News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by themodelplumber on Friday February 10, 2023 @04:41PM (#34746305)
Funny, though tbh it seems like there are cheaper ways to cause the US to spend gobs of cash. I even hesitate to mention some ideas that immediately come to mind that would be easier/more efficient to really nail than the Pringles can idea.

Plus many of the more prominent base-personnel sightings land quite a bit far from that particular ballpark. Take a look into the Rendlesham Forest incident for example.

The problem with "summing up UFO contact" is that the variety of encounters is absolutely insane. Compare Rendlesham to Varginha, etc.

It really starts to bring out the "inter" in the more colorful inter-dimensional contact theories.

Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by r3trohack3r on Friday February 10, 2023 @04:50PM (#34746409)
Had never heard of the Rendlesham Forest incident - what a rabbit hole. Thank you for sharing.
Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by cpursley on Friday February 10, 2023 @05:23PM (#34746816)
Knowledge like this is what keeps bringing me back to HN.
Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by GartzenDeHaes on Friday February 10, 2023 @05:28PM (#34746863)
If you know something about how the USAF responds to incidents, the idea of the deputy base commander and disaster preparedness running around in the middle of the night chasing UFO's is hilarious. It's obviously a practical joke that got out of hand.
Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by r3trohack3r on Friday February 10, 2023 @06:14PM (#34747328)
Just watched some interviews. The guys claiming to have “downloaded” an alien signal by touching the craft.

The signal was transmitted in binary and just happened to be ASCII encoded English. Odd that a ship from 8100 transmitted data in an archaic dialect of an ancient language using an ancient encoding that just happened to match the language and encoding in widespread use during this guys lifetime.

Having a hard time with this.

Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by JohnBooty on Friday February 10, 2023 @05:44PM (#34747025)

    Funny, though tbh it seems like there are cheaper ways 
    to cause the US to spend gobs of cash.
Yeah.

My best understanding based on watching a lot of retired military personnel is that isolated incidents cost the US almost exactly zero additional dollars.

The way an Air Force base works is this: there is a budget. This covers the (considerable) costs of the base itself, the personnel, the equipment, and so on.

Active-duty fighter pilots must fly a certain number of hours per month to remain on active status. Just like any other demanding activity (sports, competitive gaming, whatever) their skills require constant maintenance. These flying hours are of course budgeted. (This will be true of literally any air force; it's not specifically a USAF thing)

Things like these incident responses, and even things like flyovers before sporting events, come out of those predetermined budgeted flying hours that they were going to fly anyway. So isolated incidents like these don't really increase USAF expenses in a meaningful way. Those $400K/ea missiles will presumably need to be replenished but this must be compared to the USAF's total budget of $180 billion.

To put any strain whatsoever on the US's capabilities our foes would need to start sending large amounts of drones: essentially, a saturation attack. More than we can comfortably respond to. Which is of course... extremely possible.

But as long as these remain isolated incidents we can surmise that our adversary's goal is not "cost the US a bunch of money."

Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by mistermann on Friday February 10, 2023 @06:10PM (#34747287)
A potential flaw in this plan: while everything you say may be true, it is not broadly known. If China (or whoever) was to keep floating these things our way and we kept shooting them down at a don't worry about it, we're pot committed rate of ~$400k per incident, maybe people's blind faith in the military and politicians might be replaced with some rare curiosity, and maybe even displeasure! (Though: it's not like they have an alternative to vote for, but that too is not immutable, it only seems that way.)

Keeping people immersed in a complex narrative is a lot easier than one would think, but it is also a very tricky balancing act that can get upset by the weirdest things.

Personally, I'm all for it - anything that has the potential to wake up the American/Western public from their dream state is a good thing in my books, plus it makes for good entertainment.

Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by JohnBooty on Friday February 10, 2023 @08:03PM (#34748350)
Can you elaborate?

    while everything you say may be true, it is not broadly known
It's readily available public information. As far as "widely known," I guess that's true. Most people haven't really nerded out on the details of how pilots maintain combat readiness and how budgets work, but uh, your point?

    anything that has the potential to wake up the American/Western 
    public from their dream state is a good thing in my books
I'm not exactly the biggest fan of any government, but what specifically are you talking about here?

What is the "dream state" that these incursions might shatter?

Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by mistermann on Sunday February 12, 2023 @12:45PM (#34764911)
> It's readily available public information. As far as "widely known," I guess that's true.

It's even worse: even when people do ingest available information, they very often do it erroneously, forming a misunderstanding (without realizing it).

> Most people haven't really nerded out on the details of how pilots maintain combat readiness and how budgets work, but uh, your point?

Broadly: humanity runs mostly on untrue stories, and does not realize it (actually, there's a "it's even worse' here too).

>> anything that has the potential to wake up the American/Western public from their dream state is a good thing in my books

> I'm not exactly the biggest fan of any government, but what specifically are you talking about here?

Simplistically: people's understanding and trust in their government (abstract and concrete), and what is going on in general is highly erroneous, and not only do they not realize this, they believe the opposite. I consider this to be an extremely dangerous state of affairs, despite it having always been the case and "we're doing ok" nonetheless. Things often go "ok" for a very long time, and then suddenly start going "not ok", often without an obvious trigger.

> What is the "dream state" that these incursions might shatter?

The phenomena resulting from the combination of consciousness + culture + time, both individually and collectively.

You might be best served by filing this under "woo woo" though...but then again, you also might not - there's only one way to (possibly) find out!

Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by LarryMullins on Friday February 10, 2023 @05:50PM (#34747090)
> it seems like there are cheaper ways to cause the US to spend gobs of cash.

Yeah, the Mig-25 / F-15 thing comes to mind. Soviets develop a super secret jet, very big, very fast.. it must be very impressive fighter jet! America is spooked so tons of resources are poured into the F-15 to make the absolute best possible air superiority fighter jet they can, to counter this new Soviet threat.

Except then it turns out that the Mig-25 was never a fighter jet, it was an interceptor that was very fast in a straight line but not much more. So the US built an incredible air superiority fighter to counter a phantom of a jet that never really existed in the way America thought.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonnell_Douglas_F-15_Eagle#F...

Come to think of it, maybe China is going low-tech with balloons to avoid this dynamic?

Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by HeyLaughingBoy on Friday February 10, 2023 @07:15PM (#34747962)
> So the US built an incredible air superiority fighter to counter a phantom of a jet that never really existed in the way America thought.

Are you sure that's what really happened, or did a group of people in the Air Force want an air superiority fighter and use the Mig-25 as the excuse?

Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by LarryMullins on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:19PM (#34755933)
By all accounts I have read, the defection of Viktor Belenko with a Mig-25 really did change the way NATO understood the Mig-25.
Re:Live Briefing on Alaska Aerial Object Shoot-Down by somat on Friday February 10, 2023 @08:40PM (#34748649)
But it does not end there. The f-15 in turn spooked the soviets, and they put a bunch of money into the Su-27 program.