News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by Dalewyn on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:16AM (#34760970)
Humans being humans will always be a thing, but if we let that be the showstopper then we can't do anything period.
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by emodendroket on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:18AM (#34760981)
If nuclear power requires more vigilance or competence from the people running it to avert disaster then that's a real demerit.
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by rightbyte on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:29AM (#34761050)
Which especially makes me nervous about all these plans for small reactors.

Harder to supervise for authorities and more "silos" where incompetence could emerge.

Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by tb_technical on Sunday February 12, 2023 @10:06AM (#34763333)
Beware fear, uncertainty, and doubt. The new small reactors have safer designs and more fail-safes than the last gen reactors.
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by mpweiher on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:50AM (#34761525)
It doesn't.

Fukushima clearly demonstrated this.

1. The reactor was an old design, not really considered safe

2. Known deficiencies were not fixed

3. Despite the regulations saying they needed to be fixed

4. Regulations that were also found to be insufficient

So really colossal screwups piled on top of each other.

And so an accident happened. Explosions happened. Without the containment of more modern plants.

And yet, the actual effect was minimal. (The panic, on the other hand...)

Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by cinntaile on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:41AM (#34761793)
You clearly prove his point, more vigilance and/or competence is needed.
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by mpweiher on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:25AM (#34762001)
If you mean that more vigilance and/or competence is always desirable: Absolutely!

If you mean that more vigilance and/or competence is required to operate nuclear power: I clearly showed the opposite.

Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by cinntaile on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:37AM (#34762061)
* * *
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by mpweiher on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:19AM (#34762293)
> operate a nuclear power plant

No. I was talking about whether countries/societies operate nuclear power.

Very different.

For example, the Bhopal disaster at a chemical plant killed several thousand people.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_disaster

Germany did not get out of chemicals production afterward, or after Seveso or Flixborough, even though the case for that was a lot stronger than for getting out of nuclear.

But of course this does not imply it is fine to run a chemical plant this way.

Separate issues.

> trying to prevent accidents

Key word is trying. You will never be able to prevent all accidents and being 100% certain to prevent all accidents cannot be the standard, and it is not a standard applied anywhere else.

And Fukushima showed that a lot of idiocy has to be stacked on top of each other in order to get to an accident, and even then the actual effects of the accident are fairly benign.

> If accidents are no issue

No. Accidents are issues. But the response to those issues has to be appropriate and proportionate.

> Society wants a safely operated plant without serious accidents.

Society also wants and needs energy, and nuclear energy is one of the safest/cleanest forms of energy we have, and the safest/cleanest form of reliable energy we have. Not having reliable energy would be a far greater disaster than any nuclear accident to date. In fact, the net effect is highly, highly positive even for fossil fuels.

Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by cinntaile on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:47PM (#34767973)
Chemical plants serve a different purpose than a nuclear power plant. You can produce electricity in a lot of different ways, you usually can't produce chemicals in a lot of different ways. They're a prerequisite to produce other chemicals or products so not producing them damages your supply chain. Sometimes you can subsitute them for another chemical, usually you can't. Chemical accidents such as the ones you mentioned have for that matter resulted in a lot of new safety precautions.

> And Fukushima showed that a lot of idiocy has to be stacked on top of each other in order to get to an accident, and even then the actual effects of the accident are fairly benign.

A lot of accidents are considered unlikely, but it doesn't stop them from happening. Even if we accept that the impact on humans has been limited, we still cannot ignore the $100+ billion in additional costs costs.

> Society also wants and needs energy, and nuclear energy is one of the safest/cleanest forms of energy we have, and the safest/cleanest form of reliable energy we have.

If only it was flexible, that would be something. Unfortunately OpEx is pretty much unchanged when you vary the output.

Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by mpweiher on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:44AM (#34775923)
I never claimed there were no differences between these accidents...but we could simply ban those chemicals, or ban the industry from making those chemicals in that way. The point is not that this didn't happen because, after careful deliberation, it was found that this wasn't possible.

The point is that it wasn't even considered, despite the very many accidents having vastly more severe consequences. And it's not just this one industry. How about cars? How many people die every year? Do we ban cars? We could. Do we require cars to never go faster than 10 km/h? We could, and in fact that was what Carl Benz wanted. And one of the reasons his company effectively failed and was bought by Daimler. But we do not, because we consider the benefits to outweigh the (substantial) risks.

With nuclear, we don't seem to be capable of making such an informed decision, balancing the risks with the rewards. Instead, we demand that the risk be zero. This is obviously irrational.

The cost of the Tōhoku earthquake and Tsunami was $235 billion. Do you also count the cleanup costs of all the other technology that was destroyed by the earthquake and Tsunami against that technology. Or do you do that only with nuclear?

The $100 billion cost you claim against nuclear was caused by the Tsunami, not by nuclear power, and of course the number is massively inflated due to the overreaction to the accident. So thank you for further proving my point of the massive cost of irrational overreaction to nuclear.

Fear of nuclear power has killed more people than nuclear power. And in fact, the number of lives saved by nuclear power is in the many millions.

Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by cinntaile on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:38PM (#34777024)
* * *
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by cinntaile on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:48AM (#34801494)
It's awfully quiet now that I refuted your "irrationality" claims.
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by danson on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:43AM (#34762089)
I think his point is that even with the current levels of vigilance and competence (which unarguably can and should be improved) the actualized impact was "minimal".

In other words, the expected scale of "disaster" here matters when assessing risk vs current operational fitness.

Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by mpweiher on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:03AM (#34762513)
Well put, thank you!
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by cinntaile on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:04PM (#34768108)
It's a bit strange to describe a total cost of $100+ billion as "minimal".
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power by mpweiher on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:22AM (#34775539)
I am talking about actual effects, not effects due to overreaction.

If you count effects due to overreaction, you can also count Germany's Atomausstieg, which almost certainly materially contributed to Putin's decision to invade Ukraine...