Re:Theory of Mind May Have Spontaneously Emerged in Large La...
by goatlover on Thursday February 09, 2023 @11:43PM
(#34735713)
Blind people still have bodies and other sensory perceptions to relate visual meaning to. Temple Grandin is a high functioning autist who describes how visual thinkers translate words into pictures, because they think pictorially. LLMs don't have any embodied, grounded contact with the world, so their only understanding can be statistical/symbolic pattern matching of text. Which isn't how language works for humans, since we use words for our experiences as social animals moving about and manipulating the world with our bodies.
As long as our minds pops out appropriate thoughts for the given context we don’t even think about the magic machinery behind the scenes that did that.
When queried about our thinking we are mostly creating a plausible story, not actually examining our own thinking.
Also, blind people can talk sensibly about many visual phenomena, having learned about them through language
I think the new LLM are giving us all so many wow’s, because “understanding” is the only kind of compression that actually works at the scale of the training data
I.e. representations are being created that reflect the actual functional, as well as associative or correlative, relations between concepts.