What's conspicuous however, is that MOND can make many successful a priori predictions about observations that LCDM needs to fit a posteriori using a "tuned" distribution of dark matter.
So MOND does indeed describe those observations simply even if it doesn't explain why they hold. An example of a better way to handle this than outright dismissing MOND, are recent proposals for superfluid dark matter that reproduce MOND in the right regimes.
those are the same predictions you'd get if you just set dark matter at a single uniform universal distribution. which is again, exactly what every attempt at explaining mond just ends up doing anyway... but then there's also those things that disagree with mond rendering the need for introducing a bunch of new stuff on top of it anyway.
and that's the thing mond leads us to dark matter plus extra stuff. Occam's razor is hardly an absolute truth but we like it and we can explain things without the extra stuff.
it's also like a real fucking brain worm to call "matter follows a statistical distribution": tuning or more parameters like the sibling post does. "Matter follows a statistical distribution" is what we already see in all the matter we see.
Personally, the way I think about dark matter is that it’s a map of the variances we see between the expected behaviour and actual behaviour of galaxies. That’s it. That’s it’s a distribution of gravitating matter is one possibility. That would fit the observations, so it’s a reasonable working hypothesis, that’s all.
MOND simply doesn’t describe the distribution of the effects we see. It does in many common cases, but not all by a long way and the variance is different from case to case, so it still leaves a gap we’d need to fill with something else.
Iirc, LCDM has trouble explaining satellite galaxies. They're traveling through the halo, which should create drag on them. They shouldn't last long enough to exist at all.
Yes that's fine, but it also doesn't necessarily try to [1]. LCDM can't explain linear Tully-fisher, can't explain external field effect, can't explain why satellite galaxies are long lived, can't explain why bullet cluster even exists (galaxies shouldn't be going that fast), can't explain early galaxies, etc.
[1] so maybe it shouldn't. There's a lot of systematic uncertainty in some of those really large scale movements. For example suppose our standard candle was off by half an order of magnitude at the largest scales. For LCDM, not a problem. Reparametrize the distribution and ratios of dark matter. Presto chango theory still works. That this should be possible should scare you.
And LCDM does this too. If you want a comprehensive survey of the tuning done by each model to fit observations, see:
https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.06936v3
It seems clear that neither approach is satisfactory as they stand, but the resistance to recognizing the significant flaws in LCDM is frankly puzzling.
So it needs more research, but pretending that the model doesn’t fit the observations with a very simple framework, and instead throwing more and more parameters at Dark Matter to get it to fit… At some point it’s starting to look silly?
Why not consider that there is probably more to understand here and try to combine these theories as Sabine is arguing?
So does Dark Matter
I'm curious about your background: you seem to know both physics and Prolog? How come?
Btw, thanks for your comments in the Prolog thread. Much more level-headed reaction than mine, I have to say with embarrassment.
Just sorta started noodling around with prolog a while back on a whim. Fits my brain well enough and it's kinda fun. Still never really used it in anger but I've been hanging around tech/programming circles for so long i can speak (somewhat) intelligently about languages well before I can do anything with them.
I hope you stick with Prolog. It's a unique thing. If only more people understood it, and used it, in their everyday work.
Thanks!
You'll find the two journal papers in my old profile at the very end of Louise's Readme :)
I mean it doesn't really. Worse though, it doesn't explain the observations. It's just a model fit post hoc. Everytime they try to explain why gravity would act like that they just end up reinventing dark matter but calling it a field and hoping no one points out particle/field equivalence during peer review.