man this is one loaded comment. The OP was asking if the titanic was any good. I merely suggested that if they are not interested in old films that it wouldn't make sense to check this one out. In hindsight it is an obvious point so maybe I shouldn't have made it but your response makes a lot of assumptions about what I intended with my comment.