News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by twodayslate on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @07:31AM (#3474635)
How can you copyright that? If it is, it should be under creative commons.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by sp332 on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @07:36AM (#3474649)
In the USA (and most other jurisdictions, really) as soon as you write it down, you have the copyright on it. You also have some control over "derivative works" including any copies of the "performance" of the speech. In music, for example, you would need to pay royalties to the songwriter for publicly playing a recording of their song, no matter who actually sang the song.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by ck2 on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @07:44AM (#3474670)
I'm kind of surprised congress didn't try to retroactively copyright the Declaration of Independence and Gettysburg Address and force textbook publishers to pay royalties.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by brudgers on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @08:02AM (#3474708)
Laws are protected by copyright and documents incorporated by reference into the law may be placed online.

The model building codes which are both incorporated by reference into many laws and are protected by copyright as model building codes, provided the test case.

Veeck v SBCCI

http://www.law.cornell.edu/copyright/cases/293_F3d_791.htm

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by sp332 on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @07:47AM (#3474680)
Those were works made by the government, so they're automatically in the public domain. I don't see why you're against Mr. King having the copyright on the speech he wrote and gave?
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by ck2 on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @07:58AM (#3474701)
MLK said those words to move governments and their people, to everyone and anyone that would listen.

Some things are too important to lock down and copyright, at least not until 2038.

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by anamax on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @09:56AM (#3475065)
With copyright, he/his heirs get to decide how it can be used, such as selling Coke. (They didn't have to decide "sell Coke".)

> Some things are too important to lock down and copyright, at least not until 2038.

And the copyright law language embodying that principle is?

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by henrikschroder on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @11:17AM (#3475316)
It doesn't exist in copyright law, but may be it should? If enough people think it should be, we can write it down and make it law.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by anamax on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @04:12PM (#3476488)
I was unclear. I wasn't asking for an existing law that implements your idea. I was asking for language that does.

> If enough people think it should be, we can write it down and make it law.

Oh really? If enough people think that pi should be 3, can we pass a law and it will be so?

There are lots of things that people want that can't be codified with the desired properties. This is something that looks (to me) to be on the edge.

How about some other examples? (If it's just "I have a dream", we can pass specific legislation.)

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @09:22AM (#3474955)
USA was just about the last place to accede to the international treaties on copyright, wherein copyright is granted at the time of creation of 'a work'. You don't have to fix the work in any particular medium to gain copyright - an expressive, creative mime could be a copyright work; or just a tune you whistled, or a cake, or ...
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by spacemanaki on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @07:38AM (#3474652)
Well, the article actually explains how it was copyrighted. Basically the King estate sued CBS and the court determined they had a claim.

"Typically, a speech broadcast to a large audience on radio and television (and considered instrumental in historic political changes and ranked as the most important speech in 20th century American history) would seem to be a prime candidate for the public domain ..... the judge determined that the speech was a performance distributed to the news media and not the public, making it a “limited” as opposed to a “general” publication. That meant the speech, like other “performances” on CBS, was not in the public domain. That meant the King estate had the right to claim copyright"

This is relatively readable: http://www.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/ops/19989079.MAN.pdf

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by Maro on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @07:45AM (#3474673)
So it really started with Martin Luther King's descendants disgracing his heritage.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by arethuza on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @08:03AM (#3474716)
Not really, according to the article:

"But the copyright dilemma began in December 1963, when King sued Mister Maestro, Inc., and Twentieth Century Fox Records Company to stop the unauthorized sale of records of the 17-minute oration."

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by ck2 on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @08:25AM (#3474775)
There is a difference in going to court to protect it from being misused and sold without his consent to trying to lock it away so it can be a profit making item.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by rdtsc on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @08:39AM (#3474839)
It is a case of going overboard. Initially they didn't care probably. But then they saw someone making money off it. So they didn't just go and stop that particular instance but went further and made sure nobody would be able to do it. They saw how money could be made from it, and decided they should be the ones profiting from it.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by squidfood on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @09:04AM (#3474905)
Also note that it would be out of copyright now according to the law at that time.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by brudgers on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @08:10AM (#3474731)
Accoding to the article:

The lawsuit was filed in 1963 when Dr. King was very much alive.

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by lnanek on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @01:22PM (#3475837)
Seemed to start with King himself, according to the article. It seems like both him and his family donate the proceeds, however, which makes me feel better about the whole deal: " King himself donated proceeds from licensing the speech to fund the civil rights movement, and the King family has made similar pledges. "
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by riffic on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @08:23AM (#3474767)
Creative Commons didn't exist in the 1960s